Skip to main content
Broadway with AJ and Sarah

Broadway with AJ and Sarah

By AJ Jaffari and Sarah Duarte

Join AJ and his theater partner in crime, Sarah, as they rate, review, and dive deep into the world of musical theater in their community! As members of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, AJ and Sarah will bring the best that the Bay Area theater scene has to offer with their hot takes on all the shows they see!
Available on
Amazon Music Logo
Apple Podcasts Logo
Castbox Logo
iHeartRadio Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Something Rotten at Hillbarn Theatre!

Broadway with AJ and SarahMay 01, 2024

00:00
54:40
Something Rotten at Hillbarn Theatre!

Something Rotten at Hillbarn Theatre!

We're heading back to the Hillbarn Theatre in Foster City to review their latest musical. The show runs now until May 12th and tickets can be purchased at hillbarntheatre.org! We also got to chat with Randy O'Hara (Director), Leslie Waggoner (Choreographer), Jad Bernardo (Music Director), Julio Chavez (Shakespeare), Jill Jacobs (Portia), Samantha Kenbrandt (Ensemble) and Nick Kenbrandt (Ensemble).
May 01, 202454:40
Anastasia at TMC Arts!

Anastasia at TMC Arts!

This week, we traveled northeast to the Douglas Morrison Theater and got to chat with Tori Speed (Anastasia) and Tommy Lassiter (Dimitri)!

Apr 24, 202446:50
Happy 1 Year Pod-versary!

Happy 1 Year Pod-versary!

This week, we're celebrating our 1 year of starting this podcast. We would like to thank everyone from the bottom of our hearts for following along on this wonderful journey. Here's a look back at some fun moments from this past season.

Apr 18, 202452:06
The Final All Shook Up recap!

The Final All Shook Up recap!

This week, we’re revisiting the predictions episode from January and wrapping up our favorite moments from All Shook Up at WVLO!
Apr 10, 202438:19
A Reunion with Lysander & Aunt Kathy!

A Reunion with Lysander & Aunt Kathy!

Join us this week for a special reunion episode with Lysander Abadia and his former home-ec teacher, who also happens to be Sarah’s Aunt Kathy!
Apr 05, 202444:56
A Mean Girls tour review!

A Mean Girls tour review!

This week, we’re discussing our thoughts on the latest musical to head into Broadway San Jose!
Mar 27, 202440:24
Legally Blonde at Foothill Music Theatre!

Legally Blonde at Foothill Music Theatre!

We’re seeing Legally Blonde again! But this time, we’re visiting Foothill College and we’re chatting with Rachelle (Elle) and Melissa (Brooke).
Mar 20, 202401:06:38
An All Shook Up guest review!

An All Shook Up guest review!

Join us on our opening week as we invite our pal, Bryan, to review what we’ve been working on the past few months! We’re also joined by Zack (Chad).
Mar 13, 202450:23
A Chicago review!

A Chicago review!

This week, we’re talking about our recent visit to Broadway San Jose to see the touring cast of Chicago! Get ready for our unfiltered thoughts!
Mar 06, 202429:43
A Jerry Springer Opera review!

A Jerry Springer Opera review!

Join us this week as we visit 3Below Theaters & Lounge to see the Jerry Springer Opera! We’re also joined post-show by Ric (Jerry Springer) and Jared (Diaper Boy)
Feb 28, 202456:43
A Mean Girls movie musical review!

A Mean Girls movie musical review!

This week, we’re breaking down the iconic movie-turned musical that went viral. What did everyone think of the latest Mean Girls musical movie adaption?
Feb 21, 202426:20
Rent at Hillbarn Theatre!

Rent at Hillbarn Theatre!

Another trip to see Rent but this time, it’s our first visit to Hillbarn in Foster City and we’re interviewing Sol (Joanne), Gabe (Choreographer), and Reed (Director)
Feb 14, 202401:01:24
Boeing Boeing at Coastal Repertory Theater!

Boeing Boeing at Coastal Repertory Theater!

Join us this week minus Sarah and with guest host Maddie as we break down the farce with a beautiful set!
Feb 08, 202428:38
All Shook Up predictions!

All Shook Up predictions!

Join us this week as we break the ice with our cast members during a magic 8 ball game of predictions!
Feb 07, 202442:27
A Little Night Music at South Bay Musical Theatre!

A Little Night Music at South Bay Musical Theatre!

This week, we’re reviewing the Sondheim piece often rarely seen and we’re chatting with director Walter M. Mayes and Dana Cordelia Morgan (Charlotte).
Jan 31, 202457:52
A Reunion with Bryan Ringsted!

A Reunion with Bryan Ringsted!

This week we’re sitting down with AJ’s former drama teacher from high school, Bryan. We’re chatting about some fun theater memories and play a fun game.
Jan 24, 202401:03:25
Legally Blonde at Tri-Valley Theater Company!

Legally Blonde at Tri-Valley Theater Company!

Join us as we talk with Austin, CJ and Tommy from the cast of Legally Blonde! Sadly, there was no time for a game but please enjoy a poorly worded question from your host, AJ!
Jan 17, 202441:41
Spelling Bee at Pintello Comedy Theater!

Spelling Bee at Pintello Comedy Theater!

We’re headed to a South Bay theater to see Spelling Bee and we’re chatting with CJ and Em who star as the only adults (mostly).
Jan 13, 202451:09
A Maestro review!

A Maestro review!

It’s our last episode of 2023 and we’re reviewing the latest Bradley Cooper film Maestro!
Dec 28, 202335:43
A Waitress musical movie review!

A Waitress musical movie review!

This week, we’re talking about the musical movie filmed live on stage!
Dec 13, 202332:19
White Christmas at Coastal Repertory Theater!

White Christmas at Coastal Repertory Theater!

A story time with Sarah segment you won’t want to miss! Hear our thoughts about our latest visit to the Half Moon Bay theater company.
Dec 06, 202339:13
The Games Afoot at City Lights!

The Games Afoot at City Lights!

It happened. We actually attended a straight play and enjoyed it!
Nov 30, 202337:24
Young Frankenstein at WVLO!

Young Frankenstein at WVLO!

This week, we went to see Young Frankenstein and got to chat with David Mister (Igor), Michael Frelier (Monster), and Allie Bailey (Director) about their experience with the show. Happy Thanksgiving!
Nov 22, 202346:34
A Wizard of Oz Party! With Mike and Stacey Reed

A Wizard of Oz Party! With Mike and Stacey Reed

This week, we’re chatting with husband and wife Mike and Stacey, about their recent star in Palo Alto Players’ The Wizard of Oz! Plus a fun theater-themed newlywed game!
Nov 16, 202352:31
Madame Sherry recap with Tressa!

Madame Sherry recap with Tressa!

We’re breaking down Sarah’s latest run at Lyrics Theater in Madame Sherry with director, Tressa!
Nov 09, 202322:44
A Sweeney Todd review! With Stacy Levin

A Sweeney Todd review! With Stacy Levin

This week, we’re chatting with Stacy from Sunnyvale Community Players on the latest production, Sweeney Todd!
Nov 01, 202350:53
A Disenchanted review!

A Disenchanted review!

This week, we visited 3Below Theaters & Lounge and are here to recap our thoughts on the Disney parody musical, Disenchanted!
Oct 25, 202342:13
A Theater Camp review!

A Theater Camp review!

Join us as we give our hot take on the recent theater themed film. Buy our merch! Link in bio on our Instagram to shop now.
Oct 18, 202336:46
A Hadestown review!

A Hadestown review!

This week, we’re breaking down our recent visit to Broadway San Jose when Hadestown made its way here!
Oct 11, 202343:51
A RENT party! With Justin Kerekes, Tyler Savin, and Nicole Roca

A RENT party! With Justin Kerekes, Tyler Savin, and Nicole Roca

Join us this week as we talk about our recent visit to South Bay Musical Theater to see Rent! We are joined by Justin (Mark), Tyler (Roger), and Nicole (Mauren) and discuss their favorite moments from the rehearsal process as well as a fun rent-themed game!
Oct 04, 202354:54
Another Kinky Boots review!

Another Kinky Boots review!

Join AJ and Sarah as they attend Kinky Boots at the Berkeley Playhouse!
Sep 27, 202332:34
A Little Mermaid party with Thomas Times and Sol Husband!

A Little Mermaid party with Thomas Times and Sol Husband!

Join us this week as we chat with Thomas (Sebastian) and Solana (Ariel) who are currently playing in the Sunnyvale Players’ production of The Little Mermaid! We discuss the process of putting together this iconic show and play a fun Mad Libs game where, spoiler alert, AJ sucks at!
Sep 20, 202354:23
A Matilda Party with Doug Santana, Brigitte Losey, and Randy Lee!

A Matilda Party with Doug Santana, Brigitte Losey, and Randy Lee!

This week we're joined by Doug (Trunchbull), Brigitte (Mrs. Wormwood), and Randy (Mr. Wormwood) as we talk about the Palo Alto Players production of Matilda! We discuss the process of creating the show, play a fun spelling game, and give our review of the opening night! If you'd still like to attend, the show runs until September 24th and you can still use our code MATPOD5 for $5 off your ticket price.
Sep 14, 202359:01
A 'Shakespeare In Love' Review!

A 'Shakespeare In Love' Review!

It happened. Sarah and I attended a straight play! Hear about our first visit to Silicon Valley Shakespeare and what's to come on the podcast in the next few weeks!
Sep 08, 202341:16
A Tina Turner Musical review!

A Tina Turner Musical review!

Join us this week with special guests Tressa and Andrew Mo! We discuss our hot take on the hit biopic-style musical that hit San Jose this week and play a fun trivia game to test our Tina knowledge. Use our code MATPOD5 for $5 off your tickets to see Matilda at the Palo Alto Players starting next week!
Sep 02, 202351:24
Bright Star with the long awaited Kris!

Bright Star with the long awaited Kris!

Join us this week for a special discussion with the man behind the distaste for theater, Kris! Did he enjoy Bright Star?
Aug 23, 202352:04
A Chat with Janie Scott! A Bay Area theater gem

A Chat with Janie Scott! A Bay Area theater gem

Join us this week for a fun chat with Janie Scott, known previously Gleason, for her work as a director, choreographer and performer. Use code MATPOD5 for $5 off ticket prices Matilda running at Palo Alto Players opening in September!
Aug 20, 202348:45
A Reunion with Robert Lopez from Starting Arts!

A Reunion with Robert Lopez from Starting Arts!

Join us this week for a special interview with Robert Lopez, AJ’s director from middle school days. Robert is most recently starring in TMC’s production of Bright Star the musical in Castro Valley.
Aug 11, 202358:23
A Beetlejuice review!

A Beetlejuice review!

This week we’re breaking down the hit musical Beetlejuice as it made its way to the Bay Area. Plus what’s to come on the next few episodes of the podcast!
Aug 04, 202333:46
Sarah finally gets to see Kinky Boots! Featuring Amber Smith

Sarah finally gets to see Kinky Boots! Featuring Amber Smith

We’re back and here to discuss Sarah’s take on Kinky Boots. We’re joined by AJ’s cast mate Amber Smith who plays Nicola. Catch Kinky Boots at City Lights Theater running until newly extended date, August 27th!
Jul 28, 202301:05:39
A Chat with Lisa… Mallette! From City Lights Theater Company

A Chat with Lisa… Mallette! From City Lights Theater Company

Join us for a sit down with City Lights Theater Company’s artistic director Lisa Mallette as we dish on Kinky Boots, what’s next for the future of the company and a fun Broadway-themed game!
Jul 19, 202343:27
Hunchback of Notre Dame at Cabrillo! Featuring Vinh, David and Juan
Jul 14, 202353:34
Double Feature! A review of Matilda and Falsettos

Double Feature! A review of Matilda and Falsettos

Join us for our hot take on the recent trips to SVCT and the Pear Theater! Definitely would say we’re excited to return to the Pear for another musical.
Jul 06, 202347:26
Sarah learns a new word... Again! Welcome Bart Perry!

Sarah learns a new word... Again! Welcome Bart Perry!

Today, join AJ and Sarah as they host Bart Perry (portraying Lola) from Kinky Boots at CLTC. Games were played, questions were asked, and words were learned! Kinky Boots opens July 15th and runs until August 20th.
Jun 21, 202301:09:58
AJ and Sarah take on the Tony’s

AJ and Sarah take on the Tony’s

We’re back and we’re talking about the biggest night for theater. AJ probably should’ve watched more than a few clips!
Jun 15, 202351:30
The Wizard of Oz at ACT: This was certainly not a straight play

The Wizard of Oz at ACT: This was certainly not a straight play

Join us for our weekly shenanigans while we discuss our recent visit to the ACT in San Francisco to see a modern reimagined version of Wizard of Oz! Needless to say, we were very impressed!
Jun 07, 202355:14
1776 Review with Sarah!

1776 Review with Sarah!

Join AJ and returning member Sarah as they dive into their recent theater visit to see the musical 1776, plus a catch-up on what’s to come for the podcast!
May 25, 202344:40
Attend the Tale of Sweeney Todd with Sarah and Tressa

Attend the Tale of Sweeney Todd with Sarah and Tressa

Join me as I sit down with Sarah and Tressa, both cast members in Sweeney Todd at South Valley Civic Theater. We discuss my favorite moments as an audience member, some backstage mishaps, and fond memories filled with laughter.
May 18, 202345:38
AJ, Sarah, and The Great First Episode of Broadway with AJ

AJ, Sarah, and The Great First Episode of Broadway with AJ

On this premiere episode of Broadway with AJ, hear AJ and Sarah’s hot take on their recent visit to the San Jose Playhouse to see Natasha, Pierre, and The Great Comet of 1812.
Apr 25, 202347:42