The Dissidents
By The Dissidents
The DissidentsJan 13, 2022
S4 E11 | An Ounce of Prevention: Overestimated Harm Motivates Science Censorship
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth talk about trends in the censorship of scientific results. Recent research suggests one explanation for censorship behavior is misguided hyper-concern for others reactions. Scientific findings were rated as potentially harmful, and less beneficial, if they were controversial or confusing. We discuss the implications for the marketplace of ideas and scientific inquiry in the current socio political environment. Biased cost-benefit analyses can undermine the advancement of research and influence funding decisions. Hypervigilant concerns may fuel academic cancellation campaigns, paper and presentation rejections, and journal article retractions.
Podcast notes:
Clark, C. J., Graso, M., Redstone, I., & Tetlock, P. E. (2023). Harm Hypervigilance in Public Reactions to Scientific Evidence. Psychological Science, 34(7), 834–848.
Legacies of Black Pioneers: The Problem with Black Excellence with Ada Akpala
In this series of the Dissidents Podcast, Legacies of Black Pioneers, we speak with Ada Akpala of the Equiano Project on her problem with the term “black excellence”. Co-hosts, Winkfield Twyman, Jr. & Jennifer Richmond speak often of black resilience and triumph in their book, Letters in Black and White. After reading Ada's piece, My Problem with the Term Black Excellence, Wink sent her a note saying, "Jen has used the phrase "black excellence" in a recent tweet. I have devoted a month to exploring Pioneer Black Lawyers. Maybe, Jen and I missed the mark..."
We talk with Ada about the limitations of a well-intended phrase, black excellence. Does the phrase frame blackness in a negative light? Are there circumstances where black excellence conveys a constructive and positive good? Our discussion takes us from London to Virginia and Nigeria. Does black excellence make sense in a world containing over 1 billion people of Sub-Saharan descent? The question deserves more than a yes or a no answer. Enjoy a thoughtful conversation about a word many take for granted, black excellence.
Sign up on Circle to be a part of our live events and to join the conversations, and visit our website to sign up for our monthly newsletter to keep in the loop of all our new offerings.
Resources:
My Problem with the Term Black Excellence, Ada Akpala
Letters in Black and White, Winkfield Twyman, Jr & Jennifer Richmond
The Problem with 'Black Community', Ada Akpala on the Patience Xina podcast
S4 E10 | Jew-Jitsu with Dmitri Shufutinsky
In this week's podcast, Mike Burke meets with Jewish intellectual Dmitri Shufutinsky to discuss his upcoming book, "Jew-Jitsu". The conversation ranges across a number of topics, including how to identify and push back against a worryingly widespread and apparently growing antisemitism and historic illiteracy.
Resources:Neo-Confederacy & Palestinian Ultranationalism: How Prejudice is Justified Through the Myth of “Lost Civilization",Dmitri Shufutinsky
The Legacies of Black Pioneers: Daniel Brown
Welcome to our the new monthly series of the Dissidents Podcast on the legacies of black pioneers, brought to you by the Black Institute of Liberal Values (a joint project of Free Black Thought and the Institute for Liberal Values). In this episode, Winkfield Twyman, Jr & Jennifer Richmond, speak with Mark Brown on his common cousin with Wink, Daniel Brown. According to Wink, who writes of Daniel often in his book with Jen, Letters in Black and White, Daniel was a “founding father” for his family.
Mark, Wink and Jen talk about the relevance of genealogy for seeing each other as “Old Americans”, the role of faith in this mission, the possibility of “Post-Traumatic Slave Syndrome”, and the curative effects of narrative therapy and writing for coming together across the color line.
Follow us on Circle for more resources and materials on black pioneers in American history.
Podcast Resources:
Letters in Black and White: A New Correspondence on Race in America, Jennifer Richmond & Winkfield Twyman, Jr.
Find out more about the book on Truth in Between
The Dead Hand of Daniel Brown, Jennifer Richmond & Winkfield Twyman, Jr.
On the Road to Oak Lawn, Winkfield Twyman, Jr.
Greatness as Character, Winkfield Twyman, Jr.
A Race Story, Winkfield Twyman, Jr.
Find other resources, including Wink’s Pioneering Black Lawyers, on the Black Institute for Liberal Values on Circle.
S4 E9 | Self-Righteous Foolishness? A Look at Moral Protests
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth discuss an article that outlines some of the reasons we might choose to quietly or more openly protest wrongdoing within our organizations. It often seems futile to stay in a partially corrupt institution, even in an attempt to influence reform, but is it really preferable to resign in protest when the move is unlikely to have an impact? Can we recognize our own motivations for protest, or are we hopelessly biased in that assessment? We discuss these ideas in the context of contemporary culture and events, including criticism of college campus leaders.
Podcast notes:
Hill Jr, T. E. (1979). Symbolic protest and calculated silence. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 9, 83–102.
S4 E8 | She's Got the Look: Perspectives on Sexism and Career Motivation
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth discuss a recent journal article about reminders of bias. The authors found that women who read about sexism tended to report lower achievement expectations and career motivation. Our perspectives and interpretations diverge somewhat from that of the authors. We evaluate the study design, findings, and implications through the lens of cancel culture, and consider what a similar study on reminders of racism might reveal.
Podcast Notes:
Doolaard, F. T., Lelieveld, G., Noordewier, M. K., Beest, I., & Dijk, E. (2022). How information on sexism may increase women’s perceptions of being excluded, threaten fundamental needs, and lower career motivation. European Journal of Social Psychology, 52, 405-419.
The Legacies of Black Pioneers: Lemuel Haynes
Welcome to our the first episode of our monthly series of the Dissidents Podcast on the legacies of black pioneers, brought to you by the Black Institute of Liberal Values (a joint project of Free Black Thought and the Institute for Liberal Values). In this inaugural episode, Winkfield Twyman, Jr & Jennifer Richmond, speak with Bill Paine and Tom Miller, two descendants of the first ordained black minister, Lemuel Haynes. Jen & Wink talk about what it means for people to come together across the color line in celebration of pioneering ancestors and in community as “Old Americans”.
Lemuel Haynes Resources:
Sketches of the Life and Character of the Rev. Lemuel Haynes, for Many Years Pastor of a Church in Rutland, and Late in Granville, New York. Timothy Mather Cooley. Publisher: John S. Taylor, NY. 1839
Black Puritan, Black Republican The Life and Thought of Lemuel Haynes, 1753-1833. John Saillant. Oxford University Press, 2003
Lemuel Haynes, a bio-bibliography. Richard Newman. Lambeth, Press, NY. 1984
Black preacher to white America : the collected writings of Lemuel Haynes, 1774-1833 / edited by Richard Newman; introduction by Helen MacLam ; preface by Mechal Sobel.
Haynes, Lemuel, 1753-1833.
Brooklyn, N.Y. : Carlson Pub., 1989
Liberty Further Extended-https://www.jstor.org/stable/1919529
John Saillant SEA Scholar of the Month June, 2023 https://www.societyofearlyamericanists.org/whats-new-announcements/sea-scholar-of-the-month-june-2023-john-saillant
https://www.jstor.org/stable/365942 "Not Only Extreme Poverty, but the Worst Kind of Orphanage": Lemuel Haynes and the Boundaries of Racial Tolerance on the Yankee Frontier, 1770-1820 Author(s): Richard D. Brown Source: The New England Quarterly , Dec., 1988, Vol. 61, No. 4 (Dec., 1988), pp. 502-518 Published by: The New England Quarterly, Inc.
https://we-ha.com/memorial-to-lemuel-haynes-dedicated-in-west-hartford/
https://granbydrummer.com/2020/08/lemuel-haynes-an-eloquent-man-of-god/
https://granbydrummer.com/2020/09/lemuel-haynes-an-eloquent-man-of-god-2/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0AaYsRYojDc *The Lemuel Haynes part starts at 32:28
And another small segment from West Rutland a couple years ago
https://vermonthistory.org/lemuel-haynes
https://jwhamil.com/Hamil/Family.htm (Family website)
Other related resources:
Discovering Black Vermont, African American Farmers in Hinesburgh, 1790-1890. Elise A. Guyette. Vermont Historical Society. 2020
The Little Professor of Piney Woods, The Story of Professor Laurence Jones. Beth Day. Julian Messner, Inc. NY. 1956
Benjamin Banneker and Us, Eleven Generations of an American Family. Rachel Jamison Webster. Henry Holt and Company. NY. 2023
Vermont African American Heritage Trail: https://www.vermontvacation.com/~/media/files/pdfs/itineraries/vermont-african-american-heritage-trail-2015.ashx?la=en
S4 E7 | Irreconcilable Differences: The Unethical Nature of Illiberalism
This week, Mike and Elizabeth ask whether illiberalism is unethical (spoiler alert: we think so) A couple of brave psychologists recently suggested the same when they advocated for adding the protection and defense of free speech to the American Psychological Association's ethics codes. We find their premise regarding illiberalism sound, even if their arguments are somewhat weak, and make strong arguments of our own that illiberal behaviors are difficult to reconcile with ethical standards.
Podcast notes:
O’Donohue, W., & Fisher, J. E. (2022). Are illiberal acts unethical? APA’s Ethics Code and the protection of free speech. American Psychologist, 77(8), 875–886.
S4 E6 | Keeping Up Appearances: Ethics and Neutrality in the Everyday Life of a Librarian
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth talk about personal and institutional neutrality with academic librarian Pam Hayes-Bohanan. While many of us think about free speech and academic freedom in the abstract, they are concrete and routine considerations for libraries and librarians. Institutions release statements and professional organizations issue ethical guidelines, but no one knows better than librarians the often conflicting impracticalities these can pose. We discuss the challenges of book bans, collection policies, socio-political culture, and what they mean for community and academic libraries and staff.
S4 E5 | Feelings are Facts: Adding Emotional Appeal to Reason-Based Argument
In this week's episode we challenge liberal communicators to make better use of emotional language and imagery to boost their logical arguments. Mike refers to philosophical and historical references to the conflict between reason and sentimentality. Elizabeth describes what research in psychology has to say about the the important contributions of the brain's emotional system to everyday functioning. Reason and emotion are not in conflict; they work in concert.
________
Register for our Liberalism in Practice Panel Discussion: Lessons from Harvard and the Claudine Gay Affair.
To see our calendar of events, and to join our discussions, we invite you to join us on Circle.
S4 E4 | Competitive Suffering: Collective Victimhood and Antisemitic Attitudes
This week's focus is on research suggesting a link between anti-semitism and a culture of competitive victimhood. Elizabeth and Mike briefly describe research designed to test the hypothesis that the Holocaust serves as a standard for comparing victim status. We consider how the research might help us understand outgroup bias, including anti-semetism, and seemingly inexplicable endorsements of terroristic activities past and present.
Podcast Notes:
Antoniou, G., Dinas, E., & Kosmidis, S. (2020). Collective victimhood and social prejudice: A post‐Holocaust theory of Anti‐Semitism. Political Psychology, 41(5), 861–886.
S4 E3 | Diversity Drill: Analysis of a Workplace Training Program
n this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth discuss diversity training, specifically an "Anti-Racist Fight Club" pamphlet, forwarded to us anonymously. We go through the materials, click on embedded links, and fact check where appropriate. This is a long episode, but it could have easily been longer still. For example, we focused on aspects presented as objective information, but did not linger over portions that were clearly presented as the author's opinion. We hope this episode may be helpful to listeners who are facing their own workplace DEI seminars.
Podcast Notes
Watch Coleman Hughes Colorblindness Ted Talk:
https://www.ted.com/talks/coleman_hughes_a_case_for_color_blindness
Watch Doyin Richards Tedx Talk:
https://www.ted.com/talks/doyin_richards_racism_from_the_perspective_of_a_non_threatening_black_man
Listen to Our Podcast with Wilfred Reily:
Listen to Glenn Lowery and John McWhorter talk about Ibram X Kendi:
See Barack Obama reconnect with the boy (now a young adult) who wanted to touch the former president's hair:
https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2022/05/27/obama-hair-like-mine-photo-kid-orig-kj.cnn
S4 E2 | The Tide is High: Little Evidence of Ebbing DEI Impacts
Recent editorial headlines and social media posts suggest the resignation of Harvard's president, combined with shifting public sentiment, are signals that DEI initiatives are losing their grip on education and government. In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth discuss why a few small cracks in the DEI facade are unlikely to turn the tide. We are very skeptical that the overall strength and vastness of DEI influences have been diminished and see more evidence of continued vulnerability to a belief system that is baked into the consciousness of so many. Policies, procedures, and commitments have been made that will require institutional compliance with DEI initiatives for many years to come, and DEI administrators, true believers or not, are unlikely to abandon their posts. Mike wonders if shifts in public sentiment will further fuel the skepticism and distrust already reflected in public sentiments about elite institutions. Podcast Notes: Our podcast with Helen Pluckrose and Rio Veradonir: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-033-slippery-slopes-helen-pluckrose-rio-veradonir/id1537516628?i=1000638524042 From the Chronicle of Higher Education: https://www.chronicle.com/article/a-decade-of-ideological-transformation-comes-undone?utm_source=Iterable&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=campaign_8675282_nl_Academe-Today_date_20240103&cid=at&source=&sourceid=&sra=true Lee Jussim's Substack https://unsafescience.substack.com/p/2023-academic-self-delegitimization https://unsafescience.substack.com/p/victory-lap From the Atlantic: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/05/dei-training-initiatives-consultants-companies-skepticism/674237/ From the Boston Globe: https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/01/04/opinion/dei-college-woke-universities-harvard/ An example of long term commitments to DEI: https://www.michigandaily.com/news/umich-to-invest-79m-toward-hiring-30-professors-as-part-of-dei-program-with-nih/
S4 E1 | Attention Inequality: When and Where we Ideologically Focus
This week, Mike and Elizabeth talk about research linking ideology to our habits of attention and memory, including our interpretation of cues related to social status and behaviors. The episode was recorded before Harvard’s president resigned, but our discussion is relevant to the ongoing controversy about her path to leadership and short lived tenure as president. The conversation was inspired by a popular online opinion piece proposing that “pathological kindness” (the author’s term, not ours!) leads individuals to act in ways that are ultimately unproductive or socially harmful.
Podcast notes:
Waldfogel, H. B., Sheehy-Skeffington, J., Hauser, O. P., Ho, A. K., & Kteily, N. S. (2021). Ideology selectively shapes attention to inequality. PNAS Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 118(14). https://doi-org.libserv-prd.bridgew.edu/10.1073/pnas.2023985118
https://unherd.com/2023/10/the-tyranny-of-pathological-kindness/
A Moral Moment: Winkfield Twyman Jr. on Harvard President Claudine Gay
Winkfield Twyman Jr., former law school professor, writer, and Harvard Law School graduate, joins Elizabeth Spievak for a discussion about Claudine Gay. Wink questions the moral courage of Harvard's president and has called for her resignation. Gay's recent congressional testimony is discussed as an example of what is a larger problem on college campuses and beyond. We talk about what it means to have a moral compass, historical and contemporary examples of moral courage, and what can and should be expected of leaders. Throughout, the issues and challenges are framed in the context of liberal values.
Podcast Notes:
Wink's Substack on this topic:
https://twyman.substack.com/p/please-resign-harvard-university
https://twyman.substack.com/p/what-does-moral-competence-look-like
https://twyman.substack.com/p/toby-ziegler-and-a-moral-moment
https://twyman.substack.com/p/can-you-help-a-sister-out
Bari Weiss Free Press Articles: https://www.thefp.com/archive?gclid=CjwKCAiA1fqrBhA1EiwAMU5m_wJQhpNBLyx_TMgEC2p8eJyaacI7qCLA-hZXadnZkEmoQluoeR6ZIxoCaykQAvD_BwE
Ep. 033: Slippery Slopes: Helen Pluckrose & Rio Veradonir talk Liberal Norms and Moral Panic
This week we talk culture, ideological politics, philosophy, and law with the celebrated author of Cynical Theories (Helen Pluckrose) and the Assistant Director at the Bi Foundation and editor-in-chief of Queer Majority (Rio Veradonir). Helen and Rio speak with Mike and Elizabeth about challenges to liberalism, past, present, and future. They also share their reasons to celebrate and be hopeful.
Podcast Notes:
Queer Majority: https://www.queermajority.com/
Bi Foundation: https://bi.org/en/about
Bailey, Allison (2014). The Unlevelled Knowing Field: An Engagement with Dotson's Third-Order Epistemic Oppression. Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective. The Unlevel Knowing Field: An Engagement with Dotson’s Third-Order Epistemic Oppression, Alison Bailey - Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective (social-epistemology.com)
Burke, Edmund (1790). Reflections on the Revolution in France. The Project Gutenberg eBook of Burke's Writings and Speeches, Volume the Third, by Edmund Burke.
Dotson, Kristie (2011). Tracking Epistemic Violence: Tracking Practices of Silencing. Hypatia. Tracking Epistemic Violence, Tracking Practices of Silencing on JSTOR
Mills, Charles (2005). "Ideal Theory" as Ideology. Hypatia. Wiley. "Ideal Theory" as Ideology on JSTOR
Paine, Thomas (1791). The Rights of Man. Project Gutenberg. The Writings of Thomas Paine, Complete by Thomas Paine | Project Gutenberg
Pluckrose, Helen & James Lindsay (2005). Cynical Theories. Pitchstone Publishing. Amazon.com: Cynical Theories: How Activist Scholarship Made Everything About Race, Gender, and Identity - and Why This Harms Everybody (Audible Audio Edition): Helen Pluckrose, James Lindsay, Helen Pluckrose, Pitchstone Publishing: Books
Pluckrose, Helen (2023). The Perilous Pendulum Swing Threatening LGBT Rights. Queer Majority. The Perilous Pendulum Swing Threatening LGBT Rights — Queer Majority
Stenner, Karen (2012). The Authoritarian Dynamic. Cambridge University Press. Authoritarian Dynamic (05) by Stenner, Karen [Paperback (2005)]: Stener: Amazon.com: Books
History of Liberalism | James Petts
In this Liberal Conversation series of the Dissident’s Podcast, Mike and James discuss the history of liberalism, how power is abused by those factions traditionally associated with the left and the right and how those labels are themselves arbitrary rather than principled.
Potemkin Villages: The Origin of Antisemitic Soviet Propaganda & it's Influence on American Education & Media | Izabella Tabarovsky
Welcome to the Radical Roots of Ethnic Studies, a series of the Dissidents Podcast, with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
This week we speak with Izabella Tabarovsky, a Soviet Jewish Immigrant who has dedicated her research to exploring the spread of Soviet propaganda throughout the modern world. In this podcast she shares with the Soviet origins of antisemitic & anti-zionist propaganda & tropes, both the right & left’s adoption of these ideologies, its influence in today’s American media landscape and education system, and how Hamas used the same protocols put forth by the Russians and subsequently the Nazis to justify a Jewish genocide.
Coalition for Empowered Education
Podcast Notes:
The Protocols of the Elders of Zion
Find out more about Izabella, a Senior Advisor at the Wilson Center, and see her most recent media interviews.
How Soviet Propaganda Informs Contemporary Left Anti-Zionism, Izabella Tabarovsky for Tablet Magazine
Let Russian Jews Lead, Izabella Tabarovsky for Tablet Magazine
The Cult of ‘Antizionism’, Izabella Tabarovsky for Tablet Magazine
Read Izabella’s Afterword for Letters in Black & White
"Queers for Palestine" and the Death of Irony | Armin Navabi & David Bernstein
In this week's podcast Armin Navabi, David Bernstein & Mike Burke discuss homophobia in relation to Israel, Gaza and the West Bank, "pink washing", the future of the two state solution (or lack thereof) and the role that religion plays in how different cultures conceive of power and weakness.
Podcast Notes:
Armin Navabi, “Queers for Palestine” and the Death of Irony — Queer Majority
Female Saudi anchor on Al Arabiya confronts Hamas leader Khaled Mashal on his group's terrorism in Israel - Hamas Leader Abroad Rejects Accusations of Transgressions against Civilians on October 7 Attack - YouTube
Ep. 032: Dirty Little Secrets: University Funding, Academic Freedom, and Antisemitism
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth talk about a report that links receipt of undisclosed foreign donations with the erosion of tolerance on U.S. campuses. Larger donations from Middle Eastern and authoritarian countries appeared especially troublesome. Correlational results indicate that a lack of university transparency about their funding sources was concurrent with reported increases in antisemitism and with challenges to norms of free expression. Elizabeth expresses skepticism regarding any causal inferences. Mike shares his views about the likely goals of donors from authoritarian countries and specifically discusses funds from Qatar. Both agree with the authors that more research is warranted.
Podcast Notes:
The Corruption of the American Mind: How Concealed Foreign Funding of U.S. Higher Education Predicts Erosion of Democratic Values and Antisemitic Incidents on Campus.
From the Network Contagion Research Institute:
https://networkcontagion.us/wp-content/uploads/NCRI-Report_The-Corruption-of-the-American-Mind.pdf
Critical Resentment Theory & the Colonization of the Mind
Welcome to the Radical Roots of Ethnic Studies, a series of the Dissidents Podcast, with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality. This week we speak with Carob Marcelle, an educator, mother and host of Be Not Afraid. Carob moved her family from Washington to Utah in search of a K-12 education for her child that was free of indoctrination. What she found instead was a growing institutionalization of critical social justice throughout both the education system and religious environment. In her concern over the “colonization” of our minds, she has gone in search of ways to promote black history free of critical “resentment” theory. Podcast Notes: Be Not Afraid: https://www.youtube.com/@CarobMarcelle
Ep. 031: Balancing Act: The Dynamics of Friendly and Unfriendly Connections
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth go back to basics with a discussion about balance. We begin and end with contemporary challenges to balance in our personal and professional lives, particularly those posed by DEI initiatives. Sandwiched between is a deep dive on balance in international relations, with a focus on the Middle East. Mike employs his background and training to take us through some of the most important historical challenges to balance in the region, from the Ottoman Empire to the crisis unfolding today.
Podcast Notes:
Antal, T., Krapivsky, P. L., & Redner, S. (2006). Social balance on networks: The dynamics of friendship and enmity. Physica D, 224(1/2), 130–136. https://doi-org.libserv-prd.bridgew.edu/10.1016/j.physd.2006.09.028
Ep. 030: Digital Dopamine: The Value of Personal and Organizational Statements
In this week's episode ILV fellows Mike, Elizabeth, and James discuss position statements and ILV's commitment to liberal conversations. First, Mike talks with Elizabeth who argues that organizational statements are of little practical use and may jeopardize the non-partisan and non-sectarian missions of consortiums like ILV. In the second part of the podcast, Mike and James continue to discuss how dangerously close institutional statements can come to compelling speech. In both segments we talk about antisemitism, war, and the difference between personal and organizational neutrality.
Podcast notes:
https://provost.uchicago.edu/reports/report-universitys-role-political-and-social-action
New Beginnings and Old Fears: Channy Laux on Escaping Cambodian Genocide
Channy Chhi Laux joins us to discuss her perspectives on communism, free speech, individual rights and responsibilities, and contemporary challenges to liberal values. Channy was just 13 when the Khmer Rouge seized Cambodia in 1975. She endured 4 years of starvation, forced labor, and disease before arriving in Lincoln, Nebraska as a Cambodian refugee who spoke no English and who had been denied 4 years of education. Channy went on to earn an advanced degree in Applied Mathematics and spent 30 years working in Silicon Valley as an engineer. She is the founder of Angkor Cambodian Food, and works with schools and other organizations, like the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation, to promote awareness of the Cambodian Genocide.
Podcast Notes:
Channy’s memoir: Short Hair Detention: Memoir of a Thirteen-Year-Old Girl Surviving the Cambodian Genocide(Bloomington, IN: Archway Publishing, 2017).
Learn about the California Collaborative for Holocaust and Genocide Education: https://holocaustcenter.jfcs.org/california-collaborative/
Access a preview of Channy's Cambodian Genocide educational materials: https://cambodiangenocideresourcecenter.com/lesson-plan-download/
See Channy's Victims of Communism page here: https://victimsofcommunism.org/speaker/channy-chhi-laux/
Check out Angkor Cambodian Food:
https://www.angkorfood.com/
Ep. 029: Antisemitism Before and After the 7th | David Bernstein & Brandy Shufutinsky
On October the 5th Brandy Shufutinsky, David Bernstein and Mike Burke met to discuss the growing problem of antisemitism on both the political left and right. Little could any of them know what was about to happen just a couple of days later on October the 7th, which was the worst attack on the Jewish people, since the Holocaust. In an addendum to the original recording, made just a few days later but in what felt like a totally different era, Mike and Brandy included a follow-up conversation on the outpourings of antisemitic madness erupting across Western world, including direct incitements to violence by academics at prestigious universities, hordes of people taking to the streets to celebrate some of the worst of atrocities of the 21st century and schools in London having to temporarily close due to the very real fear of violent mobs attacking Jewish children.
Podcast Notes:
Podcast notes:
You can find the Coalition for Empowered Education’s downloadable letter to California superintendents on the Institute for Liberal Values website.
Connecting Liberated Ethnic Studies and Hamas
Welcome to the Radical Roots of Ethnic Studies, a series of the Dissidents Podcast, with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
Hamas’ recent terrorist attack in Israel has garnered the support of the Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies (CLES), a group that is designing curricula for K12 education and is involved in teacher training, funded in large part by California taxpayers. In this episode we discuss CLES’ support of Hamas, the subtle and sloganized language used by CLES and Hamas supporters that conflates hatred and terrorism with “resistance”, CLES Ethnic Studies curricula’s ideological emphasis on Palestine, and the release of recent curricula surrounding the attack that fails to address the nuance and complexity of the conflict.
Coalition for Empowered Education
Podcast Notes:
Neo-Confederacy & Palestinian Ultranationalism: How Prejudice is Justified Through the Myth of “Lost Civilization”, Dmitri Shufutinsky in ISGAP Flashpoint, Feb 27, 2023
The Cult of ‘Antizionism’, Izabella Tabarovsky in Tablet Magazine, Sept 19, 2023
*You can find Izabella’s Afterword to Letters in Black and White on the Truth in Between website.*
*You can find the Coalition for Empowered Education’s downloadable letter to California superintendents on the Institute for Liberal Values website.”
Ep. 028: Bones of Contention: Anthropologist Elizabeth Weiss on Sex, Bones, and Ethical Hypocrisy
In this week's podcast Elizabeth Weiss, Professor of Anthropology and fellow at the Center for Academic Pluralism, joins us to talk about bones! We discuss research ethics, respect for artifacts, the preservation of research materials, and academic freedom in anthropology and beyond. Current and future access to documents, laboratory spaces, databases, and physical objects are at risk. Also at risk is exposure to diverse and challenging ideas in anthropology research and education. We talk about contemporary social and political challenges surrounding the categorization of bones and the related ideological hypocrisies the field is actively avoiding. Elizabeth gives us a brief overview of her most recent cancellation experience: a panel discussion originally accepted for the American Anthropological Association conference was deemed potentially harmful and removed from the schedule. She invites us to hear the canceled panel discussion on November 8, offered through Heterodox Academy.
Podcast Notes:
Sign up for "[UNCANCELED] Let's Talk About Sex Baby: Why Biological Sex Remains A Necessary Analytic Category in Anthropology" by clicking here: https://t.co/hrsArQWnun Wednesday, November 8th at 4 - 6 pm ET
Books by Elizabeth Weiss: Reading the Bones: Activity, Biology, and Culture (2017) and Repatriation and Erasing the Past (2020).
Materials about the AAA cancellation: https://elizabethweiss74.wordpress.com/discussing-sex-is-no-longer-allowed-at-anthropology-conferences/
Elizabeth Weiss article in Quillette: The Problem of Sex Discrimination in Indigenous Archaeology (quillette.com)
Elizabeth Weiss piece in Spiked: There’s no such thing as a nonbinary skeleton - spiked (spiked-online.com)
Article by Kathleen Lowrey about the canceled AAA panel: https://compactmag.com/article/how-anthropology-canceled-sex
The Sound of Silence: A Liberal Conversation about Free Speech with Cherise Trump
Executive Director of Speech First, Cherise Trump, and Elizabeth Spievak discuss the state of free speech on college campuses. Cherise gives us an overview of her work at Speech First to promote open discourse as an essential component of a comprehensive education. We talk about the importance of being exposed to different and challenging ideas to build strength and resilience, as well as the difficulties faced by students and faculty alike in the current socio political climate. Throughout, the issues and challenges of free speech are framed in the context of liberal values.
Podcast Notes
https://speechfirst.org/
Ep. 027: Gimme Shelter: Questions about Vicarious Trauma from News Consumption
In this week's podcast, Mike and Elizabeth discuss an article about the responsibility of journalists in reporting, specifically reports about the war in Ukraine. The authors suggest that consumers of the news may be traumatized by seeing 24/7 coverage, perhaps even more traumatized and demoralized than those who are living in a war zone. The description of potential harm and the fragility of readers or viewers is reminiscent of that which is leveraged by some social justice advocates, and the authors narrowly escape a call for censorship.
Podcast notes:
Su, Z., McDonnell, D., Cheshmehzangi, A., Bentley, B. L., Ahmad, J., Šegalo, S., da Veiga, C. P., & Xiang, Y.-T. (2023). Media-induced war trauma amid conflicts in Ukraine. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 18(4), 908–911.
Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics: spj.org/ethicscode.asp
Ep. 026: Money for Nothing and your Angst for Free: Leadership, Control and Stress
In this week's podcast, Mike and Elizabeth discuss research on leadership and stress. In what may at first seem like counterintuitive findings, military and government leaders had lower levels of the stress related hormone cortisol than non-leaders. A sense of control was a significant mediator of anxiety and stress. We talk about contemporary labor relations and social applications of the findings, as well as some similar research that clarifies who may benefit the most from a sense of control in the workplace.
Podcast notes:
Sherman, G. D., Lee, J. J., Cuddy, A. J. C., Renshon, J., Oveis, C., Gross, J. J., & Lerner, J. S. (2012). Leadership is associated with lower levels of stress. PNAS Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 109(44), 17903–17907.
Socialism Then & There, Here & Now | David Smolansky
Welcome to a new series of the Dissidents Podcast with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
This week we speak with David Smolansky, a mayor in exile from Venezuela. David tells his personal story living through the transition from democracy to socialism in Venezuela. His experience guides our discussion on various trends in education then & there in Venezuela to the here & now in the United States.
Podcast References:
David’s Victim’s Of Communism Witness Video: https://victimsofcommunism.org/witness/david-smolansky-urosa/
Politicization of the Classroom: From Radical Roots to Government Mandate Livestream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnUmScJhEKs&t=5s
Ep. 025: The Struggle Within: Campus Culture, Free Inquiry, and the New Princeton Principles | Lee Jussim
In this week's podcast Elizabeth and Mike talk with Lee Jussim about the new "Princeton Principles for a Campus Culture of Free Inquiry." Lee, distinguished professor of psychology at Rutgers, joined an interdisciplinary group of professors from many institutions in creating a set of principles that offer contemporary guidelines for the revitalization of higher education's core mission. The document addresses the special and honorable duties of universities to foster freedom of thought and to actively avoid becoming political or ideological battlegrounds. We alternate between frustration, worry, and hope in our discussion and examples of the challenges ahead for ensuring access to a truly liberal education.
Podcast Notes
Princeton Principles:
https://jmp.princeton.edu/princeton-principles-campus-culture-free-inquiry
Chicago Statement:
https://provost.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/documents/reports/FOECommitteeReport.pdf
Kalven Report:
https://provost.uchicago.edu/reports/report-universitys-role-political-and-social-action
Political Compass:
https://www.politicalcompass.org/
Society for Open Inquiry in Behavioral Science:
https://openinquirybehavio.wixsite.com/oibs
Lee's Substack:
Diversity for the Curious: A Liberal Conversation with Brandy Shufutinsky
Welcome to a special “Liberal Conversations Series” of the Dissidents Podcast.
In this series we invite guests who have resources, ideas, and viewpoints that will challenge us to reflect on liberal values, what they are, how they are applied, their impact on us as individuals, and why they matter for the larger communities in which we live.
In this episode, Brandy Shufutinsky and Elizabeth Spievak discuss intercultural and academic opportunities that can enhance liberal democratic ideals. Brandy gives us an overview of her upcoming course and its usefulness for teachers, parents, and laypeople. The course and our discussion of current challenges in education, from the broad and sociopolitical to the personal and specific, are framed in the context of liberal values.
Podcast Notes
https://freeblackthought.substack.com/p/i-am-not-your-negro
https://sapirjournal.org/education/2022/08/day-schools-and-dei-a-parents-perspective/
https://www.jns.org/jns/antisemitism/23/6/11/294273/
Register for Brandy’s course starting October 26, 2023:
https://bit.ly/464tnH8
Ep. 024: In the Group Groove: Building Connections by Experiencing Similar Emotions
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth discuss the group based emotions we experience as a result of our membership in, or identification with, a group. The article we chose focuses on the motivations for those emotions: first, it feels good to feel like we belong, and second, experiencing group emotions enhances our sense of connectedness. We discuss the good and the bad of group emotions, and explore examples that span the abstract and philosophical, to the personal and political.
Podcast Notes:
Porat, R., Tamir, M., & Halperin, E. (2020). Group-based emotion regulation: A motivated approach. Emotion, 20, 16–20.
Bigotry of Low Expectations | Kofi Montzka
Welcome to a new series of the Dissidents Podcast with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
This week we speak with Kofi Montzka, an attorney, wife and mother. In March, Kofi spoke out at a Minnesota Legislature assembly against a bill mandating ethnic studies. According to Kofi, radical or critical ethnic studies may assuage white guilt, but teaches kids of color a hopelessness that affects their ability to succeed. These educational agendas institutionalize a bigotry of low expectations, amounting to a new form of racism in our schools.
https://empowered-ed.org/ https://ilvalues.org/
Podcast References:
Ep. 023: The Kids are Alright: One Conspiracy Theory Debunked
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth discuss the ease with which we engage in outgroup accusations and denunciations, use language that divides us, and even accept accusations of conspiracy without skepticism. After being alerted to one potential conspiracy to indoctrinate children, we did a deep dive into UNESCO (the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) and their "Comprehensive Sexuality Education" initiative. Elizabeth enrolled in their course for teachers and went through the materials. Mike examined their website for red flags. We report on our findings, including a lack of evidence for a conspiracy. Podcast Notes: https://www.unesco.org/en/brief https://www.unesco.org/en/health-education/cse-campaign
Knowing Me to Know Thee: A Liberal Conversation with Zander Keig
Welcome to a special “Liberal Conversations Series” of the Dissidents Podcast.
In this series we invite guests who have resources, ideas, and viewpoints that will challenge us to reflect on liberal values, what they are, how they are applied, their impact on us as individuals, and why they matter for the larger communities in which we live.
This week, Zander Keig and Elizabeth Spievak discuss the importance of wellness, and wellbeing in complex times. He gives us an overview of his upcoming course and its usefulness for both the ordinary and the extraordinary in our daily lives. The course and our discussion are framed in the context of liberal values.
Podcast References:
https://www.zanderkeig.net/
https://braverangels.org/
Ep. 022: Moral Hypocrisy and Ethical Blind Spots
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth discuss the motivation to appear moral without incurring the losses that may accompany actually behaving morally (like being thought of as a cheater or liar). In one paper, researchers showed that in order to appear fair in the eyes of others, participants engaged in social deception to disguise their selfish behavior. In another paper, participants were more unethical and self-serving in ambiguous situations, and in a third paper ambiguity led participants to behave unethically in order to benefit a person for whom they were induced to feel compassion. Results are discussed in the context of contemporary virtue signaling.
Podcast notes:
Lönnqvist, J.-E., Irlenbusch, B., & Walkowitz, G. (2014). Moral hypocrisy: Impression management or self-deception? Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 55, 53–62.
Pittarello, A., Leib, M., Gordon-Hecker, T., & Shalvi, S. (2015). Justifications shape ethical blind spots. Psychological Science, 26, 794–804.
Fang, X., Chen, L., Wang, J., Zhang, Q., & Mo, L. (2020). Do all types of compassion increase prosocial lying? Psychology Research and Behavior Management, 13.
Ep. 021: Expanding our (dis)comfort zones for learning
In this week's episode Mike and Elizabeth talk about getting comfortable with discomfort. We discuss a series of studies in which people who were prompted to seek discomfort as a sign of growth and learning demonstrated increased willingness to engage in challenging activities. Some spent more time on improvisational exercises, others read more about COVID 19, gun violence, or opposing political viewpoints. The article resonated with us on personal and professional levels, and is quite relevant in this culture of victimhood, anxiety, and discomfort avoidance. We also link the article to methods commonly used in diversity training.
Podcast Article:
Woolley, K., & Fishbach, A. (2022). Motivating personal growth by seeking discomfort. Psychological Science, 33(4), 510–523.
Justice by Learning History | Amy Lesserman
Welcome to a new series of the Dissidents Podcast with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
This week we speak with Amy Lesserman, an English and Social Studies teacher with a long career in the Los Angeles Unified School District. We discuss the importance of more inclusive history curricula to replace current ethnic studies curricula, the exclusionary aspects of liberated ethnic studies, e.g. those of “inconvenient” minorities, and the alarming exodus of students from K-12 public schools.
https://empowered-ed.org/
America's Dangerous Repeat of the Chinese Cultural Revolution | Mike Zhao
Welcome to a new series of the Dissidents Podcast with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality.
This week we speak with the President of the Asian American Coalition for Education, Mike Zhao. Zhao, the author of Critical Race Theory and Woke Culture: America’s Dangerous Repeat of the Chinese Cultural Revolution, shares his personal story of living through the Chinese Cultural Revolution, his eventual immigration to the West, and his alarm at seeing similar Marxist trends infiltrating the American K-12 education system.
Ep. 020: Utopian daze and reality checks
In this episode Mike and Elizabeth discuss the idealistic hopes of utopianism and the difficulties of implementing them in real life. Mike covers philosophy, and Elizabeth includes references to some famous psychologists who suggested that their field would be at the center of successful utopian community life. We connect utopianism to current politics and communism. Podcast notes: Nagel, T. (1991). The Problem of Utopianism. Equality and Partiality, 21. https://ilvalues.org/
Ep. 019: Scarlet Letter
During this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth discuss a unique study in which, over the course of a week, 5 co authors agreed to be ostracized by the other 4, each for 1 day. The authors documented their experiences of being targets and perpetrators. Despite foreknowledge and consent, the co authors reported feeling rejected, confused and guilty. Their work and personal relationships were strained. The authors advise that, while the project was an important contribution to the field (specifically the psychology of ostracism), future research be undertaken with caution. Mike and Elizabeth agree. Ostracism is so powerful that even obvious and orchestrated simulations have the potential for serious negative outcomes for individuals and groups.
Reference:
Williams, K. D., Bernieri, F. J., Faulkner, S. L., Gada-Jain, N., & Grahe, J. E. (2000). The Scarlet Letter Study: Five Days of Social Ostracism. Journal of Personal & Interpersonal Loss, 5(1), 19–63.
The Radical Roots of Ethnic Studies (A Series of The Dissidents Podcast) no. 1
Welcome to a new series of the Dissidents Podcast with your co-hosts, Jennifer Richmond and Brandy Shufutinsky. In this series we explore the radical roots of liberated ethnic studies, how extreme ideology is infiltrating our schools with the aim to indoctrinate instead of educate, and our search for solutions to empower parents, teachers and students, giving them the tools to embrace inquiry and to express their individuality. Join us.
https://empowered-ed.org/
https://ilvalues.org/
Ep. 018: The tangled web of post-cancellation shaming
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth discuss a recent article on cancel culture. The title of the article, "Blame, then shame," reflects the author's findings that assessment of personal character followed cancellation decisions and demands for apology. Few participants were interested in debating diverse perspectives. We talk about what the study's methods and results might mean to further research on cancel culture, as well as our surprise that the project was published. Kudos to the author and to the journal for starting the process.
Podcast Notes:
Thomas S. Mueller (2021) Blame, then shame? Psychological predictors in cancel culture behavior, The Social Science Journal, DOI: 10.1080/03623319.2021.1949552
Ep. 017: Talking Taboo: Data & Racism | Wilfred Reilly
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth talk with Wilfred Reilly, Associate Professor of Political Science at Kentucky State University and author of Hate Crime Hoax: How the Left is Selling a Fake Race War and Taboo: 10 Facts You Can't Talk About. We discuss COVID learning loss, affirmative action, race, culture, what modern quantitative methods reveal about privilege, and how to talk about taboo topics.
Podcast Notes:
Reilly W. (2019). Hate crime hoax : how the left is selling a fake race war. Regnery Publishing a division of Salem Media Group.
Reilly W. (2020). Taboo : 10 facts you can't talk about. Regnery Publishing a division of Salem Media Group.
Ep. 016: Old Americans & Sidestepping History | W.F. Twyman, Jr. & Jennifer Richmond
In this week's Dissidents Podcast Mike Burke and Elizabeth Spievak have their second conversation with Winkfield Twyman, Jr. & Jennifer Richmond about their new book Letters in Black and White. In this episode they explore their debate over Wink’s suggestion of creating a common American identity premised on “Old Americans” and Jen’s criticism that this would be seen as “Sidestepping History”. Additionally, they discuss and debate the meaning of authenticity in a culture that prefers that we segregate into binary black and white identities laced with stereotypes and caricatures.
References:
To see the original documents from the book, visit Truth In Between
Ep. 015: Communism past and present, and modern military culture | Ken Pope
In this week's episode, Mike and Elizabeth talk with Ken Pope, CEO of the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. Ken had a 34 year career in the US Army, consulting and academia. While in uniform, he served in a variety of Foreign Area Officer assignments in Russia, Europe, the Middle East, and Central America. He had over 12 years of operational fieldwork with a variety of assignments in Russia, Ukraine, Estonia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Kosovo. We discuss a broad range of topics relevant to communism and democracy in the world, including Russia, China, and the current state of US military recruitment and training. We think listeners will agree that there is much more to learn from Ken, so we hope this is just the first in a series of appearances on The Dissidents Podcast!
Podcast Notes:
Link to Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation website:
https://victimsofcommunism.org/
Report of the National Independent Panel on Military Service and Readiness:
Ep. 014: Moral Identity, no. 2
In this second episode about moral identity, Mike and Elizabeth talk about whether threats to ingroup image, specifically the image some liberal leaning whites might prefer to hold about themselves, could prompt dissociation with their ingroup. The authors of the article we chose believe so, and that this dissociation might be good for social justice causes, but Mike and Elizabeth aren’t so sure. We have a lively discussion about the authors’ claims and our own interpretation of their findings.
References:
Dai, J. D., Eason, A. E., Brady, L. M., & Fryberg, S. A. (2021). #NotAllWhites: Liberal-leaning White Americans racially disidentify and increase support for racial equity. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 47(11), 1612–1632.
Ep. 013: Moral Identity, no. 1
In this first of two episodes about moral identity, Mike and Elizabeth discuss the possibility that the outrage emblematic of cancel culture may not always be the prosocial justice-focused emotion that the activists claim. Moral outrage might also be used to enhance personal beliefs about moral character. The research we discuss in this podcast suggests that reminders of personal moral failings increased the motivation to blame and punish a third-party (country, company or industry). Expressions of moral outrage served to both alleviate guilt and repair moral identity.
Rothschild, Z. K., & Keefer, L. A. (2017). A cleansing fire: Moral outrage alleviates guilt and buffers threats to one’s moral identity. Motivation and Emotion, 41(2), 209–229.
Simler, K., & Hanson, R. (2018). The elephant in the brain: Hidden motives in everyday life. Oxford University Press.
Jordan, J. J., Hoffman, M., Bloom, P., & Rand, D. G. (2016). Third-party punishment as a costly signal of trustworthiness. Nature, 530(7591), 473–476.