Skip to main content
Canonically Incorrect

Canonically Incorrect

By Canonically Incorrect

Hi, my name is Maya and I love fanfiction. Hi, my name is Sydney and I love talking about fanfiction with my friends. And we're Canonically Incorrect, your favorite fanfiction podcast! Every Friday, we tell you a story from the world of fan-made media. It could be us recounting fics we'd recently read, telling you the history behind your favorite fanfiction platforms, or interviewing fanfiction authors about their well-known works. Send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Castbox Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Episode 43: Here for the Vibes, Here for the Analysis (w/Into the Archives)

Canonically IncorrectFeb 18, 2022

00:00
53:30
Episode 119: Wattpad - The Good, The Bad, and The Fanfiction
May 08, 202401:16:04
Episode 118: Being in the Right Place At the Right Time (w/MarvellKya17)
May 03, 202401:00:41
Episode 117: Flashes of Fire
Mar 26, 202435:05
Episode 116: palm split with a flower with a flame
Mar 01, 202401:04:04
Episode 115: The Value of Doing Things Poorly (w/lavenderhatchet13)
Feb 16, 202401:06:50
Episode 114: G(et) T(he) F(uck) O(ut)
Feb 09, 202401:02:23
Episode 113: More Views. More Money.

Episode 113: More Views. More Money.

DISCLAIMER: Before we begin today's episode, we'd like to kindly ask everyone 17 and under to not listen. This episode is full of NSFW content not suitable for minors. We're sorry for the inconvenience, but we will be back next with another episode suitable for all. 

Do you all remember a certain chest that Sydney has stored under her bed? Do you remember what that chest was filled with? Well it's been over a year and Sydney has dragged that chest out from its hiding spot and has opened it for all (of age 18 and older). She's dug around, rummaged between items, and pulled out a camcorder. If you are do willing, you may sit down and relax as Sydney pops in the tap she has found inside. Maybe there will be happy home videos... or maybe there will be the nastiest porn you've ever seen between Castiel and Dean Winchester. As always, send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com

Support the author and give them a kudos over on AO3: More Views. More Money. by herbivoredinosaur

Thank you to our Patreons, AutumnalRiver and Rillie C., for your continued support!

Like us and what we do? Donate to help us do more fun things at ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ko-fi.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ or join our Patreon for bonus episodes, access to our community discord, and a chance to choose what we feature on the show! ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Patreon.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠⁠

Feb 02, 202401:05:14
Episode 112: Keeping Fandom and Work Separate (w/MildManneredMuse)
Jan 26, 202401:18:40
Episode 111: Pencil Pushers
Jan 19, 202442:46
Episode 110: The Request Revolution
Jan 12, 202447:02
Episode 109: The Muppet Episode
Dec 20, 202353:49
Episode 108: Operation Secret Santa
Dec 08, 202301:13:07
Episode 107: Sapphic, Feral, and Loose in a Fantasy World (w/top_me_daenerys)

Episode 107: Sapphic, Feral, and Loose in a Fantasy World (w/top_me_daenerys)

Fanfiction author top_me_daenerys (Marriage of Convience, wednesday’s children are full of woe, and The ghosts that we knew will flicker from view) joins Sydney to discuss how fanfiction, fandom, and sexuality intermix; the differences of being a F/F fanfiction writer and a M/M fanfiction writer; the joys of building upon and writing for an established fantasy world; and how the other aspects of her life (experience being a dungeon master, working towards her masters degree in a STEM field) have aided her writing. Plus, Sydney and Kenzie gush about Taylor Swift, her storytelling through song, and how she has impacted fanfiction authors from every corner of the internet. As always, send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com.

Check out Marriage of Convience, wednesday’s children are full of woe, and The ghosts that we knew will flicker from view, as well as all of top_me_daenerys's other fics on ⁠⁠⁠⁠Archive of Our Own⁠⁠⁠⁠.

Fic Recommendations: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠i see fire (i hope you remember me)⁠ by darkdisrepair⁠⁠, anachronism by ⁠chellethewriter, and I Can Hear Your Heartbeat by LesbihonestGuys.

Thank you to our Patreons, AutumnalRiver and Rillie C. for your continued support!

Like the episode? Like us and what we do? Donate to help us do more fun things at ⁠ko-fi.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠ or join our Patreon for bonus episodes, access to our community discord, and a chance to choose what we feature on the show! ⁠Patreon.com/canonicallyincorrect

Nov 24, 202301:15:11
Episode 106: The 2023 Game Awards
Nov 17, 202359:51
Episode 105: Peeta's Games
Nov 03, 202301:32:04
Episode 104: Mystery at the Mansion — A Canonically Incorrect Whodunit
Oct 20, 202348:17
Episode 103: Baldur's Gate 3 Dating Game
Oct 13, 202346:59
Episode 102: Pokémon Creepypastas to Tell in the Dark

Episode 102: Pokémon Creepypastas to Tell in the Dark

Pokémon has become a staple in every generation of child, but underneath that façade of cute, family-friendly content there's always been a dark and creepy underbelly. From disturbing Pokédex entries to Easter Eggs of ghosts and ghouls purposefully placed in game by game designers, the world of Pokémon has become ripe for horror lovers and fans of everything scary to go wild with terrifying fan theories, scary fanart (some by famous manga artist Gunji Ito), and spine-chilling Creepypastas. Creepypastas were once the scariest thing a child could read on the Internet, and while may not be cheesy and cringe in retrospect, there's something about those silly little stories that have such a special place in Sydney's heart. So mixing her love of Pokémon with her love to the macabre, Sydney's will tell two tales from the dark with the help of her friends Unown and Hypno. As always, send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com

Read along (at your own risk) to these Creepypastas: The Unownking’s Curse: A Pokémon Creepypasta and Hypno's Lullaby

Thank you to our Patreons, AutumnalRiver and Rillie C., for your continued support!

Like us and what we do? Donate to help us do more fun things at ⁠ko-fi.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠ or join our Patreon for bonus episodes, access to our community discord, and a chance to choose what we feature on the show! ⁠Patreon.com/canonicallyincorrect

Oct 06, 202301:12:52
Episode 101: Girls Just Want to Write Smut (w/MrsAckermanX)
Sep 22, 202301:06:40
Episode 100: A Tribute to AO3
Sep 15, 202351:22
Episode 99: Maya's Big Skyrim Storytime
Sep 09, 202325:01
Episode 98: Hashtag Soulmates
Sep 08, 202301:07:05
Episode 97: Romance with a Capital 'R' (w/sunshine_and_gunpowder)

Episode 97: Romance with a Capital 'R' (w/sunshine_and_gunpowder)

Aug 18, 202301:22:21
BONUS - Legend of Zelda: Smash or Pass
Aug 11, 202301:15:22
BONUS - The Ultimate Dungeons and Dragons Tournament
Aug 04, 202301:31:24
Episode 96: Give Me a Happy Ending or Give Me Death (w/HetaliaWall)
Jul 21, 202301:03:34
BONUS - Sydney and Maya's Top 5 Childhood Crushes
Jul 14, 202301:26:15
BONUS - Three Sunflowers
Jul 07, 202359:32
Episode 95: Canonically Incorrect: Into the Fanfictionverse
Jun 30, 202346:58
Episode 94: The Perks of Joining Fandom Later in Life (w/Rillie_Ann)

Episode 94: The Perks of Joining Fandom Later in Life (w/Rillie_Ann)

Fanfiction author Rillie_Ann (Little Yuji, Lavender and Honey, and Bittersweet Lightning) joins Sydney and Maya to discuss the joy of multi-shipping, what she feels she missed from not finding fandom at a young age, why she dislikes the amnesia trope, and celebrating the community and friendship that comes with fandom. As always, send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com.

Check out ⁠Little Yuji, Lavender and Honey, and Bittersweet Lightning, as well as all of Rillie_Ann's other fics on ⁠Archive of Our Own⁠.

Fic Recommendations: ⁠Say Yes by Purple_peony and NyQuil™ by useless_donut

Thank you to our Patreons, AutumnalRiver and Rillie C., for your continued support!

Like the episode? Like us and what we do? Donate to help us do more fun things at ⁠ko-fi.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠ or join our Patreon for bonus episodes, access to our community discord, and a chance to choose what we feature on the show! ⁠Patreon.com/canonicallyincorrect

Jun 16, 202301:00:22
Episode 93: What I'm Trying to Say is I Think I Love You Again
Jun 09, 202301:03:07
Episode 92: Ink Blots and Forget-Me-Nots
Jun 02, 202301:00:56
Episode 91: Say You Read Fanfiction Proudly (w/Uit_Het_Hart)
May 19, 202301:03:19
Episode 90: The "Totally Not Complicated" Legend of Zelda Timeline
May 12, 202301:20:33
Episode 89: A Thing of Vikings Part II
May 05, 202301:08:28
Episode 88: Delusional Y/N Authors (w/Mikamochii)

Episode 88: Delusional Y/N Authors (w/Mikamochii)

Fanfiction writer Mikamochii (skyfall, loving a monster is probably unconventional, and for this, you were born) joins Sydney and Maya to talk about loving the video game Undertale but not wanting to touch the newest addition Delta Rune, the revolution of Tumblr sexyman Sans, how to fight the stigma of writing fanfiction with a "cringy" character, and why being a Y/N author inherently makes you delusional (because that man would never love you). Plus, Sydney, Maya, and Mika reminisce on the summer of 2020 as being the worst time for their shared Y/N delusions. As always, send us your fic recommendations, or reach out if you are a fic author who would like to be interviewed in the future, at canonicallyincorrectpod@gmail.com.


Check out ⁠skyfall, loving a monster is probably unconventional, and for this, you were born, as well as all of Mikamochii's other fics on ⁠Archive of Our Own⁠.


Fic Recommendations: ⁠algernon by parsnipit, ⁠⁠When I'm Gone by KittyKittyBoBitty, and Can You Hear Me? by MelodyofChaos (Original and Discontinued/Rewrite and Ongoing)


Thank you to our Patreons, AutumnalRiver and Rillie C., for your continued support!


Like the episode? Like us and what we do? Donate to help us do more fun things at ⁠ko-fi.com/canonicallyincorrect⁠ or join our Patreon for bonus episodes, access to our community discord, and a chance to choose what we feature on the show! ⁠Patreon.com/canonicallyincorrect

Apr 21, 202301:04:18
Episode 87: Same Man I Was Before
Apr 15, 202353:58
Episode 86: Anne Rice and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Thing She Did to Fanfiction Writers
Apr 07, 202301:19:33
Episode 85: To Plan Or Not To Plan
Mar 31, 202354:52
Episode 84: The Incomparable Beauty of a Character Study (w/FairytalesofForever)
Mar 17, 202355:32
Episode 83: The Five Stages of Grief
Mar 10, 202301:21:38
Episode 82: Out of Time
Mar 03, 202301:22:44
Episode 81: The First Pioneers of Archive of Our Own (w/BrightneeBee)
Feb 17, 202301:01:32
Episode 80: TLDR? Tron
Feb 10, 202357:44
Episode 79: Nothing's Quite As Sweet
Feb 03, 202359:40
Episode 78: It's Not Going to be Right the First Time (w/SilentWanderlust)
Jan 27, 202358:51
Episode 77: The Past Remains
Jan 21, 202348:41
Episode 76: As Long As We Stay Together (If We Just Stay Together)

Episode 76: As Long As We Stay Together (If We Just Stay Together)

Jan 13, 202301:32:33
BONUS! Q&A Season 2 Finale
Dec 23, 202201:11:14
Episode 75: Surrender (Whenever You're Ready)
Dec 09, 202201:20:20