Skip to main content
So what do you think?

So what do you think?

By Jay Bee

The world is full of weird events and we want to talk about them! Join Jay and Bee as they break down the weirdness and let you know exactly what they think.
Available on
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

S7 Ep 6 Into the night: Where did Nelda Hardwick go?

So what do you think?Oct 06, 2023

00:00
22:30
S7 Ep 6 Into the night: Where did Nelda Hardwick go?

S7 Ep 6 Into the night: Where did Nelda Hardwick go?

When Nelda Hardwick disappeared after a late night trip to the store in 1993, there was no real investigation done and it would likely have been forgotten about over time. However, when a mystery woman is killed in the next state over 5 years later the similarities between her and Nelda are noted. Was Nelda the woman who was killed all those years later, and if so where had she been for that time. Or was it someone else all together?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Oct 06, 202322:30
S7 Ep 5 Real life Succession? The murders of Barry and Honey Sherman

S7 Ep 5 Real life Succession? The murders of Barry and Honey Sherman

Barry and Honey Sherman were one of the richest couples in Canada, owning a billion dollar pharmaceutical company. Unfortunately, they both had a darker side and upset many people along the way. When they are found murdered there are almost too many suspects to consider, yet essentially no evidence at all. Who killed Honey and Barry Sherman and why?









Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 29, 202326:35
S7 Ep 4 The mystery of the Tallman Haunted Bunks

S7 Ep 4 The mystery of the Tallman Haunted Bunks

We know that there are many accounts of inanimate objects that seem to carry entities, but they tend to be more portable objects such as dolls or paintings. Today we discuss a case where a set of bunk beds seem to have come with an unwanted evil entity, that which terrorised a young family.




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 22, 202322:15
S7 Ep 3 The bizarre final commute of Colonel Philip Shue

S7 Ep 3 The bizarre final commute of Colonel Philip Shue

Buckle up for a wild ride as we discuss the final 2 hours of Colonel Philip Shue, where his usual commute to work ended up leading to not only his death but evidence of a bizarre series of events that unfolded on the journey. Who tortured and killed Philip, and why did he not stop for help before dying in a tragic accident?



Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" By Fast Lady

Sep 15, 202334:32
S7 Ep 2 Accident or attack? The death of Lauren Agee

S7 Ep 2 Accident or attack? The death of Lauren Agee

Lauren Agee was a young girl with her whole life ahead of her, who made the mistake of attending a weekend sporting event with friends. When she seems to vanish while camping overnight people start to wonder where she has gone and why. Those questions are soon answered and many more asked when her body is found later that day.


Was Laurens death a tragic accident that could have been prevented, or was something far more sinister at play?



Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 08, 202338:08
S7 Ep 1 Stranger danger: The death of Amy Mihaljevic

S7 Ep 1 Stranger danger: The death of Amy Mihaljevic

Amy was a 10 year old girl who fell prey to a predator who tricked her into doing a nice deed for her mum. Under the guise of a surprise shopping trip this person lured her to her ultimate death. Who killed Amy and why have they not been found yet?


NOTE: If you wait until after the end outro music you will get an extra section of Jay and Bee crapping on about dogs. We have removed it from the actual episode content out of respect for this very serious case.






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" By Fast Lady

Sep 01, 202324:04
S6 Ep 6 The Zodiac Killings

S6 Ep 6 The Zodiac Killings

It's one of the most famous serial killer cases there is, and still to this day it is unsolved. Who was this person who called themselves the Zodiac killer? And what was it that led to him being able to continue his reign of terror without being caught, even with so many eye witness accounts?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Aug 11, 202353:58
S6 Ep 5 Murdered on the job. They unexpected slaying of Lindsay Buziak.

S6 Ep 5 Murdered on the job. They unexpected slaying of Lindsay Buziak.

Lindsay Buziak was just starting out in her career as a real estate agent when her life was tragically cut short. It is the details of her murder that make for such a bizarre scenario, so much so that you will just be left shaking your head.






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Aug 04, 202327:20
S6 Ep 4 Something doesn't seem right. The death of Christian Andreacchio.

S6 Ep 4 Something doesn't seem right. The death of Christian Andreacchio.

Christian Andreacchio really seemed to have his life together in many ways. He worked hard in his dream job and was able to buy a home and expensive car by the young age of 21. He did have a tumultuous relationship though and after a fight one day with his girlfriend Christians brief life was ended. Was it suicide as the police were so quick to claim? Or was there a lot more to this story?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jul 28, 202329:20
S6 Ep 3 What was the Beast of Gevaudan?

S6 Ep 3 What was the Beast of Gevaudan?

It 18th century rural France and there is a beast terrorising the town of Gevaudan, causing the death and maiming of hundreds of villagers. This thing is thought to be nothing anyone has ever seen before and becomes so famous that even King Louie gets involved. What was the beast and how could it evade capture for so long?







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jul 21, 202328:23
S6 Ep 2 Trail to nowhere: The disappearance of Aaron Hedges

S6 Ep 2 Trail to nowhere: The disappearance of Aaron Hedges

Aaron Hedges thought he was simply going on a hunting/camping/hiking trip with his mates, just like he did regularly. When things don't go according to plan on the first day a few modifications have to be made to the plan, leading to Aaron taking off on his own for a day to resupply. Despite the trail being one he had taken many times before it seems he becomes lost and eventually disappears. Did Aaron really get lost and perish in the wilderness, or is the truth more complicated?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jul 14, 202338:02
S6 Ep 1 Who or what caused the tragic Luna Park ghost train fire?

S6 Ep 1 Who or what caused the tragic Luna Park ghost train fire?

The Luna Park Ghost Train fire tragedy is a horrific moment in Australia's history, with so many innocent children being claimed by what seemed to be a deliberately lit fire. So who lit it and why? Who would perpetrate such evil?







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jul 07, 202342:08
BONUS EPISODE: For those who like closure, we present "So What Do You think? SOLVED

BONUS EPISODE: For those who like closure, we present "So What Do You think? SOLVED

Well its bonus episode time and this week we have something for those of you out there that hate the unsolved stuff. So this week we will be presenting a couple of episodes that have been very famous over the years in the true crime world and very recently have been SOLVED.






INTRO/OUTRO "SUGAR SUGAR" BY FAST LADY

Jun 28, 202347:10
S5 Ep6 Disappearance at the Vatican: Where is Emanuela Orlandi?

S5 Ep6 Disappearance at the Vatican: Where is Emanuela Orlandi?

It is amazing to think that the disappearance of a girl who lived in the Vatican could disappear with out a trace and it not be a well known story. That is exactly what happened to Emanuela Orlandi in 1983 though and we still have no answers. Why are there so many players and people inserting themselves in this case? And is it a stand alone case or part of something more sinister and much bigger?






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" By Fast Lady

Jun 16, 202346:14
S5 Ep5 Running to nowhere: The death of Blair Adams

S5 Ep5 Running to nowhere: The death of Blair Adams

When Blair Adams started acting strange his family were instantly concerned that something wasn't right with him. His paranoia soon led him on a wild ride from Canada to USA where he seemed to be driving to nowhere. When he is found dead one morning there are more questions than answers. Was Blair really being pursued by someone who eventually killed him or was it something else all together?







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jun 09, 202323:49
S5 Ep 4 The wild adventures of Huang Yangqiu

S5 Ep 4 The wild adventures of Huang Yangqiu

Every now and then we come across a story that really stretches belief, and this is one of those times. Huang Yanqiu was a young Chinese farmer who has a story to tell that is so crazy you just have to hear it to believe it. Where he went and what he did defies logic.







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Jun 02, 202344:22
S5 Ep3 Bathtub accident or murder? What really happened to Sarah Widmer?

S5 Ep3 Bathtub accident or murder? What really happened to Sarah Widmer?

When Sarah Widmer went up to take a bath one night while her husband watched the football, she could not have known it would be the last thing she would do. When she is found dead in the tub it is initially assumed that she fell asleep and drowned, but the autopsy had a different tale to tell. What really led to Sarah Widmer's death?








Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

May 26, 202334:08
S5 Ep 2 Double disappearance: What happened to Annette Sagers and Korrina Malinoski?

S5 Ep 2 Double disappearance: What happened to Annette Sagers and Korrina Malinoski?

Korrina Malinoski was in a bad marriage to a violent man, so when she vanished one day people thought it was equally possible that she left him or he killed her. So one year later when her daughter Annette also goes missing, more questions are raised. Did Annette leave to start a new life with her mother or is the truth something a lot more dark?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

May 19, 202326:09
S5 Ep 1 Victim of circumstance or cold blooded killer? The trial of Keli Lane

S5 Ep 1 Victim of circumstance or cold blooded killer? The trial of Keli Lane

Keli Lane was a promising water polo player with her sights on the olympics, so having a baby was not part of her plans. Despite this she managed to get pregnant on a number of occasions, usually resulting in her having an abortion or giving the child up for adoption. However, there was one baby born that seemed to vanish without a trace. What happened to baby Tegan, and is Kelly a victim of circumstance or a cold blooded murderer?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

May 12, 202334:31
BONUS EPISODE: Telling stories volume 1: Jay's haunted house

BONUS EPISODE: Telling stories volume 1: Jay's haunted house

ts bonus episode time again!While you wait for the next round of strangeness we thought we would take this chance to finally tell the story many of you have been waiting for, JAY'S HAUNTED HOUSE STORY!

May 03, 202332:57
S4 Ep 6 Death at Wanda Beach

S4 Ep 6 Death at Wanda Beach

Australia was just not ready for the horrific murders of 2 teenaged girls in January 1965, and everyone struggled to make sense of such violence. The police department tried their best, launching an investigation that has still not been surpassed to this day in sheer size. However, it just was not enough to get justice for Christine Sharrock and Marianne Schmidt and to this day we still search for who caused such terror on Wanda Beach that day.





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" By Fast Lady

Apr 28, 202331:27
S4 Ep5 Murder and millions: Who killed Abraham Shakespeare?

S4 Ep5 Murder and millions: Who killed Abraham Shakespeare?

When Abraham Shakespeare won $17 million on the lottery that should have meant the end of his worries. Unfortunately for him what it actually meant was a lot of people holding their hands out to get a cut. When he is killed in mysterious circumstances only a couple of years later the focus soon turns to a strange woman who seems to have befriended him quite recently. Did DeeDee Moore have anything to do with Abraham's death or is the reality even stranger?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" By Fast Lady

Apr 21, 202343:09
S4 Ep4: Did Doveland ever really exist?

S4 Ep4: Did Doveland ever really exist?

Can a town really just disappear completely? This is the question we pose today when we discuss the mysterious town of Doveland, Wisconsin. Doveland seemed to be there one day and gone the next. Some people say they remember the town and have even visited many years ago. So did it really exist and if so where did it go?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Apr 14, 202327:06
S4 Ep 3 Murderer made or murderer exposed: What really happened to Teresa Halbach?

S4 Ep 3 Murderer made or murderer exposed: What really happened to Teresa Halbach?

When Teresa Halbach went missing and was found murdered, noone could ever have imagined that her death would be the subject of one of the most famous true crime documentaries of all time 10 years later. Were Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey really framed for the crime or is the truth even more shocking?







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Apr 07, 202357:29
S4 Ep2 Toy trucks and sandwiches: The disappearance of Judy Smith

S4 Ep2 Toy trucks and sandwiches: The disappearance of Judy Smith

What started as a trip to a conference that doubled as a short getaway for newlyweds Judy and Jeff, soon becomes the start of a truly baffling disappearance, as Judy seems to vanish. Filter through the many sightings with us as we try to understand what really happened to Judy when she left the hotel that day, and how she ultimately ended up the way she did.





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Mar 31, 202349:30
S4 Ep1: The tragic and baffling death of Ellen Greenberg

S4 Ep1: The tragic and baffling death of Ellen Greenberg

Ellen Greenberg seemed to have everything going for her. A great home and work life, with the prospect of a wedding on the way. So why would she suddenly and violently take her own life? And if she didn't, then who did? Everything is not at it seems in this crazy case.






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Mar 24, 202334:59
BONUS EPISODE: Cocktails and Cryptids part 1
Mar 15, 202301:18:12
S3 Ep 6 Taken by the Devil himself? What happened to Owen Parfitt?

S3 Ep 6 Taken by the Devil himself? What happened to Owen Parfitt?

Owen parfitt was a grumpy old guy, and there were many people that would have liked to see him disappear. So when it appears that he vanished into thin air you would think there were many suspects. However, the details of his disappearance actually suggests that there were not really any. What really happened to Owen?






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Mar 03, 202324:32
S3 Ep5 The strange last moments of Rey Rivera

S3 Ep5 The strange last moments of Rey Rivera

Rey Rivera was by all accounts a larger than life guy who always took on life head on and with enthusiasm. It was then totally shocking when he was found dead from an apparent suicide. However, as the circumstances around his death became known everyone soon began to realise that not everything was as it seemed.





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Feb 24, 202345:34
S3 Ep4 What really happened to Jaime Melgar?

S3 Ep4 What really happened to Jaime Melgar?

When Jaime and Sandra Melgar decided to celebrate their 32nd wedding anniversary, they had no idea it would be the last thing one of them would ever do. When Jaime is found brutally murdered the next day with Sandra bound and unconscious nearby, it seems like an obvious home invasion gone wrong. So why did law enforcement not see it that way?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Feb 17, 202337:50
BONUS EPISODE: We need to talk about Nicola Bulley

BONUS EPISODE: We need to talk about Nicola Bulley

Nicola Bulley vanished while walking her dog on her every day route on January 27th, nearly 3 weeks ago. There where she was last seen was her phone, dog harness and her dog Willow. In a town full of CCTV and a park full of people, where the hell did she go?


The route

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGxCZ6hSHVw



Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady




Feb 14, 202336:48
S3 Ep3 Murdered or martyred? The exorcisms of Anneliese Michel

S3 Ep3 Murdered or martyred? The exorcisms of Anneliese Michel

Anneliese Michel was a young girl who was ultimately killed through neglect after months of long and tortuous exorcisms. Her death was followed by a court case putting the priests involved on trial, who would be found guilty of allowing her death. Was Anneliese really possessed? Or was something else going on that was missed by everyone, leading to her being let down by the people in her life in the worst way possible?



Exorcism recordings

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29fpnF1DWoQ




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Feb 10, 202328:58
S3 Ep 2 Allegations and booby traps: Who was the Circleville letter writer?

S3 Ep 2 Allegations and booby traps: Who was the Circleville letter writer?

Before the Watcher letter writing case, there was another similar, yet far more sinister series of events in Circleville, Ohio. Here, the residents of the whole town received letters threatening to out private secrets and scandals. However it was one family who were targeted in a far more malicious way.

Who was the Circleville letter writer?







Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Feb 03, 202336:05
S3 Ep 1 The Disappearance of Paddy Moriarty
Jan 26, 202348:43
S2 Ep 47: Into thin air: What happened to Jennifer Kesse?

S2 Ep 47: Into thin air: What happened to Jennifer Kesse?

Jennifer Kesse was a young woman who seemed to have it all, great partner, loving family, good job and a brand new condo all of her own. One day she didn't show up for work, triggering alarm bells. Where did Jennifer go and who was responsible for this disappearance that has baffled the true crime community for nearly 20 years?


Suspect CCTV

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUwhUPGXeUE




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Nov 25, 202244:29
S2 Ep 46 The fire breathing terror: Who was Spring Heeled Jack?

S2 Ep 46 The fire breathing terror: Who was Spring Heeled Jack?

To the Victorian people life could be hard, especially in London where most people didn't know whether they would have a roof over their head at night. So when a strange entity started attacking London citizens, people were sent into even more of a state of panic. Soon tales of a clawed, glowing eyed, fire breathing entity who leaped about like he was on springs filled everyone's nightmares. Who was Spring Heeled Jack and how could he terrorise England for nearly 70 years?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Nov 18, 202232:16
S2 Ep 45 Death and corruption? What happened to Tom Brown?

S2 Ep 45 Death and corruption? What happened to Tom Brown?

When popular teenager Tom Brown goes missing one night, his family and friends launch into trying to find him. Although there is much community support for the search effort, local law enforcement seem to want to quickly write his disappearance off as a suicide. Did Tom really take his life that night or was there something more sinister at play?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Nov 11, 202251:15
S2 Ep 44 Taken in plain site: The murder of Holly Bobo

S2 Ep 44 Taken in plain site: The murder of Holly Bobo

Holly Bobo was a young student with her whole life ahead of her when a stranger took her from her home and murdered her. Her brother Clint witnessed the kidnapping and saw the kidnapper, but could provide no information as to who the perpetrator was. Under intense community pressure the local law enforcement desperately try everything to solve the case and eventually settle on a group of 4 men as being the guilty parties.

But were they really the brutal killers of Holly or were they just the local scumbags who police decided should go away for this crime, finally putting an end to the mystery?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by fast lady

Nov 04, 202244:57
S2 Ep 43 The Enfield Haunting
Oct 28, 202228:05
S2 Ep 42 Who was the Pyjama Girl?

S2 Ep 42 Who was the Pyjama Girl?

When a young woman is found badly beaten and burned on the side of a road, the race to find out who she was quickly began. However, soon it became clear that this was going to be an impossible task, and drastic measures are used to get her details and appearance out to the public. When a man is charged, leading to a name being finally given to this woman it seems like the mystery is over. What people don't realise is that the mystery was only just beginning.




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady
Oct 21, 202235:31
S2 Ep 41 Driving into nothingness: the disappearance of Jason Landry
Oct 14, 202230:38
S2 Ep 40 Cloaked entities and mysterious disappearances: Is the Predator real?
Oct 07, 202235:47
S2 Ep 39 The execution of Jill Dando

S2 Ep 39 The execution of Jill Dando

A famous new presenter is executed and England is up in arms. The murder of Jill Dando has so many people wondering who could kill such an amazing woman, but it is soon discovered that there is a long list of people who may have wanted her dead. Join us as we delve into mysteries and conspiracies as we ask who took Jill's life and why.




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 30, 202243:25
S2 Ep 38 Strange messages and murder? The YOGTZE case.

S2 Ep 38 Strange messages and murder? The YOGTZE case.

In the midst of a what appears to be a paranoid episode, Gunther tells his wife that there are people after him and that he is concerned for his safety. He writes a strange message and then takes off into the night. We only know some of his movements that night but we do know it ends in his bizarre death. Who was Gunther afraid of? How did he end up in the situation he did? And who was the mystery man seen with him in his final moments? Tonight we speak about what has become to be known as 'The Yogtze Case'.





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 23, 202225:32
S2 Ep 37 Set aside: Why wasn't Sandrine Jourdan’s disappearance investigated?

S2 Ep 37 Set aside: Why wasn't Sandrine Jourdan’s disappearance investigated?

Sandrine Jourdan went missing at the same time as 2 other women in different cases, so why did their cases get so much attention and hers didn't? Was it the fact that she lived a more 'alternative' lifestyle than the other women that led to police fobbing her disappearance off as a probable suicide? key clues were missed in this case that definitely looks like there is more than meets the eye. 





Intro/outro "Sugar, Sugar" by Fast lady

Sep 16, 202233:46
S2 Ep 36 The attempted rescue of Frida Sofia
Sep 09, 202227:59
S2 Ep 35 Vanished in the woods: The disappearance of Tom Messick

S2 Ep 35 Vanished in the woods: The disappearance of Tom Messick

Tom Messick was an older guy but he still loved getting outdoors, despite his many ailments. When he disappears on a hunting trip with family and friends, everyone is baffled at how he could have even moved from his watch point, let alone vanished into thin air.

Was Tom the victim of foul play? Did he wander off and get lost? Or did something even stranger happen?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Sep 02, 202230:00
S2 Ep 34 The twitch of a finger: Did Tex McIver really accidentally shoot his wife?

S2 Ep 34 The twitch of a finger: Did Tex McIver really accidentally shoot his wife?

Tex and Diane McIver seemed to have it all, money, high powered jobs, a high society social circle and a great marriage. So when Tex seems to accidentally shoot Diane in a bizarre accident, people think it is just that, a tragic event. Is there more to this shooting though? Was it really an accident or something more sinister?





Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Aug 26, 202233:11
S2 Ep 33 The Baffling Disappearance and Reappearance of David Lewis

S2 Ep 33 The Baffling Disappearance and Reappearance of David Lewis

When David Lewis disappears one day right in the middle of making food and looking to be about to settle in for the Superbowl, his family are at a loss as to where he could have gone. Soon reports of strange behaviour start to emerge from the previous couple of days, but still he cannot be found. Eventually he is found 11 years later but the details of where he ended up only add to the bizarre nature of this case. Why did David disappear? Was someone else involved? And why did he end up where he did?




Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Aug 19, 202233:21
S2 Ep 32 Japanese Ghosts

S2 Ep 32 Japanese Ghosts

The Japanese people have a beautiful culture of nature worship, and this includes embracing things natural and supernatural. It seems as though there are never ending stories of ghostly events, all happenings that people openly embrace as being paranormal.

Tonight we explore two of these stories and ask the question, are these really Japanese ghosts?






Intro/outro "Sugar Sugar" by Fast Lady

Aug 12, 202221:19