Skip to main content
Crime, Cults, & Coffee

Crime, Cults, & Coffee

By Brynne

A true crime/paranormal podcast feat. everything creepy. Grab your coffee and have a mourning with us. Hosted by Brynne Nicole
Available on
Google Podcasts Logo
Overcast Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Episode 13: "On a Scale From 1 to Nature Valley Granola Bar..."/ Jamie Silvonek

Crime, Cults, & CoffeeJan 01, 2021

00:00
01:08:05
Episode 157: "Friday the 13th”/ Rachel Mellon Skemp

Episode 157: "Friday the 13th”/ Rachel Mellon Skemp

Rachel Mellon Skemp was well-liked, thrived in school, & exuded positivity everywhere she went. Even with a tumultuous home life (at times), she seemed to have a glow about her. On January 31, 1996 — Rachel stayed home from school, only to mysteriously vanish by mid-day. Rachel has not been seen or heard from since. If you have any information regarding Rachel or her disappearance, please contact: • Bolingbrook PD: (630) 226-0600 • Bolingbrook Police Department Investigations Division: (630) 226-8620 • Crime Stoppers: (630) 378-4772 • Callers can also submit a web tip at bolingbrookcrimestoppers.org *These can be submitted anonymously* Sidenote: this week contains IMPORTANT INFORMATION regarding future episodes of Crime, Cults, & Coffee 🎃👻🖤 Not ghosting you, just on a temporary hiatus. Tata for now!
Oct 13, 202326:58
Episode 156: RE-RELEASE Slender Man

Episode 156: RE-RELEASE Slender Man

Spooky RE-RELEASE from last October 👻 Next week will come with a new episode, along with info going forward for when the Halloween babe is here 🦇 Thanks again for your understanding, listens, & support! IT’S SPOOKY SEASON GUYS & GHOULS!!! If you’ve been listening long enough, you know how much we love this time of the year. So to be super festive, we’re bringing back the eerie. This week we’re covering the story of Slender Man (aka Slendy) and the horrifying depictions that come along with him. Creature? Shadow? Human? How could a legend evolve into a murder plot of the most devious and disturbing kind? Listen in closely to find out… & maybe keep a light on. Sidenote: Happy Birthday to the lovely Mom (Sunday) and Happy ✨now 3✨ Year Anniversary to Crime, Cults, & Coffee (Monday)!
Oct 06, 202345:48
Episode 155: RE-RELEASE Mary Morris Murders

Episode 155: RE-RELEASE Mary Morris Murders

Thank you listeners for sticking it out with me as this week’s episode is another RE-RELEASE. Month 9 and I’m currently exhausted and trying to slow down a bit (since I haven’t up until now, along with running on fumes). I’m trying my best to still post something for you, even if that *something* isn’t a brand new episode!

In one of the most perplexing cases yet— this week we cover the story of the Mary Morris Murders. Two horrific crime scenes. Four days apart. Similar case details. Not to mention, two women with the SAME NAME. There are sooo many questions and not nearly enough answers.
Sep 29, 202352:10
Episode 154: RE-RELEASE Belle Gunness

Episode 154: RE-RELEASE Belle Gunness

Bare with me, as this week’s episode is a RE-RELEASE!

TRIGGER WARNING: This case includes gruesome crime scene details.

What do you get when you combine fire, murder, money, and a bat-shit crazy human with a pig farm? This. Episode. Let's take you back to the early 1900's... when searching for a husband in the personal ads was apparently a thing (at least in this story anyway), and people were going missing left and right across the U.S. If you've never heard of the crimes committed by Belle Gunness-- you're going to want to give this week's episode a listen. Atrocious doesn't even begin to describe it.
Sep 22, 202301:05:07
Episode 153: "Missed Opportunity”/ The Chameleon

Episode 153: "Missed Opportunity”/ The Chameleon

TRIGGER WARNING: Includes graphic detail, rape, and murder.

Peter Morin aka The Chameleon spent decades committing crimes... and 12 years (that we know of) taking the lives of others. Between living a transient lifestyle and going by a multitude of aliases, he evaded authorities and suspicion of certain crimes for years. Manipulative, cunning, and elusive -- he found ways to ensnare those around him, with no regards to human life. Listen in to hear not his story... but the story of the lives that were taken and/or affected by Morin, as well as his eventual capture.
Sep 15, 202330:56
Episode 152: RE-RELEASE Brian Shaffer

Episode 152: RE-RELEASE Brian Shaffer

It’s BABY SHOWER WEEK!!! 🦇🎃🤍This week’s episode is a RE-RELEASE & there’s been a couple requests for coverage of this case lately. So here it is again for those who missed it/haven’t gotten to it/didn’t realize we had an episode on it/want to re-hash Brian’s story again. CCC will be back with a new episode for next week’s podcast! In 2006– a night at the bar with friends, evolved into a massive mystery. The disappearance of Brian Shaffer is baffling, devastating, and ongoing. Where could this med student have gone? Was it foul play, an accident, or by choice? What happened after leaving the view of outdoor cameras? So many questions and not nearly enough answers. If you have any information regarding this case, please contact: — the Columbus Division of Police at 614-645-2358 — Stopcrime.org to submit a tip online According to the poster on fbi.gov you can also: — contact Detective Andre Edwards of the Columbus Police Department, Ohio at 614-645-4624 OR aedwards@columbuspolice.org — contact FBI ViCAP at (800) 634-4097 OR vicap@leo.gov
Sep 08, 202346:18
Episode 151: "Cleveland County's Sweetheart”/ Asha Degree

Episode 151: "Cleveland County's Sweetheart”/ Asha Degree

Asha Degree was a 9 year old girl, who was a star on the basketball court and had a loving and supportive family. February 14, 2000– she left her bed and disappeared into the rainy darkness. A timeline leading up to Asha’s disappearance since unfolded, clues were uncovered, and multiple questions arose. What happened to Asha in those early hours of Valentine’s morning & what truly motivated her to leave? If you have any information regarding the disappearance or whereabouts of Asha Degree, please contact: • The FBI: 704-672-6100 • Cleveland County Sheriff’s Office: 704-484-4788
Sep 01, 202333:26
Episode 150: "Or So The Legend Goes...”/ Urban Legends 4

Episode 150: "Or So The Legend Goes...”/ Urban Legends 4

Gather round’ the campfire 🔥 Let’s tell some urban legends! This episode covers the tales of 100 Steps Cemetery and Goatman. A strange ghostly figure with prophetic visions & a bloodthirsty creature hiding in the woods. Do you believe these stories… or are they really just legend?
Aug 25, 202327:09
Episode 149: RE-RELEASE Synanon Cult

Episode 149: RE-RELEASE Synanon Cult

This week’s episode is a RE-RELEASE because this week turned out to be very unpredictable and LOUD NOISES! This episode dives into the drug rehab turned cult. Synanon began in the late 50’s-early 60’s, and grew to be a nightmare for most that attended. From shaved heads, to attack therapy, to a fleet of 400 motorcycles and an airstrip, Synanon became very well known to California residents. But no cult starts out as a “cult”! Find out how this rehab program on the beach was later twisted into something horrific!
Aug 18, 202301:01:37
Episode 148: "True Life: I'm Addicted to Halloween Decor”/ Lindy Sue Biechler

Episode 148: "True Life: I'm Addicted to Halloween Decor”/ Lindy Sue Biechler

Lindy Sue Biechler was a newlywed, 19 year old girl, whose beautiful life was just beginning. After a day of work and errands, she returned home to her apartment— only to be met with an intruder of the worst kind. Investigators worked tirelessly from 1975-on, never giving up on Lindy or her case. This episode comes with a timeline of information that makes you want to scream from the rooftops (in good ways & bad). Listen in to hear Lindy’s story and the power of perseverance and DNA technology. If you have any information regarding Lindy’s murder or knew/witnessed Sinopoli during the 1975 timeframe, please contact: • Lancaster County Detective Christopher Erb: 717-299-8100
Aug 11, 202330:52
Episode 147: "It's Not Delivery... It's Detective Work”/ Kurt Sova
Aug 04, 202330:26
Episode 146: UPDATE/RE-RELEASE Samantha Lang & Kelly Nicole Godfrey Smith

Episode 146: UPDATE/RE-RELEASE Samantha Lang & Kelly Nicole Godfrey Smith

This week’s episode is a RE-RELEASE but also comes with a really recent UPDATE! Please take the time to listen (or re-listen) to these very important stories, while honoring these women and their families.

This episode covers two separate cases based out of the same Pennsylvania county. Samantha Lang was 22 years old when she was brutally murdered in March of 2007. Kelly Nicole Godfrey Smith was a young mother, whose life was tragically take in June of that same year. Both women need their stories told. Both women deserve justice.

If you have any information regarding the murder of Kelly Nicole Godfrey Smith:
— Call Lower Burrell Police Department at 724-339-4287
Jul 28, 202349:41
Episode 145: "Spirit of Halloween”/ Nancie Carolyn Walker

Episode 145: "Spirit of Halloween”/ Nancie Carolyn Walker

Nancie Carolyn Walker was a bright light & a beautiful soul, who LOVED to dance. When she disappeared in Chicago in 2003- the worst was assumed by her family, but her case was sadly not taken seriously. That was until weeks later, when nothing but foul play could be suspected. Nancie is one of the many black women who have met a tragic end, only to have her story bypassed in the media. The epidemic of violence, & in specific- violence against black and indigenous women- is very real and can be witnessed through Nancie’s story. If you have any information regarding the murder of Nancie Carolyn Walker, please contact: • Chicago PD: 312-746-8386 • FBI or FBI Violent Crimes Task Force: FBI.gov
Jul 21, 202329:40
Episode 144: "Potential Torrential”/ Lisa McVey Noland

Episode 144: "Potential Torrential”/ Lisa McVey Noland

TRIGGER WARNING: Contains mention of suicide, rape, and graphic details.

Lisa McVey Noland was 17 years old and had already endured a lifetime of trauma that (thankfully) many people never have to experience. In the early morning hours of November 3, 1984-- she was abducted on her way home from work. Listen in to this week's episode to hear Lisa's story of bravery, intelligence, and awe-inspiring action. As is the thunder in the background, Lisa is a FORCE to be reckoned with.
Jul 14, 202333:57
Episode 143: "Mother Nature is Mean Muggin”/ Elena de Hoyos

Episode 143: "Mother Nature is Mean Muggin”/ Elena de Hoyos

TRIGGER WARNING: Includes some graphic details. This week’s episode takes place in 1930’s Florida. Elena de Hoyos was a young woman, sadly diagnosed with an infectious killer of that time— Tuberculosis. Through this ailment, she soon met a man that believed to have the cure for her… as well as an obsession that ran deep. Listen in to hear her story and what progressed throughout her life & into her afterlife.
Jul 07, 202328:34
Episode 142: "Twilight Saga”/ Haunted Places 10

Episode 142: "Twilight Saga”/ Haunted Places 10

Edward and Bella will not be making a cameo in this episode, but the places being discussed are pretty epic in their own ways. In this 10th haunted places episode, the historical info and hauntings of 2 spooky locations are discussed. Listen to this episode for stories about “Carl Beck House” and “Fairmont Banff Springs Hotel”. Happy Hauntings!
Jun 30, 202335:40
Episode 141: "Hot Damn!”/ The Loveland Frogman and Flatwoods Monster

Episode 141: "Hot Damn!”/ The Loveland Frogman and Flatwoods Monster

Let’s talk about CRYPTIDS! This might be the first episode covering strictly this genre. Can’t remember at this point… but it’s super exciting and really overdue either way! Who doesn’t want to hear about a strange creature that might be your own local legend?! This week’s episode contains information about The Loveland Frogman and the Flatwoods Monster— enjoy!
Jun 23, 202333:19
Episode 140: "Bittersweet”/ The Clouse Family

Episode 140: "Bittersweet”/ The Clouse Family

In the summer of 1980– Dean Clouse, Tina Linn Clouse, & their baby Holly Marie, all picked up to move to Texas. By October 1980, the family completely vanished. Decades passed before any answers were found… & within those answers developed even stranger questions. Listen in, spread their story, & give some praise to genetic genealogy! If you have any information regarding the murders of Dean and Tina Linn Clouse please contact: • The Texas Attorney General's Cold Case and Missing Persons Unit at coldcaseunit@oag.texas.gov OR • Contact Sgt. Rachel Kading at coldcaseunit@oag.texas.gov or 512-936-0742
Jun 16, 202330:38
Episode 139: "This is Not a Drill”/ Jason Landry

Episode 139: "This is Not a Drill”/ Jason Landry

A drive to his parents’ home for the holidays, soon turned into an ongoing mystery. December 13, 2020– Jason Landry left his apartment in San Marcos, Texas & hasn’t been seen since. His car (among other items) were found only hours after he started his journey… but where was Jason?! Searches took place and theories arose, but none have brought him back to his family. If you have any information on Jason Landry or this case contact: • The Caldwell Co. Sheriff’s Office at 512-398-6777 • AG Cold Case Unit at 512-936-0742 • You can also give info via email at Coldcaseunit@oag.Texas.gov
Jun 09, 202330:56
Episode 138: RE-RELEASE Reading with Medium Laura Cifaldi - Blake Chappell
Jun 02, 202301:08:44
Episode 137: "Intergalactic Planetary”/ O'Hare International and Westall UFO Incidents

Episode 137: "Intergalactic Planetary”/ O'Hare International and Westall UFO Incidents

Most people love a good UFO sighting story… or do they?! This week’s episode includes two different sightings, decades and continents apart. Even so, similarities can be found in the witness accounts and some details are unbelievable to this day! Tune in to hear the stories of the O’Hare International Airport UFO Sighting and The 1966 Westall UFO Incident aka The Melbourne 350. 🛸
May 26, 202333:16
Episode 136: "Uhhuh Honey”/ Mee Kuen (Deborah) Chong

Episode 136: "Uhhuh Honey”/ Mee Kuen (Deborah) Chong

Mee Kuen Chong, who also went by Deborah, was known for her kindness and giving nature. In 2021, she had been living in London for around 30 years and had recently had some mental health setbacks. Luckily she had her religion, as well as a friend she could turn to, to help with her spiritual healing. June of that same year, Deborah suddenly and inexplicably vanished. When the truth emerged, it was not only unimaginable— but encompassed in evil.
May 19, 202331:13
Episode 135: "Spice Up Your Life”/ Eliza Fletcher

Episode 135: "Spice Up Your Life”/ Eliza Fletcher

TRIGGER WARNING: This case includes mention of rape.

On September 2, 2022- a daily routine, turned into a nightmare. That morning Eliza Fletcher went on a run, only to never return home. With a swift response from her family, investigators jumping into action, and surveillance footage- the truth of what had happened to Eliza quickly unraveled.
May 12, 202328:23
Episode 134: "Short & Sweet”/ The Wesson Vampire Clan

Episode 134: "Short & Sweet”/ The Wesson Vampire Clan

TRIGGER WARNING: This case includes physical, sexual, emotional, and mental abuse (including that of children), incest, & murder. In March 2004, not only did a mass murder take place in Fresno, California… but it brought attention to the horrors that had been occurring within one household. The Wessons’ had endured abuse, brainwashing, & trauma from one man for years. Some for their entire lives. This man was their husband/father/grandfather and he had created a cult right within his own family… deeming himself their master. Listen in to hear the story of the Wesson Clan, as well as an eerie listener story!
May 05, 202330:16
Episode 133: "Adult Diapers or Squeamish Suits”/ Urban Legends 3

Episode 133: "Adult Diapers or Squeamish Suits”/ Urban Legends 3

URBAN LEGENDS Part 3 coming right up! This episode covers the tales of Mercy Brown and “The Elevator Game”. Bloodsucking, alternate dimension, shake-you-to-the-core, creepiness in this one. Do you believe these stories… or are they really just legend?
Apr 28, 202349:37
Episode 132: "Vibrant Butterfly”/ Miya Marcano

Episode 132: "Vibrant Butterfly”/ Miya Marcano

Miya Marcano was a 19 year old girl in her 2nd year of college. She was living in an apartment in Orlando, Florida, working a steady job, & about to take a trip to visit family. But when her mom hadn’t heard from her & she missed her flight… her family immediately suspected that something was terribly wrong. They’d come to find out that Miya had vanished & within days, a timeline would begin to emerge with what had happened. Foundation Website: miyamarcanofdn.com Miya’s Law/Petition/Donation Info: https://miyamarcanofdn.com/miyaslaw/
Apr 21, 202332:37
Episode 131: "Weather Induced”/ Courtney Owens and Markeisha Stone

Episode 131: "Weather Induced”/ Courtney Owens and Markeisha Stone

Courtney Owens and Markeisha Stone were both in their early 30’s and living full lives. Courtney, an entrepreneur, owned her own used car dealership in Georgia. Markeisha was a mother to 4 kids and extremely dedicated to keeping them safe in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. In 2022– both of these women’s lives would be horrifically taken & in disturbingly similar ways. If you have any information in regards to the whereabouts of the suspect or Courtney’s case please contact: • Gwinnett County police at 770-513-5300 • OR you can remain anonymous by contacting Crime Stoppers at 404-577-TIPS (8477) • You can also go to www.stopcrimeATL.com Courtney’s GoFundMe: https://www.gofundme.com/f/the-queen-s-final-call Markeisha’s GoFundMe: https://www.gofundme.com/f/help-for-a-young-mother-taken-too-soon?utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link_all&utm_source=customer
Apr 14, 202331:26
Episode 130: "I'm Fuming”/ Sarah Everard

Episode 130: "I'm Fuming”/ Sarah Everard

Sarah Everard was walking home from a friend’s home, heading back to her house in Brixton Hill, England. It was March 3, 2021… & she suddenly disappeared into the night. The truth would soon emerge about what happened to Sarah— most of it eerily (& thankfully) caught on CCTV footage. A suspect would also be brought out of the darkness… & with him came disturbing revelations.
Apr 07, 202337:49
Episode 129: "But I Digress”/ Ellen Greenberg
Mar 31, 202333:50
Episode 128: "Very Sweeney Todd”/ The Bender Family

Episode 128: "Very Sweeney Todd”/ The Bender Family

It’s the 1870’s and a family of four just moved to Labette County, Kansas. The Benders acquired land and built themselves a homestead. Not only that, but they provide travelers with a place to rest, eat, & buy dry goods. But is everything as picture perfect as it seems? From 1871-1873 bodies started turning up and people continued to disappear. What was happening and were the Benders next… or were they the problem?
Mar 24, 202345:09
Episode 127: "As Mr. Beans Says”/ Texarkana Moonlight Murders

Episode 127: "As Mr. Beans Says”/ Texarkana Moonlight Murders

A Lovers’ Lane was meant to be an ideal location for frisky teens, starstruck lovers, or a quick hanky panky back in the day. However, due to the isolation— Lovers’ Lanes sadly also became hubs for crime and murder. The Texarkana Moonlight Murders aka “The Phantom Killer” was a string of such, that occurred over a 10 week period in 1946. Innocent lives left traumatized or taken, during vulnerable and intimate moments. Who would do such a thing and why?
Mar 17, 202344:05
Episode 126: "Hopefully”/ Elizabeth Salgado & Miriam Figueroa

Episode 126: "Hopefully”/ Elizabeth Salgado & Miriam Figueroa

Elizabeth Salgado had temporarily moved to the US from Mexico, with hopes of furthering her education. She had been in Utah for less than a month, when she suddenly disappeared. Years later, remains were found and sadly identified as Elizabeth. So many questions surrounded what happened to her & more arose when her aunt Miriam Figueroa went missing years later… Anyone with information regarding Elizabeth Elena Laguna Salgado’s case please contact: • The Investigations Department of the Utah County Sheriff’s office (801) 851-4010 • The WE HELP THE MISSING -TIP LINE (866) 660-4025 Anyone with information regarding Miriam Judith Salgado Figueroa’s case please contact: • The Washington County Sheriff’s Office (435) 656-6644
Mar 10, 202335:16
Episode 125: Reading with Medium Laura Cifaldi - Bianca Devins

Episode 125: Reading with Medium Laura Cifaldi - Bianca Devins

This week we welcome back Crime, Cults, & Coffee’s resident medium— Laura Cifaldi. Many of you may remember her from previous episodes, in which she connected with loved ones from a few cases we had covered. In this episode, she will be connecting with Bianca Devins— diving into a reading with Bianca’s mom, Kim. If you want to acquaint or reacquaint yourself with Bianca’s story prior to this episode, you can go back and listen to Episode 5 of our podcast. Thank you so much to Kim for always being so willing to come on to our podcast & for being open to a reading with Laura. We hope our listeners will contribute to carrying on Bianca’s legacy through her law & dire changes that need to be made 💗 CALL TO ACTION: Help with Bianca’s Law: • Contact your representatives in Congress and Senate • State that there needs to be changes to Section 230– which provides legal cover for companies that facilitate illicit content on the internet • State that you would like Bianca’s Law passed federally! • ALSO— sign this petition— https://www.change.org/p/bianca-s-law-stop-the-spread-of-violent-and-graphic-images-on-the-internet?utm_content=cl_sharecopy_23184431_en-US%3A4&recruiter=21758495&recruited_by_id=f39336f0-86dd-0130-133f-3c764e048845&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=copylink&utm_campaign=psf_combo_share_initial&utm_term=tap_basic_share&fbclid=PAAaZSk-Bv1CqCaKHPYa4D9JPCkmD2oicn5sp4rhoz5ebNqHXOHBx7985TjVE Info for our Medium Laura: Facebook— Laura Cifaldi: New Jersey Medium Instagram— @laura_cifaldi Website— http://lauracifaldinewjerseymedium.com/
Mar 03, 202301:04:05
Episode 124: "A Big Announcement”/ Rita Curran

Episode 124: "A Big Announcement”/ Rita Curran

Rita Curran was a 2nd grade teacher, with so many things to look forward to. In the summer of 1971, she had recently moved out on her own & was taking grad courses. One July night, Rita’s life was violently taken. 52 years passed without answers… until now. Make sure to also tune in this week for a very important announcement regarding our podcast.
Feb 24, 202339:38
Episode 123: "Scream Truck”/ Sherman Sizemore & Raudha Athif

Episode 123: "Scream Truck”/ Sherman Sizemore & Raudha Athif

TRIGGER WARNING: Cases contain suicide and/or suspicion of suicide.

This episode contains two cases of both shocking and devastating nature. Sherman Sizemore’s life took a turn for the worst after he went in for a routine surgery in 2006. His family became concerned after 73-year-old Sherman abruptly began showing behavior changes and alarming mannerisms. Raudha Athif was well liked and well known— not only in her community, but internationally. Becoming known as the “Maldivian girl with aqua blue eyes” was just the start of the incredible things that Raudha had ahead of her. Sad to say it, but both of these cases will most likely leave you scratching your head, wanting to know more.
Feb 17, 202342:55
Episode 122: "Red Flag”/ Gladys Ricart & Christe Chen

Episode 122: "Red Flag”/ Gladys Ricart & Christe Chen

This week we covered two separate stories discussing cases that involved domestic violence. Gladys Ricart was about to be married when her life was horrifically taken. Christe Chen was on her honeymoon when the unexpected happened. Both women were supposed to be experiencing some of the happiest moments of their lives, when that was viciously taken from them. This week’s episode also contains a spooky listener story.


The GoFundMe mentioned in this episode has now closed. A Memorial Fund at Parkview Community Federal Credit Union has been opened for fallen Officer Sean Sluganski— his family will receive 100% of the donations. Checks may be made payable to:

SEAN SLUGANSKI MEMORIAL FUND,
CARE OF PARKVIEW COMMUNITY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION
2100 EDEN PARK BLVD.,
MCKEESPORT, PA 15132
Feb 10, 202350:18
Episode 121: "Stfu & Tell Me a Story”/ Savannah Spurlock

Episode 121: "Stfu & Tell Me a Story”/ Savannah Spurlock

A vivacious, young mother of 4 went missing after a well deserved night out in Kentucky. Many searches took place, as people wondered where Savannah Spurlock could be. Six months passed, before Savannah’s lifeless body was discovered. Listen in as we discuss the details of this case, followed by two mini listener stories from Brynne.
Feb 03, 202355:01
Episode 120: "Hellfire Club”/ Haunted Places 9

Episode 120: "Hellfire Club”/ Haunted Places 9

Raise your hand if you wish this episode included an Eddie Munson cameo 🙋🏻‍♀️ Sadly not, but we still have some pretty creepy hauntings headed your way! One of which includes a Hellfire Club… but probably not the one you’re thinking of. In our 9th haunted places episode (bitchin’!) we delve into the historical info and hauntings of 4 spooky locations, that were chosen unbeknownst to the other. Listen to this episode for stories about “Montpelier Hill and Killakee Stewards House”, “Leap Castle”, “Monte Cristo Homestead”, and “Dock Street Theatre”.
Jan 27, 202301:07:22
Episode 119: "Pink Henout Room”/ Elmer DeBoer/Petric Family

Episode 119: "Pink Henout Room”/ Elmer DeBoer/Petric Family

In this week’s episode, we covered two cases— the case of Elmer DeBoer and another of the Petric family. Elmer was a 38-year-old, married father of 3 in Michigan. Mark and Susan Petric were also parents to 3 children, in a loving home in Ohio. Both Elmer and the Petric’s were living their lives, doing ordinary day-to-day things when the unexpected happened. Although these stories are vastly different, they contain some similarities… the biggest being that you never really know who you can trust & what horrors people can truly be capable of.
Jan 20, 202345:36
Episode 118: "Call to Action”/ Jennifer Farber Dulos

Episode 118: "Call to Action”/ Jennifer Farber Dulos

The morning of May 24, 2019– Jennifer Farber Dulos dropped her kids off at school and had an afternoon of plans ahead of her. Unfortunately, appointments were not kept and calls went unanswered. She had seemingly vanished into thin air. The investigation that followed soon brought horrifying realizations that something terrible had happened to Jennifer. But where was she and who was to blame? If you have any information regarding this case please contact: CONNECTICUT STATE POLICE INFO WESTERN DISTRICT HQ • TEL: (860) 626-7975 • MAJOR CRIME UNIT: (860) 626-7975 (800) 203-000 WEBSITE: https://portal.ct.gov/DESPP/Division-of-State-Police/_old/Connecticut-State-Police-Troops-and-Districts NEW CANAAN POLICE DEPT • (203) 594-3500 • http://newcanaanpolice.org CALL TO ACTION: Help with Bianca’s Law: • Contact your representatives in Congress and Senate • State that there needs to be changes to Section 230– which provides legal cover for companies that facilitate illicit content on the internet • State that you would like Bianca’s Law passed federally! • ALSO— sign this petition— https://www.change.org/p/bianca-s-law-stop-the-spread-of-violent-and-graphic-images-on-the-internet?utm_content=cl_sharecopy_23184431_en-US%3A4&recruiter=21758495&recruited_by_id=f39336f0-86dd-0130-133f-3c764e048845&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=copylink&utm_campaign=psf_combo_share_initial&utm_term=tap_basic_share&fbclid=PAAaZSk-Bv1CqCaKHPYa4D9JPCkmD2oicn5sp4rhoz5ebNqHXOHBx7985TjVE
Jan 13, 202352:50
Episode 117: "Potstickers and Orange Juice”/ Heather Elvis
Jan 06, 202344:48
Episode 116: "WWE Throwdown”/ Krampus & Grýla

Episode 116: "WWE Throwdown”/ Krampus & Grýla

Better late than never, right? The holiday season isn’t over yet! This week we decided to dip our toes into the wonderful world of Christmas folklore. Watch out though— these aren’t tales sprinkled with sugar plum fairies or magical reindeer. The stories of Krampus and Grýla are filled with dark humor & grim details.
Dec 30, 202250:26
Episode 115: "Dedicated to Boo”/ Shanquella Robinson

Episode 115: "Dedicated to Boo”/ Shanquella Robinson

TRIGGER WARNING: Case contains violent physical abuse. Listener story contains domestic violence. Shanquella “Quella” Robinson was a 25 year old woman who was described as charming and strong. Not only that, but she was a super savvy businesswoman- with lots of talent in the profession she was in. In October 2022, Quella embarked on a trip to Mexico with a friend and some acquaintances. This trip would soon become something that she could have never imagined. This week’s episode also contains a listener story. Please note that both stories are extremely heavy, but important to tell. Quella’s GoFundMe: https://www.gofundme.com/f/shanquella-robinson-funeral-services?utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwAR0I3LlZ1mlkl5h17tsrdfXy32C9N7UWjyP1DuuE9HtaL04n0GYcnAkQ-BQ Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) National Suicide Hotline: 988
Dec 23, 202250:27
Episode 114: "Romaine the Farmer”/ Ken McElroy

Episode 114: "Romaine the Farmer”/ Ken McElroy

What became a case of whodunit, also came with the question “who was the victim & who was the criminal”? Ken McElroy was known as “the town bully”, although it went WAY further than that. In 1981, the townspeople of Skidmore, Missouri had finally had enough. Fearful and feeling the justice system had failed them… they decided to face their problem head-on.
Dec 16, 202249:59
Episode 113: Reading with Medium Laura Cifaldi - Blake Chappell

Episode 113: Reading with Medium Laura Cifaldi - Blake Chappell

This week we welcome back Crime, Cults, & Coffee’s resident medium— Laura Cifaldi. Many of you may remember her from previous episodes, in which she connected with loved ones from a few cases we had covered. In this episode, she will be connecting with Blake Chappell— diving into a reading with Blake’s mom, Melissa. If you want to acquaint or reacquaint yourself with Blake’s story prior to this episode, you can go back and listen to Episode 96 of our podcast. Thank you so much to Melissa for being so beyond open during this process with Laura. You’re such an incredible person. We admire you & are so lucky to know you! We can’t wait for the day that there is #JusticeforBlake ❤️ If you have any information regarding the murder of Blake Chappell: — Contact CrimeStoppers of Greater Atlanta at (404) 577-TIPS (8477) — OR the Newnan Police Department's Tip Line at (770) 254-2350 — Send your tip in an email to unsolvedhomicide@cityofnewnan.org Info for our Medium Laura: Facebook— Laura Cifaldi: New Jersey Medium Instagram— @laura_cifaldi Website— http://lauracifaldinewjerseymedium.com/
Dec 09, 202201:06:33
Episode 112: "Move it Football Head”/ Hudson Valley UFOs

Episode 112: "Move it Football Head”/ Hudson Valley UFOs

Paranormal experiences, cryptids, unsolved mysteries. Hudson Valley, New York is known to be a hub for many things. Between 1982-1986 it added manyyyy UFO sightings to the list. Listen in this week as we share some details about what was seen, as well as a handful of eyewitness experiences. Like one observer had stated, you too might leave saying “Whoa! Wait a minute here”…
Dec 02, 202252:50
Episode 111: "Brisk”/ Luke Stout

Episode 111: "Brisk”/ Luke Stout

What would you do if your loved one left the house & just completely vanished into thin air? In July 2012, Luke Stout’s family faced just that. When he didn’t return as planned, Luke’s mom and brothers sprang into action … looking for anything to tell them where he was. 10 years have passed and Luke is still missing. If you have any information regarding this case please contact: — WV state police at 304-473-4200 — Anonymous tip line: 304-473-1001 — Case #: 3220-14004 — Submit an anonymous tip at www.wvsp.gov
Nov 25, 202242:38
Episode 110: "Twilight Zone Spiral”/ Ashley Reeves

Episode 110: "Twilight Zone Spiral”/ Ashley Reeves

In 2006, Ashley Reeves disappeared from what was supposed to be a simple night of set plans. When she did not return, she was immediately reported missing by her family. What was to come was expected by no one. Listen in to hear a story of horror, strength, & badassery. This episode also includes some listener stories of our own.
Nov 18, 202249:11
Episode 109: "Cocoon”/ The Death House Landlady

Episode 109: "Cocoon”/ The Death House Landlady

This week we were forced to stray against our typical procedure for covering a case. This episode is saturated with pieces of the perp and the pure evil that grew within her. A chameleon of sorts- she blended, shifted, & morphed into what was needed to complete her crimes, until she was ultimately caught. Living proof that you can’t always judge a book by its cover. Most importantly though— we want to honor the lives taken, especially since media coverage did not sway towards the victims’ backgrounds in this case. Rest in Peace Everson Gillmouth, Ruth Munroe, Leona Carpenter, Alvaro “Bert” Gonzales Montoya, Dorothy Miller, Benjamin Fink, James Gallop, Vera Faye Martin, and Betty Palmer. You deserved love & care in this life & we hope you’ve found it in your next. ❤️
Nov 11, 202253:57
Episode 108: "Cloak of Darkness”/ Napa Halloween Murders

Episode 108: "Cloak of Darkness”/ Napa Halloween Murders

In 2004, Halloween turned tragic when 2 brutal murders shocked the city of Napa. Adriane Insogna and Leslie Mazarra were taken from the lives that they had started for themselves. Before that night, the safe community hadn’t dealt with a homicide in years. They were left with devastation and the constant fear of who did it and why. Was it a neighbor, a friend, a stranger… & why?
Nov 04, 202255:21