Skip to main content
You've Got Five Pages...To Tell Me It's Good

You've Got Five Pages...To Tell Me It's Good

By Jean Lee

Formerly Story Cuppings! Every week we visit the local library to randomly select a new release and read its first chapter. As writers, we are told that those opening pages are crucial to hooking readers. So, let's see if the first chapter successfully hooks picky readers as well as teaches fellow hardworking writers. Cheers!
Available on
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

You've Got Five Pages, The Olympian Affair by Jim Butcher, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages...To Tell Me It's GoodMar 08, 2024

00:00
18:43
You've Got Five Pages, The Olympian Affair by Jim Butcher, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Olympian Affair by Jim Butcher, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! I find myself in a sequel with Jim Butcher's The Olympian Affair. Book 2 of The Cinder Series takes a smart approach: start with one character walking through a town with a destination in mind. When a writer takes this narrow focus, they not only give themselves a chance to reacquaint readers with a specific character, but to also re-establish the setting of the world, too. Granted, it's one town in a fantasy world, but it's enough to get a sense of what the world is like and how it operates.

Airships are the name of the game here, which is always a fun steampunk concept, and I love that spires take on a whole new meaning through this world. (The fencing swords on the cover are what drew me to pick this book up in the first place.) The writing itself has an interesting rhythm; Butcher deploys short, strong sentences amid long, active prose for those brief descriptors to pack a real punch--"The new vatteries stank."--is a personal favorite of mine. Sensory details like this mixed with banter between two airship captains made the opening pages an intriguing read. If you're ready to take off for a break from this world (I know I am) then I have a feeling Jim Butcher's Cinder Spires series would make for an excellent escape.


And what will you find in these first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Mar 08, 202418:43
You've Got Five Pages, Northwoods by Amy Pease, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Northwoods by Amy Pease, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! What a delightful find! Amy Pease’s debut Northwoods is yet another mystery set in Northern Wisconsin, but I promise you, this prose and establishing chapter promise some fun thrills in the future. Her first chapter is only two pages long, yet in those two little pages, we see our protagonist Eli down on his luck and himself, floating alone out on a lake in the middle of the night, sipping whiskey and reflecting on life. We’re not told he’s sad or depressed—we see it. Plus, the vivid sensory details of the night woods around him add to the isolation of the setting while also helping us feel Eli’s loneliness…that is, until something strange floats into his vicinity. At the end of that chapter he swims quickly ashore, unsettled, and reaches for his scanner. A couple of pages into the second chapter, we learn he’s not only in law enforcement, but a military veteran. So, if something in the water scared HIM, then we as readers can only imagine it wasn’t good.

Sure, I’m naturally a little biased for Wisconsin-set stories, but Pease does a marvelous job of balancing world-building information with active narrative. This keeps the story’s pace in motion while readers continue to learn about life in this little vacation spot in Wisconsin. For those seeking a little mystery outside the gritty city life, Amy Pease is sure to transport you into the dark, unknown wild of the North Woods.

And what will you find in these first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Feb 23, 202418:14
You've Got Five Pages, Her Last Breath by Dan Padavona, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Her Last Breath by Dan Padavona, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

The first chapter of Her Last Breath is a mixed bag. On the one hand, the build-up of the prostitute Erika being propositioned and then murdered by an unknown man in an SUV is paced fairly well with strong sensory details. We can see and feel the tension of the moment between the man calling to Erika and promising a big payout and Erika choosing to ride home with this man. Plus there is a logistical reason for Erika to accept a ride from this wealthy stranger--she's miles away from the city and needs a ride back. That isolation, even with a decaying resort motel in the background, helps readers feel the character's helplessness. How else can she get home? There are some struggles here as well, though, and these are struggles many of us writers face. We know we've got to establish the setting of our story, and establish it fast. However, we've got to think about what details the readers need here and now vs. what can wait. While the first paragraph introduces us to the prostitute cleaning up after a job at a motel, the second paragraph takes us through the history of that motel...and then we get back to the prostitute cleaning up again. It's an odd moment to hear a lot of information about the place, especially when she's going to leave it. Rundown motels outside of cities is not uncommon, so it would not have hurt to keep this initial context a bit more general so the plot's momentum can pick up speed instead. After all, a detective investigating a murder has all sorts of opportunities to learn the histories of locations--why not wait until then? These are the kinds of world-building choices we writers have to watch for. As tempting as it is to dive into the setting's history right away, do readers need it right away? Probably not. It never hurts to break that information up, and drop little bits when the needs arise for characters to learn it. And what will you find in these first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Feb 09, 202420:36
You've Got Five Pages, The Narrow Road Between Desires by Patrick Rothfuss, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Narrow Road Between Desires by Patrick Rothfuss, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

I have been recommended Patrick Rothfuss’ The Name of the Wind quite often over the years, but here I am, diving into this shorter fantasy work of his instead. Even Rothfuss recommends NOT reading this short work before his other books, but I have done so...and am glad to have done so, too.

The first chapter quickly establishes our protagonist Bast, a known character from the other books. Being a complete newbie, I accepted that there could be unclear aspects of the world for me because I wasn’t familiar with the world of The Kingkiller Chronicle. Yet the first chapter starts in a very intimate, quiet way: Bast is trying to sneak out of the inn before his master notices. The innkeeper catches him, though, and sets him up with a mysterious book and a small list of errands before asking about a stranger who stopped by the inn earlier. Bast pretends to not know much of the stranger and takes off for his errands.

Doesn’t sound like much, does it? And the stranger’s name sounds like it is also something from the other books.

But that does not leave me flustered in the least. Rothfuss has a beautiful sense of the ear in his language, describing the different sounds created when a novice tries to sneak away vs. an expert vs. the artist Bast is. The visual and aural details mixed with metaphor creates a flow of prose one can easily coast upon, happy to see where the current takes them. Sure, I may choose to follow Rothfuss’ advice and NOT read The Narrow Road Between Desires before I read The Name of the Wind, but something tells me that if I stay with the current, Bast’s tale will still take me to some pretty exciting, unique places in that fantastical realm.

And what will you find in these first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jan 26, 202412:47
You've Got Five Pages, Blind Spots by Thomas Mullen, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Blind Spots by Thomas Mullen, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

This podcast covers a lot of mysteries--I mean, a LOT of mysteries--so it's fun to see how blending mystery with another genre can create something unique yet accessible for a reader. Thomas Mullen's Blind Spots opens with a traditional setup of The Cop Stakeout, but this traditional setup is warped outside our traditional experience as protagonist Owens thinks about how much life has changed because of The Blinding: a mysterious event that has led to the humanity collectively losing their eyesight. (During my podcast I read one moment that the sun was blown out of the sky--my apologies for the misread.) Now humanity has to see through "vidders," implants that has turned humanity into "vampire bats," as Owens describes it. It's a fascinating concept that allows for the science fiction aspect of this story to shine; plus, it creates a multi-layer mystery here, for alongside the mystery Owens has to solve, we readers wonder about the mystery of The Blinding. For those who are eager for a new flavor of mystery, Blind Spots may be the perfect selection to sample.


And what will you find in these first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jan 12, 202416:38
You've Got Five Pages, The Lost Library by Rebecca Stead and Wendy Mass, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Lost Library by Rebecca Stead and Wendy Mass, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

My daughter Blondie came to me a few days ago hoping I could share Rebecca Stead and Wendy Mass’ The Lost Library with you, so here we are! I can see why Blondie enjoyed this Middle-Grade tale, too. We have a by-the-rules cat determined to keep mice out of the old house’s basement but refuses to eat them. Mortimer the cat is also a bit envious, for cats do not have many words while mice do. The multiple references to this in the first chapter leave us readers wondering if those abilities with words have something to do with this Middle-Grade mystery. Overall, this first chapter does a fine job establishing the story: we have a sense of our protagonist, we have a sense of how he interacts with others, and we also have a little bit of mystery established with Mortimer describing a guilty feeling about a library book cart in the house’s basement. Why is there a book cart down there? How could old library books make a cat feel so guilty, guilty enough to shoo mice along instead of eating them? I’m intrigued! And hey, if you've got a young reader in your household, The Lost Library could be a fun little mystery to share with them for a little extra after-school read. And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Jan 05, 202410:50
You've Got Five Pages, Death in the Dark Woods by Annelise Ryan

You've Got Five Pages, Death in the Dark Woods by Annelise Ryan

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Alas, the Prologue Curse returns. Don’t get me wrong, my fellow creatives—Annelise Ryan’s premise for Death in the Dark Woods carries promise of something weird and wild, and in Wisconsin of all places! As a fellow Wisconsinite, I’m all in for that kind of mystery. While the prologue starts a bit slow with a hunter failing to shoot a buck, the tension and pacing quickly mount to a chaotic, lethal attack. Ryan provides just enough detail for readers to experience the terror without getting gory; plus, readers are left in the dark as to what kind of animal killed the hunter. Considering Bigfoot is mentioned in the dust jacket, we as readers can certainly make a guess or two, ahem.

Then the official Chapter 1 brings all that tension to a halt as we restart the story with protagonist Morgan taking care of customers and chatting up the Chief of Police. Once again, we get a fine hook of a prologue only to be reeled in for a slow first chapter. Now the Chief is asking if Morgan will speak to someone in the DNR, so I’m hoping this means Chapter 2 takes readers to the woods where the hunter died. I just wish the narrative didn’t require slamming the brakes on the pacing in order to do that. Still, I’m happy to support local authors, especially ones with a quirky premise like this. A cryptozoologist hunting down monsters in Wisconsin? Let’s go!

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Dec 29, 202320:20
You've Got Five Pages, The Wager by David Grann, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Wager by David Grann, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

I think for the first time ever, I find the author’s note to be a compelling hook. David Grann’s The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny, and Murder, a fascinating mix of true crime and nautical history. Grann shares a quick paragraph before the prologue describing the “debris” he sorted through of conflicting accounts and half-truths and that he won’t reach a conclusion for us—we must make our own conclusions as to what really happened a couple of centuries ago. It’s a cold case without any clear-cut closure…and I’m all for it.

The prologue then gives readers some basic context for what happened regarding the British ship The Wager: originally sent to overtake a Spanish galleon, it goes MIA only to appear battered and beaten off the coast of Brazil with a starved fraction of its original crew. Yet another smaller vessel with a few more survivors lands later, and these two parties provide very, VERY different accounts of what went down on The Wager and the island where all were shipwrecked. Now considering the unique terminology that comes with nautical period writing, I don’t think Grann’s book is for everyone, but if you’re prepared to lose yourself amongst the waves of the past, then I’m sure you’ll enjoy Grann’s The Wager.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Dec 22, 202318:43
You've Got Five Pages, Distant Sons by Tim Johnston, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Distant Sons by Tim Johnston, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

For the first time in a while we have us a prologue, folks. But what a prologue. We are transported to a 1976 summer evening tense with sport and hormones and mystery as two brothers run off to play a baseball game…but only one returns. It’s a damn beautiful prologue, the cadence of the prose flowing like a river such boys would splash in to cool off after a hard nine innings in the schoolyard. The narrator focuses on the experience of the elder brother, stuck with his younger brother for the game, so caught up in the game he forgets about the brother altogether. As he walks home through the woods he remembers the boy who had gone missing a year ago—and as the prologue ends, it sounds like the younger brother has met the same fate.

Now one of my biggest beefs about prologues of this caliber is that they’re often some sort of cover for a lousy first chapter, one that brings the momentum to a grinding halt and dumps us with information before attempting to restart the narrative action. For Johnston, this is not the case. Granted, we have been shifted to a new time—2018—and ride with a new character named Sean. However, we are not given a ton of exposition—hardly any at all, really. We are watching Sean deal with his busted truck and his prediction of how his future interaction with his father may go when he gets home. I stopped at this point due to time, so how this broken truck impacts Sean, I cannot say.

What I will say is that the prologue is a brilliant study of powerful prose that balances a lush setting with the relatable pangs of a boy aspiring to be more and with the looming fear of nefarious danger in the background. Even if you don’t want to read the rest of the novel, I recommend fellow writers check out Distant Sons for the prologue alone.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Dec 15, 202320:45
You've Got Five Pages, Thorn Hedge by T. Kingfisher, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Thorn Hedge by T. Kingfisher, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the story of others to see how they do it!

I admit, I am a little bias with today’s selection. When I saw T. Kingfisher had a new dark take on a classic story, I had to jump on it. Thorn Hedge does not disappoint. Its opening pages are told from the Fairy’s perspective, describing a crushingly long passage of time as she guards a mysterious tower and the thorn hedge surrounding it. Granted, we as writers are always told to “show, don’t tell.” Kingfisher does the opposite in order to reflect on how much time passes under the Fairy’s watchful eye. Initially the wall of thorns is massive and obvious, drawing the attention of princes and ambitious boys from all over, but as generations come and go, the everyday nature creeps up and grows over this wall. Yet the Fairy fears that the story—yes, the story—of the tower and its secret has not died in time. I do love how Kingfisher focuses on the power of words, of story, and how THAT is to be feared rather than any kind of magic or weapon of the world.

Clues are given to readers to help gauge time, such as the Plague masks of the Black Death and the red crosses worn by knights during the Crusades. I admit, I started getting impatient when we reached the Crusades, for it was starting to feel like we would only see this story as a walk through time, but behold! On the sixth page comes a knight. And then, my fellow creatures, the true narrative starts.

So, if you are one for brief, vivid tellings of classic tales, I don’t think you’ll go wrong with Kingfisher here. I LOVED her take on The Fall of the House of Usher, so I’m stoked to see what she does with this Grimm, dark tale. 😊

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Dec 08, 202318:52
You've Got Five Pages, Midnight is the Darkest Hour by Ashley Winstead, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Midnight is the Darkest Hour by Ashley Winstead, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the story of others to see how they do it!

The opening pages of Ashley Winstead’s Midnight is the Darkest Hour are a real treat to read. Once we got past the trigger warning of violent things that often happen in suspense thrillers, we are transported to a small Louisiana town working to survive by a swamp. While folks are claimed by the swamp every year, this time a fisherman discovers a bashed-in skull. The sheriff holds a press conference which of course draws in the whole of the small town, our narrator keeping herself off and to the side to observe the spectacle.

Winstead wisely begins the story with the skull and doesn’t dwell much on sensory details. While I’d love to experience this swamp through her prose, as a writer, I appreciate Winstead wants us invested in the mystery first, so the narrative focus is on the skull and how the town reacts to the sheriff’s announcement of—gasp!—a homicide investigation, the town’s first in twenty years. We as readers can easily be shocked that such a long time has passed without some sort of criminal death in a town; in fact, that can certainly be a reason why we read on, for we can then be skeptical of what this town is really like with its five thousand “Christian souls” and few “Godless heathens.” The narrator also drops hints early on that she was expecting this announcement to come from the sheriff at some point, that she’s been waiting for it for years. But why? We don’t know yet, which makes me wonder how reliable this narrator really is. I guess we have to keep reading to find out.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Dec 01, 202318:06
You've Got Five Pages, North of Nowhere by Allison Brennan, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, North of Nowhere by Allison Brennan, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

One thing that drew me to Allison Brennan's North of Nowhere was the promise of siblings depending on each other for survival while on the run from their murderous father through a wintry wilderness. After plenty of stories where romance is the primary focus of the characters' relationship, I was ready for some family bonding.

The first chapter doesn't really give a chance for that to develop just yet, though. Instead, we get protector Tony endlessly thinking about how time is of the essence in getting these kids out of their small Montana town because the father's goons have been spotted. I don't mind starting the novel with the goons showing up--after all, that's where the narrative arc begins, not with one of the kids' sports games or something. However, because Tony is thinking and thinking and thinking and THINKING about the plans--what he wants to do, what they'll have to do, why they have to do any of it--I lose all sense of time and urgency. There are a couple of blips in that first chapter where Tony and the kids are actively doing something, but they are lost in the endless scope of Tony's thoughts.

On a side note, the prose itself is clear and straightforward, almost to the point of being cheesy. For instance:

"It would be faster, safer, safer to hide until they could disappear again. He’d do anything to protect Chris and Ryan? Anything. Even kill again."


How can one read that and NOT say, "Dunh dunh DUNH!"? As the pages progressed, I began to feel like we were embarking on a bit of action schlock like Arnold Schwarzenegger's Commando. And for folks like me, who do enjoy a bit of schlock, that sounds just fine. :) But after reading this chapter, I have a hard time agreeing with the cover blurb that this is "a gripping, eerie thriller." So if you are looking for that sort of thriller, I'm not sure North of Nowhere will suit your palette.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Nov 10, 202321:51
You've Got Five Pages, Star Bringer by Tracy Wolff and Nina Croft, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Star Bringer by Tracy Wolff and Nina Croft, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

With a gorgeous cover design and a surprisingly long trigger warning, Star Bringer caught my eye and exposed me to two romance writers I’ve never read before: Nina Croft and Tracy Wolff. Their publication histories are both quite impressive, showing the two clearly know a thing or two about writing in the romance genre. The book’s blurb promises a combination of Firefly and The Breakfast Club, and after reading the opening scene featuring a princess and her companions, that promise seems to hold true. Personality exudes from different members of the group, which is great, and the voice of the princess narrating is quite distinctive and personable. The first pages use the conflict between princess and empress to set up the true stakes of this story’s cosmic work: the empire may be destroyed if a certain scientist isn’t found, and it’s up to the princess to find out what’s going on.

When it comes to characterization and a hook, all is accomplished with aplomb in the opening pages. My only remaining concern is about the worldbuilding. When a writer commits to a genre like science fiction, that writer must be ready to create something new and unique with depth and age. But the princesses’ observations about anything sci-fi-related felt extremely vague, so I do hope this won’t be the case when other characters become the narrator.

That brings me to my one other concern: the dust jacket promises a primary cast of seven for this story. A glance at the chapters reveals different characters narrate different chapters. Will everyone narrate? Plenty of writers struggle just to make two characters’ narrative voices sound distinctive, let alone seven. I suppose we’ll just have to wait and see!

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Nov 03, 202318:05
You've Got Five Pages, The Longmire Defense by Craig Johnson, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Longmire Defense by Craig Johnson, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Now for the record, we’re not technically in the first five pages here. The Longmire Defense is the NINETEENTH installment in Craig Johnson’s Longmire series, so this story-world and cast of characters was established quite some time ago. Still, I was in the mood for a mystery in the mountainous West, and seeing the dust jacket promise a cold case investigation won me over.

The opening pages appear to pick up after whatever chaos the eighteenth book (Hell and Back) brought upon Sheriff Walt Longmire. Longmire is staying with family out in the middle of nowhere when his undersheriff comes and asks him to accompany her on a basic search and rescue. According to the dust jacket, this search and rescue will lead to the reopening of the promised cold case.

So I will say that Johnson is quick to put the newest tale’s plot into motion. When one’s so deep into a series, one really doesn’t see the need for much characterization work, and that’s fine. Still, it took some extra effort to catch the rhythms of dialogue between Longmire and his daughter, which pulled me out of the story. For those who have enjoyed Longmire so far (and considering the story will be adapted for Netflix, there must be quite a few of you), I’ve no doubt The Longmire Defense will be a welcome addition. For those of us who are new to Longmire, I am intrigued enough by these opening pages to hunt down the first book, The Cold Dish.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Oct 27, 202317:31
You've Got Five Pages, Clytemnestra by Costanza Casati, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Clytemnestra by Costanza Casati, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!


One of my favorite BBC miniseries of all time is I, Claudius, which is based on two historical fiction novels by Robert Graves. When reading the opening pages of Costanza Casati’s debut novel Clytemnestra, I could not help but recall Claudius’ childhood from the opening chapters of Graves’ novel. The prose is vivid, but not flowery. The action is raw, but not unfeeling. Spartan princess Clytemnestra is determined to prove she can hunt as well as any Spartan boy, and she even goes to a place of death—a ravine where infant and criminal alike are thrown to their deaths—to find her prey. Casati’s choice to begin her novel with only Clytemnestra helps readers not only acquaint themselves with the Spartan mindset about life and death, but to get a clear-cut glimpse at the titular character as well. Considering the large cast list and family tree provided before the novel, this alone time with the protagonist should help readers see her shine all the more clearly when the stage is filled with supporting characters. If you are one who enjoys historical fiction of ancient times, then I feel Clytemnestra may be a worthy queen for you to meet.


And what will you find in those first five pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

Oct 20, 202314:21
You've Got Five Pages, Whalefall by Daniel Kraus, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Whalefall by Daniel Kraus, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it! Firstly, I apologize for that two-month break, fellow creatives. Blondie broke her leg a couple of days after my August podcast, and it’s been a whirlwind of doctor and therapist visits since then. Now that we’re finally finding a new rhythm with school and recovery, I can return to my library’s New Release shelf to see what’s happening! And Blondie helped me pick this one, too. 😊 “Hey, Mom, isn’t that like the James Bond movie Skyfall?”

Well I don’t think Daniel Kraus’ Whalefall has anything to do 007, Kiddo, but I do wonder if the font for the title was made to look like the Bond film title on purpose. 😊

ANYWAY, the opening pages of Kraus’ work are quite compelling. I was admittedly skeptical when I saw Gillian Flynn’s generic “Astoundingly great” blurb on the front cover—what does that even mean?!

The first two brief chapters not only introduce us to protagonist Jay, but also his conflict with his family, his difficult relationship with his father, and the path to redemption he feels he must take in order to come to terms with his father’s death. That’s a hell of a lot to pack in just a few pages, but Kraus succeeds while also providing a unique rhythm of prose, the long, contemplative thoughts punctuated with brief lines of intense sensory detail. It’s a rhythm I’m willing to listen to for a while, and if you’re looking for a unique read about a teen’s journey into the waters to combat his grief, then Whalefall is certainly worth a look.

And what will you find in those first five pages? Let's find out!

Cheers!

Oct 13, 202315:40
You've Got Five Pages, Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader’s engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let’s study the stories of others to see how they do it!

As a born and bred fantasy lover who’s raised a girl obsessed with the Wings of Fire series, I had to grab Rebecca Yarros’ Fourth Wing from the library’s new release shelf. Dragon stories are always in demand, whether it’s for the sheer escapist adventure or the exploration of the bond between a human protagonist and their dragon, or anything in between. Now the first pages of Fourth Wing provide no dragons, but they do provide an introduction to the brutal world our protagonist Violet must live in. As a twenty-year-old in their militaristic kingdom, she must join a service like all other twenty-year-olds; the difference here is that the scribe training she had under her father has been tossed aside by her mother, one of the highest generals of the kingdom. Violet must be a dragon rider, or die trying.

The concept itself is neat and definitely had me engaged from the outset. I only wish the opening pages were more than a bickering match between Violet’s mother and sister, who also serves the army as a dragon rider. The argument feels like it’s there solely to give readers a bunch of establishing information of the story and its stakes for Violet; while the information is certainly useful, it does cause the argument to drag out far more than it needed to. Still, the premise here is very promising, and for those who enjoyed tales like Christopher Paolini’s Eragon or Naomi Novik’s His Majesty’s Dragon, Rebecca Yarros’ Fourth Wing will be a perfect addition to your book hoard.

And what will you learn in these opening pages? Let’s find out! Cheers!

 

Aug 18, 202320:51
You've Got Five Pages, The Big Sugar by Mary Logue, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Big Sugar by Mary Logue, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

It’s prologue time, folks, but I’ll give Mary Logue props here for effectively using a prologue to tackle a LOT for her book The Big Sugar: A Brigid Reardon Mystery. The first section provides a vivid description of the Wyoming Plains and Rocky Mountains and how they contrast with protagonist Brigid’s Irish homeland. Since this novel is set in the 1880s, this opening prose not only gives readers a sense of time and place, but of the narrator’s own voice, too. It feels fitting for the period while remaining accessible for the modern reader, which is always important.

The remaining sections of the prologue (there are four total) each carry their own job to prepare readers for this second installment of Logue’s Western Mystery series. The second section provides a quick rundown of the first book’s events so that readers aren’t wondering about how’s who and why folks would listen to this pioneering narrator in the first place when it comes to crime-solving. The third section brings up to the present day for Brigid and a grisly discovery of her neighbor’s body hanging in a tree. It’s not clear if this neighbor was present in the first book; I’ll presume it, as the fourth section gives Brigid a chance to work through the emotional weight of losing her neighbor (let alone discovering her hanging dead in a tree). There are allusions to cattle barons and Ella’s own small herd, which promises a “David and Goliath” style story of the lone soul seeking justice against the wealthy and powerful. It’s a common Western kind of conflict, and I’m sure those who love a mystery will appreciate Logue’s careful research and eloquent voice to build a compelling story. And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Aug 04, 202320:26
You've Got Five Pages, The Senator's Wife by Liv Constantine, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Senator's Wife by Liv Constantine, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! After the more somber, experimental style of Oates' book last week, I'm actually rather happy to have a suspenseful thriller that reads like something from the Hallmark Channel. Liv Constantine's The Senator's Wife opens with a cross-couple conflict at a beach house, where husbands and wives have to comfort each other because one wife (Peg) accuses her senator husband of infidelity. While the scene reads a bit cheesy, I respect Constantine's quick pacing through the scene along with the establishment of the conflict and low-key mystery to get things started. The prose is not flowery or unique; rather, it's direct and clear like a screenplay, which is another reason I can't help but think of "made for TV movie" as I read this. The plus side of this approach, though, is Constantine's prose is very accessible, so for those who want a popcorn mystery with a touch of cheese, I'm sure Constantine's latest will fit those tastes perfectly.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jul 28, 202319:38
You've Got Five Pages, 48 Clues into the Disappearance of My Sister by Joyce Carol Oates, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, 48 Clues into the Disappearance of My Sister by Joyce Carol Oates, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! I'll be honest here, folks--After just a few pages, I felt exhausted reading Oates' 48 Clues into the Disappearance of My Sister. Oates takes a more experimental, non-linear narrative approach; while vivid, lush, and highly stylized, the prose also doubles back on itself again and again and again to the point you wonder if you'll ever move on from the observation of the first paragraph. Being Oates, I'm sure the story here will be powerful and engaging for those who enjoy this style of writing. However, if you're looking for a simple piece of escapism, this particular book is not for you.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jul 21, 202315:04
You've Got Five Pages, Ink Blood Sister Scribe by Emma Törzs, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Ink Blood Sister Scribe by Emma Törzs, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


I was so happy to discover a new fantasy release at my local library--that's rare! I don't like grabbing hyped books by big news book clubs, but I can see why folks dig Törzs' Ink Blood Sister Scribe. The prose is very descriptive and balanced between action and reflection. The dialogue feels a little awkward at times, but the characterization carries it through, especially when you have such a compelling family dynamic. How could a book kill the father? Why did one sister have to run away but not the other? Is the mother really dead? Because if she is, why must one daughter "never let her in"? I may not be a fan of prologues, but using the prologue to establish the death of the father from one sister's perspective then allows the first chapter to focus on the other sister, allowing her to not only establish the passage of time and her unique life choices, but the mystery in conflicting details about the mother. If you're keen on a contemporary fantasy with a bit of danger and family drama, then I'm sure Törzs' will meet your needs.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jul 14, 202320:42
You've Got Five Pages, The Devil's Blaze by Robert J. Harris, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Devil's Blaze by Robert J. Harris, to Tell Me You're Good.

Jul 07, 202323:12
You've Got Five Pages, Storm Watch by C.J. Box, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Storm Watch by C.J. Box, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


C.J. Box’s Joe Pickett is not a boring protagonist, nor do the opening pages of Storm Watch feel stale. This game warden clearly has principles when it comes to treating wildlife with dignity and respect, whether it’s putting an elk out of its misery or capturing a wolf before it kills another creature–cattle, or human. But it’s the first few lines that really impressed me with Box’s prose: Late March in the foothills of the Bighorn Mountains wasn’t yet spring by any means, but there were a growing number of days when spring could be dreamt of. For Wyoming game warden Joe Pickett, this wasn’t one of those days. This was a day that would both start and end with blood on the snow.



Right off the bat, we get a sense of the narrator’s dry sense of humor. (As a Midwesterner, I can empathize with the sentiment, too.) That touch of humor comes right along with important information about our protagonist, where he is, what the environment is like, and what he has to deal with: bloodshed. Now what’s really cool is that the “blood on the snow” is NOT just an allusion to his work with wildlife; in fact, we as readers know from the dust jacket that there is a mysterious death to be solved in this hard wilderness. So Box’s turn of phrase here is particularly effective: it connects to the opening scene and the protagonist’s profession as well as foreshadows the rise in action to come.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jun 23, 202322:37
You've Got Five Pages, The Golden Spoon by Jessa Maxwell, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Golden Spoon by Jessa Maxwell, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


So I was initially bummed when I saw The Golden Spoon by Jessa Maxwell had not one prologue, but TWO. I also glanced ahead and saw that frequent head-hopping is in a reader's future, for the story follows the many perspectives of baking contestants on a cooking show at a hoity-toity New England estate. So if you're not a fan of constantly changing POVs, this may not be the book for you.


That said, the first prologue does a wonderful job of balancing a little backstory with current action. Since we are with Betsy, the estate's owner and creator of this baking competition, we are quickly learning her desperation to keep the show and estate afloat while begrudgingly taking on some "grunt work" of checking camera equipment on a dark and stormy night. Her thoughts allude to some previous debacle, of conflict with the cohost, of possible problems with the contestants--everything seems to be going wrong this season, and the dark'n'bloody discovery she makes in the camera tent--well, it's the icing on the cake, isn't it?


The *second* prologue is a news release from *two weeks earlier.* So yes, we already have a flashback and we're not even in the proper novel yet. Still, I appreciate Maxwell's move to utilize a news release for providing quick breakdowns of the cast--that is, the baking contestants. It's an eclectic mix of people with their own voices and skills, all of which sound like they could potentially get applied in a murderous situation. As a writer, I can also see how such a breakdown could help with easy refreshes of a character's voice and perspective so that one doesn't mess up these character traits and languages. As Janet Evanovich highlights in her blurb, this book has strong Clue vibes, and I am ALWAYS up for a good game of Clue. :)


What will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jun 09, 202321:53
You've Got Five Pages, Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


We've got another delight here, my friends! Now I know Sanderson's a big name in fantasy writing, but I wasn't expecting a Jane Austen-style cover for one of his books. Apparently, Tress of the Emerald Sea was to be something for his wife, so its voice, characters, world, etc. are not meant to be connected to anything else he's written. This is fine, as I'm one of those heathens who's never read Sanderson. :) I do hope his other books have such a playful narrative voice! That's what hooks you in these first few pages, honestly. The first chapter is almost entirely exposition about where protagonist Tress lives: a putrid island where nothing can grow and only salt can save you from the cosmic spores raining from the sky. I was keenly reminded of Tolkien's asides to readers as I went, though this narrator's tongue is a bit more, shall we say, barbed: "Ships sailed that dust like ships sail water here, and you should not find that so unusual. How many other planets have you visited? Perhaps they all sail oceans of pollen, and your home is the freakish one."


We learn more about the world than we do about Tress in this opening chapter, but it's enough to keep us going. For a girl who insists she's happy on an island where the government orders the residents to remain until death, she still collects cups decorated with things that can't survive where she lives. For a girl who does her best to tame her hair and be socially presentable, she never seems to succeed. For a girl with a family name like Glorf ("don't judge," says the narrator), she deserves a chance to be more. And hopefully, we'll read on to see just that.


What will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jun 02, 202316:53
You've Got Five Pages, The Ferryman by Justin Cronin, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Ferryman by Justin Cronin, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Ever hear of the sci-fi cult classic Logan's Run? It's a 1976 film about a world where everyone is young and perfect, and life will always give you just what you want. Once your hand's computer light starts flashing, you have to go be "renewed"--or as one quickly finds out, you die.

This immediately came to mind when I picked up Justin Cronin's The Ferryman, so I was a little wary of how this deceiving utopia would compare with the likes of Logan's Run. Happily, my concern was unnecessary. The prologue (yes, a prologue) introduces readers to the "mother" of the book's protagonist. She is preparing to leave all that she knows; since the dust jacket says that folks of a certain age in this utopia are taken away to be "renewed," we can safely assume she's preparing herself for that journey. Unlike Logan's Run, it appears this renewal is almost like a reincarnation: the aged or taken away, bodies de-aged and minds erased, to come back to the island as teenagers to start life again as wards to selected adults of the city. Yes, this prologue is a lot of exposition, but the prose fits the moment, for the woman is describing all that she says as she says farewell to her life. She then recalls meeting her ward, the protagonist Proctor, and is surprised by the maternal feelings she holds. She doesn't understand them.


And frankly, the alienness of family feeling is what I find so compelling here. As a writer, we can create whatever kind of world we want, and I see Cronin's done precisely that. Yet something must be relatable for the reader, or they won't feel the story is accessible. Most people have their own sense of family, whether by birth or friendship, but the fact that this society has turned that sense of family into an alien feeling leads readers to question what else has been essentially removed from the human experience--perhaps the soul itself?


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

May 26, 202321:11
You've Got Five Pages, Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Oh, this is a fun one, my fellow creatives. Jesse Q. Sutanto has a marvelous narrative voice for Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers, which made this first chapter a delight to read. Even though this chapter is exposition, we as readers can still see the unfussable Vera Wong launch herself into her morning routine. While this may not sound very interesting for a hook, the narrator's lighthearted, playful tone mixed with Vera's eccentric personality hook readers into loving this old lady very quickly. Plus, using the exposition helps us realize that this morning routine isn't unique or special to the narrative--rather, this is how she always is, from texting her son at 4:31am to tell him he should be awake, to counting every one of her 3,112 steps on her morning walk. Yet even this first chapter is not without its emotional weight, for that same morning walk takes her by the tai chi group her husband, long passed, used to attend. In fact, the chapter ends with Vera, while resolute and determined to continue her day as normal, cannot completely silence her sadness over the dwindling relationship with her son since her husband passed. It's an artfully done first chapter, full of humor and uniqueness with an emotional tug at the end...all disguised in an elderly lady's morning routine.


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

May 19, 202321:50
You've Got Five Pages, Birnam Wood by Eleanor Catton, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Birnam Wood by Eleanor Catton, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


For the first time, I have to say that this novel may very well need an engaging prologue to hook readers. Granted, at the outset, Eleanor Catton's Birnam Wood isn't bad. The prose is dense but vivid, its opening paragraphs dedicated to establishing the setting of a landslide in New Zealand and the aftermath of a small town in isolation. We meet Mira in the third paragraph: she is described to us as well as how she is willfully using an alias and misleading real estate agents of that isolated small town because...we don't know.


So, we as readers have a compelling reason to read on. We want to know why our main character is not being honest about her identity and motivations.


Yet the more I read the first chapter, the more exposition I got. Paragraph after paragraph details what Mira reads in her research of one person in that town. That's it. The curiosity I had for Mira's motivations dwindled with every paragraph of exposition. Perhaps I was spoiled by Janice Hallet's The Appeal, which also gave us such research, but in its original format of emails and newspaper clippings vs. an omniscient narrator telling us the protagonist is reading these things. The middle man, in a sense, was cut out in The Appeal; plus, reading the original messages from characters gave us a sense of different characters and their voices. Five pages into Birnam Wood, I only know that "Mira read on." Now, chances are this story is a slow burn with the action coming later on, and that's fine for those content to wait. For the picky, impatient reader such as myself, however, I think I'll go back to the New Release Shelf.



And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

May 12, 202320:54
You've Got Five Pages, The Crane Husband by Kelly Barnhill, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Crane Husband by Kelly Barnhill, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Ooo, folks, this is a neat one. The atmosphere of a dark fairy tale hangs heavy in the old farmhouse where Kelly Barnhill's The Crane Husband takes place. Our narrator is a fifteen-year-old girl who's become the caregiver to both her little brother and mother--a mother who, on this day, brings home a large crane and calls him their father. We as readers are as agog as the little brother, while the teen is doing her best to maintain a cynical sanity to her mother's artistic whims. The fact we as readers do not know about the crane being dressed in human clothing until the second page irked me at first, but as a writer I respect Barnhill's choice to show the reactions to the initial shock of a crane in the kitchen before the next shock of the crane in clothes. The third shock comes when the mother shows intimate displays of affection to the crane--and the crane reciprocates. The chapter ends with the teen blowing this off, eager for the crane's departure like her mother's other lovers, but the chapter ends with yet another masterful twist by Barnhill*:


My mother wasn't one to keep anything around, save for me and Michael. So I wasn't particularly worried about the crane.

I should have been worried about the crane.


With such a bizarre start, I can only imagine where Barnhill's tale can go from here.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!



*If I refer to Kelly Barnhill as Kate at some point, I humbly apologize. I goofed!

May 05, 202321:08
You've Got Five Pages, The Writing Retreat by Julia Bartz, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Writing Retreat by Julia Bartz, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Well, what do you know? Here the author from last week's episode left a positive blurb on the book for this week--The Writing Retreat by Julia Bartz. The opening pages introduce us to Alex, a woman who is hung up on a broken friendship with Wren while attending a book release party for a mutual friend. At times the voice really shines in this prose--a bit immature, a bit creative, but overall unique. Other times the word choices do not jive with that personality--who on earth says "unselfconsciously affable"? But it was the last paragraph I read that promised redeeming qualities to the voice, for that last paragraph gave us a very clear, colorful picture of just how badly Alex latched herself to Wren. Alex describes all sorts of glittery, beautiful dreams of a friendship with Wren mere moments after meeting her at a job. This not only explains why Alex keeps lamenting the loss of Wren and why she can't stop thinking about her; it makes us wonder what Wren really thinks of Alex. We could very well be dealing with one character obsessing over another, fantasizing about the scale of that relationship while the truth is quite different. If so, then this suspenseful read just got more...suspensefuler.


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Apr 28, 202320:45
You've Got Five Pages, The Appeal by Janice Hallett, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Appeal by Janice Hallett, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

This review, I'm afraid, is going to be rather short, as this novel is not quite like other novels. Rather than a traditional narrative and/or paragraph structure, Janice Hallett's The Appeal is created with emails, text messages, and other media snippets compiled for two lawyers to study in preparation for tackling a murder case. On the one hand, this means we're not getting any details regarding setting or character appearance. On the other hand, we're getting a wealth of first-person perspectives over a period of time that *should* guide us readers to the ultimate solution of the mystery. As a reader, I'm definitely intrigued. As a writer, I admire Hallett taking on this risk. It's a dangerous thing to essentially tell readers, "You don't have all the materials. Hopefully, it's in the right order. Good luck!" It'd be all too easy to just withhold all sorts of things so you can just dump it all in the resolution later. Hopefully, Hallett does not do this. The extra challenge is also to make sure the writing voices for all these characters is consistently different. So far, I couldn't help but chuckle that one character only writes in two-word responses compared to the gushing emails from another character. It's an interesting dynamic, and I've got to continue at least a bit more into the tale to see where these emails take me.


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!


Apr 21, 202318:11
You've Got Five Pages, Homecoming by Kate Morton, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Homecoming by Kate Morton, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Well, we had a good run. The prologue has returned, and a rambling prologue, at that. Kate Morton's Homecoming opens with a woman named Isabel. Isabel is pondering various things while hanging up some bunting for a New Year's Day family celebration. The prose itself is well-crafted, and there are certainly some interesting lines that help us feel the weight of natural Australian dangers on Isabel as she's out and alone. Actually, Morton's quite good at dropping hints of danger and trouble within Isabel without Isabel actually saying these are troubles--moments relating to her depression, her marriage problems, her desire to do away with her own kids, her "guilty conscience" and her determination to "make things right"--it's all quite good foreshadowing for SOMEthing to happen. And the prologue does end with the promise of something bad about to happen.

The downside, at least to me, comes with how long it takes to reach that moment. We spend the entire prologue with Isabel thinking. That's it. Now a few pages of thoughts can be well done, for as I mentioned, Morton's cleverly hiding hints of danger within Isabel's psyche. But it's a slow, slow process through all of Isabel's thoughts, and by prologue's end I'm saying, "Thank goodness THAT'S over." That's not what a writer wants a reader to feel. As writers, we've got to make every line count. We shouldn't need to hide a hint of foreshadowing beneath a mountain of exposition. A little goes a long way, whether one's writing a short story, a novel, or anything in between. And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Apr 14, 202321:17
You've Got Five Pages, The Whalebone Theatre by Joanna Quinn, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Whalebone Theatre by Joanna Quinn, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


We return to historical drama in Joanna Quinn's The Whalebone Theatre, and know what? I don't mind. The story is geared to follow Cristabel Seagrave from toddlerhood to adulthood spying on Nazis in France, so our first impression of the protagonist is her impish, defiant nature. Oh, this kid is great fun, and I wouldn't mind following the toddler Cristabel around for a whole novel. Quinn does marvelous work as a writer in keeping the prose vivid and active, while also throwing in the occasional childish term like "nothingy." It's a lovely balance for adult readers who may not appreciate the quirky language of a child, while also sounding true as a voice for a young character. We watch Cristabel meet her stepmother for the first time, and this occasion clearly marks a strained relationship for the future--any stepmother who refers to a child as "it" is not all that keen on children, to be sure! So while we didn't see the whalebones just yet, I enjoyed seeing much of Cristabel's personality and imagination shine through so much in this opening scene. Those are the character traits an author wants to establish early so that the protagonist's later choices not only propel the story forward, but also ring true to the character we're happy to know. And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Apr 07, 202319:35
You've Got Five Pages, Babel by R.F. Kuang, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Babel by R.F. Kuang, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Goodness, ANOTHER happy find! I don't know if I've ever had such a run with great books on this podcast. :) Babel by R.F. Kuang not only has a fascinating book cover, but an intriguing premise as well: the world's magic is manipulated through words and silver, and in the early 1800s, England is the master of that magic. The opening is not set in England, though, but in China, where a young boy awaits his death from cholera, the same illness that had already taken his family. A mysterious British professor knows where he lives and magically heals him before taking him to the English Factory. Where this factory actually is I've no idea, as this would take us past five pages, but I can safely say the first five pages do a wonderful job of hooking us as readers. Kuang's use of descriptive language wastes no time ensnaring us with her description of the boy's mother dying of cholera and his acceptance of his fate. On the second page, we're already shown a magic healing; while it doesn't tell us how the boy is healed, it's enough worldbuilding for us to know that some have magic, and others do not. As a writer, I'm also intrigued by the details dropped about the mysterious professor and English woman who helped raise the boy. What is it about this particular child that has drawn distinctively different English people to him, thousands of miles away in China? I don't know, but I'm excited to find out. :)


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Mar 31, 202321:18
You've Got Five Pages, A Mansion for Murder by Frances Brody, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, A Mansion for Murder by Frances Brody, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Another happy surprise! When I saw Frances Brody's A Mansion for Murder had a prologue, I immediately rolled my eyes. Yet that little prologue provided a lovely scene with just enough ominous foreshadowing. Does the prologue create a "bait and switch" for a boring first chapter? Nope! Chapter One gives a few brief paragraphs about the protagonist and why she's an investigator, then dives right into the letter she receives summoning her to her latest case. Considering this is the thirteenth (!!!) book of the series, I did not feel lost or behind. Brody's introduction of the character is a fine piece of succinct exposition, giving readers just enough to go on regarding the protagonist and her career. Plus, by using first-person prose, Brody can have Shackleton essentially "introduce herself" so readers can understand Shackleton's frank and fearless personality. It's a smart strategy for a writer. The cadence of the prose, too, is well formulated, the movement of consonants and vowels making it pleasant to read aloud. For those searching for a cozy mystery, this may be just the literary escape you've been looking for.


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Mar 24, 202319:39
You've Got Five Pages, Hester by Laurie Lico Albanese, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Hester by Laurie Lico Albanese, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

I was pleasantly surprised by this one. I did not read the blurb for Hester by Laurie Lico Albanese, but by the end of the first page I realized we were dealing with a character who inspires Nathaniel Hawthorne to write The Scarlett Letter. It's an interesting concept, especially since Isobel, the protagonist here, does seem to be experiencing some sort of magic by seeing the world in vibrant colors. Her mother scares her into keeping it secret, for witch-burnings can and do still happen in Scotland in the early 1800s. The prose itself reminds me of Louise Erdrich--lines to experience by sound as much as by sight. And for one who doesn't dive into historical fiction much, I found myself intrigued by Isobel's determination to enjoy the colors of her visions "safely": through needlework as a seamstress. If you are not one for historical fiction, I understand passing on this one. For those who want a unique journey to the past or to experience a classic story from a fresh perspective, then I highly recommend Albanese's imagination here.


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Mar 17, 202320:51
You've Got Five Pages, The City We Became by N.K. Jemisin, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The City We Became by N.K. Jemisin, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Twenty-two pages of prologue? Really?!?

Okay, that gripe aside, the opening pages of The City We Became by N.K. Jemisin do successfully balance hints at the fantastical while remaining grounded in New York City. Our protagonist, who's unnamed in the opening pages, hears something breathing and calling back to her whenever she sings or paints the city. It's a unique balance of active exposition that helps readers see and feel the same unsettled curiosity as the protagonist. The only interaction we see the protagonist has with another human being is Paulo, who seems to have this mentor kind of position of a side character. Paulo is trying to share his own moment of seeing something alive in the depths of the city and knows the protagonist can hear whatever that thing is. But the protagonist doesn't care about a thing; she cares about getting some food in her stomach and having a safe place to sleep from one night to the next.

So this story is something of a slow burn. I'm not saying that's bad; Jemisin isn't shy that this is the first book of a series, so Book 1 will of course be full of dropped seeds and mystery boxes to compel readers to read. And these opening pages do have moments alluding to the fantastical hidden among the everyday grit and grime of the city. Why this had to be inside a huge prologue I don't know, but for those who enjoy urban fantasy stories, I'm sure Jemisin will not disappoint.

What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Mar 17, 202320:53
You've Got Five Pages, Killers of a Certain Age by Deanna Raybourn, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Killers of a Certain Age by Deanna Raybourn, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


Deanna Raybourn's Killers of a Certain Age certainly needs no prologue to hook readers! Instead, her opening chapter starts with the protagonists preparing for their first mission--not only as stewardesses, but as assassins, too. I mean, when the third and fourth sentences of the novel are "It's not murder," Helen corrects. "It's an assassination, and you can make an effort to look nice.", you as a reader know you're in for a fun time. The opening scene introduces us to a group of women new to this "life of lies" as they prepare for their first mission under their supervisors posing as airline pilots. The dialogue drags a smidge on the fourth page, but there's enough personality in the exchange that we as readers are okay with the slow preparation, as we are learning to differentiate the character traits of the team. Plus, a brief reflection by one of the women helps remind readers just how much is at stake: not just the mission, but the lives of everyone on the mission, too. The use of movie lines during the exchange also helps emphasize the timeframe we are dealing with, as this first chapter is, essentially, a flashback to the protagonists' first mission in 1979. The majority of the story is to take place in the present day when all these female assassins are older. For one who loved the movies Red, Harry Brown, Sea Wolves, and yes, Arsenic and Old Lace, I'm really excited to see what time does to these ladies--and what happens to those foolish enough to underestimate them.


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Mar 03, 202320:33
You've Got Five Pages, The Last Party by Clare Mackintosh, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Last Party by Clare Mackintosh, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Another thriller, another prologue. Is this a thing? Are thrillers required to have prologues in order to achieve publication these days?

Not that I'm complaining in this case. Clare Mackintosh's The Last Party contains beautiful setting details that could easily be the stuff of prose poetry. The third-person omniscient narrator allows for easy movement through the occasional mutterings of different village characters before the main event: the annual New Year's Day dive into a lake along the Welsh/English border. Only this year, these villagers are joined by a dead body.

The prologue is long enough that it took me to the end of the episode, and yes, I admit to being a bit silly this time with my movie trailer voice. :) The premise here just reminded me of too many trope movies--the "cop who doesn't play by the rules," the "outsider who must become a hero," and so on. This time, we have "the victim who wanted everyone dead and everyone is a suspect." Goodness, the dust jacket itself says, "With a lie uncovered at every turn" and "In a village with this many secrets..." It feels a touch absurd with such descriptions, but you know what? Action schlock with those anti-rule cop buddies are still fun. Fantasies that always count on that reluctant hero are still fun. So I bet this mystery with a town full of Edward Gorey-esque suspicious people will be fun, too.  

What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Feb 24, 202318:38
You've Got Five Pages, Little Red House by Liv Andersson, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Little Red House by Liv Andersson, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


 Liv Andersson's thriller Little Red House gave me a delightful surprise. Not through it's subject matter, for the record--it's a dark thriller that starts with the perspective of a rape and torture victim held captive in a man's basement. If you do not want to read about rape, just avoid this book. I'm sure Andersson will understand.


No, the surprise for me came as a writer. Andersson avoids prologues, yet her first chapter reads like a prologue we so often see here: it's short, first-person, and a vivid telling of a dangerous scene. Listening to the victim describe what she hears when her tormentor approaches, hearing her focus on details of her environment for she's determined not only to escape but kill her tormentor in the process--it is, in short, a compelling opener. I feared that Andersson had given us a stark first chapter to offset what we often see in this podcast: a really slow "second" opener to the book. 


Yet that is not the case here! While Chapter 2 does "start over" with another character in first person, we see that this new character is related to the first, which immediately gets us wondering how well the two may know or know of each other. The voice of the new character is similar, but not to the point where I have to check what their names are to keep them straight. Her chapter is also pure active movement with just the teensiest bits of background, so the momentum started with Chapter 1 continues onward. Even though we've left one protagonist in a prison, this new character also seems to be in a prison of her own making. Even though she has a key to escape (metaphorically speaking), she refuses to use it. Why?


Again, for those who do not wish to read of sexual trauma, please wait for next week's installment. But for those who read thrillers into the darker turns of human nature, you'll not be disappointed with Andersson's protagonists here. As a writer, too, I find her balance between present action, voice, and "telling between the lines" to be most instructive.


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Feb 17, 202319:42
You've Got Five Pages, Fortune Favors the Dead by Stephen Spotswood, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Fortune Favors the Dead by Stephen Spotswood, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!


While Fortune Favors the Dead by Stephen Spotswood is not a new book, it is new to my library. It's the first of a "hard-boiled" detective series featuring a pair of women (one with multiple sclerosis) solving crimes in the 1940s. When I read that blurb about the detectives, I just had to give it a go, and I'm so glad I did. No need for bait-and-switch prologues here! We jump right into character Willowjean Parker describing the first time she meets detective Lillian Pentecost: "The first time I met Lillian Pentacost, I nearly caved her skull in with a piece of lead pipe." It's a wonderful opening line that brings the classic game/film Clue to mind, and it got me hooked to see how these two would really interact. Just as Pentecost's body language and dialogue share a lot about her, so do Parker's thoughts one what she sees and reacts to ("I took the wire out of her hand and had the job done in ten seconds flat. I'd picked harder locks blindfolded. Literally.") I'm already eager to see how the other two books in this series shape up, for if these opening pages are any indication, Pentacost and Parker are not a pair to pass up. 


What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!


Feb 10, 202318:07
You've Got Five Pages, Bleeding Heart Yard by Elly Griffiths, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Bleeding Heart Yard by Elly Griffiths, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! 


Well, my curse on this podcast strikes again. The prologue of Bleeding Heart Yard by Elly Griffiths is quite well-crafted and compelling and leagues ahead of the first chapter, which is an exposition dump detailing a separate character's fast-track in her career with law enforcement. Now I can see that Griffiths herself is an avid mystery writer, winner of awards, etc., and the prologue shows me why. Writers would do well to study those first couple of pages to see how this first-person narrative shares a lot about the character without saying it directly. For instance, the first two lines read: "Is it possible to forget that you've committed a murder? Well, I'm here to tell you that it is." This isn't shocking necessarily, as the dust jacket alludes to the group of main characters committing murder during their school days. It's how the paragraph ends that gets me: "...everyone [during the murder mystery game] would get drunk and forget the clues. This rather irritated me. I like following rules." This speaks LOADS about the unique juxtaposition of character Cassie's traits and morals, not to mention the way her mind works. I was ready and willing to continue with Cassie, only the official first chapter just starts the story over again with a different character. Had Griffiths given us a bit more time with Cassie and smoothed that shift over to another character's pov--ending a chapter with Cassie realizing this new character would be in attendance at a party, for instance--I think readers would be more intrigued to learn about her "friend" even if it takes sifting through an exposition dump to do so.


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Feb 03, 202319:25
You've Got Five Pages, Beasts and Beauty by Soman Chainani, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, Beasts and Beauty by Soman Chainani, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

I had originally planned a mystery for today, but once I saw my selection directly tied back to a previous book without much context, I took my daughter Blondie's offer to read Beasts and Beauty by Soman Chainani instead. I'm so glad I did! The illustrations of the first story, "Red Riding Hood," are stark and bleak--a perfect balance with the vivid yet succinct prose that describes the story-world. Just look at this first sentence: "On the first day of spring, the wolves eat the prettiest girl." That right there is intense and violent while also providing a sense of time and action. Even though the story is written in third-person omniscient, we as readers feel like we are a part of the story, watching the girl who never thought herself beautiful be chosen by the wolves for their meal. We watch her discard fear, take up her red cloak and knife, and enter the forest. We have heard this tale a thousand times, yet we cannot help but read on, for we don't know where Chainani's unique tellings will take us. His control over language is pure magic, and I cannot wait to see his imagination play with the story-worlds of Snow White, Peter Pan, and other classic fairy tale folk.

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jan 27, 202319:10
You've Got Five Pages, A Ghost of Caribou by Alice Henderson, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, A Ghost of Caribou by Alice Henderson, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Once again, we have a prologue, and once again, this is where the action happens in the opening pages of Alice Henderson's A Ghost of Caribou. On a technical level, the writing itself is fine: the pacing of the action is clear. The details help us see the woman being chased by a "thing." Yet this prologue also feels very distant; we're not really feeling things as the character feels, but merely stand as witness as this old woman runs and is eventually captured. And that's something that snapped me back to reality, too: a seventy-two-year-old is outrunning what sounds like a drone through dangerous terrain in the dark. Whaaat?! It reminds me of the opening sequence to a tv episode like X-Files, where we've got to see someone in danger so we can be motivated to keep watching and see that person be saved.

But this is not TV. This is a book. And so we have the words and ability to gather the words that could help readers feel what someone in danger is feeling. 

The first chapter's opening pages continue to give me those "TV vibes." After writing the characters' full names for the reader, Henderson then has the characters say their names as if they've not seen one other in twenty years. "Alex Carter!" "Ben Hathaway!" But they did see each other only a year ago. Why this double-dump of information? It happens again when Ben asks if Alex wants to get something from the coffee shop. We get double-details that the shop is decorated with local art on the walls and has an "artistic" vibe. This kind of repetitive description simply isn't necessary, especially since such an environment has become quite common in the western world and therefore is easy for readers to picture. Again, it feels like these details are there as if a script needs a quick setting description before the dialogue starts.

But this is not TV. This is a book, where every word counts. And when one's writing a mystery, those words should always propel us toward the mystery's heart rather than its "artistic" walls of generic detail. 

And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jan 20, 202323:12
You've Got Five Page, The Personal Assistant by Kimberly Belle, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Page, The Personal Assistant by Kimberly Belle, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! 


Ironically, the prologue is my favorite part of the opening pages in Kimberly Belle's The Personal Assistant. These first two pages are a well-paced scene with balanced external action and sensory detail from the perspective of an unnamed girl without a dime to her name. Her car's run off the road by a farmer in the middle of nowhere, her tire blows out, and she has no one she could turn to for money. The prologue ends with a mysterious man pulling up to her vehicle offering aid.


Now I mention in my episode that prologues make me nervous because they seem to be the author's backup plan to hooking readers when they know the first chapter is a slog. Lo and behold...


We meet protagonist Alex, a social media influence married to a financial talking head named Patrick who also does a lot on social media. The opening pages detail how happy she is with her rise to fame, his skepticism about why people care enough to follow her online, and how he never cared about her daughters.


+++CORRECTION+++ It is not clear in these opening pages if Patrick is the father of those girls or not. In the episode, I interpreted that he is, which makes him sound like an even bigger jerk than he might be. Just wanted to clarify that. +++


Kimberly Belle clearly knows how to craft a scene. Belle knows how to balance detail and action, and she knows how to use dialogue to relay information. If I spot another book by Belle, I'll likely give it a try. I just struggle to read a story about this particular kind of character. For folks who enjoy the realm of social media drama, or thrillers with that social media flare, this fiction will fit right in with your tastes. As one who is not as keen on such drama, I struggle to relate to such personalities. So, I'm going to see what the next mystery from my library contains.


And what will you learn from these opening pages? Let's find out! Cheers!

Jan 13, 202321:33
You've Got Five Pages, The Twist of a Knife by Anthony Horowitz, To Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Twist of a Knife by Anthony Horowitz, To Tell Me You're Good.

CORRECTION: Over the course of the podcast I say The Twist of a Knife is the third book of Horowitz's series, but it is actually the fourth. My apologies!

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

One of my favorite styles of writing is writing with personality. Horowitz's The Twist of a Knife has plenty of personality in the prose because the narrator, Horowitz himself, IS a character in the series. It's a delightful homage to the Watson-style storytelling approach Doyle took for chronicling the adventures of Sherlock Holmes--except in Horowitz's case, the story begins with him and his Detective Hawthorn parting ways. 

NOOOOOooooooo.....

Of course they can't stay parted. There is a whole book here, after all. But such a beginning does help establish some immediate conflict between protagonists that is bound to help make future points of plot--such as the murder of Horowitz's critics--more challenging to overcome. The pair's banter and chemistry were a joy to read, rather like the Thursday Murder Club in Richard Osman's series. My one niggle here is that Horowitz opens his story with an exposition dump. While I appreciate we are getting exposition from the character in character voice that establishes the story-world, it's still a bit of a slog, especially when compared to the quick, delightful dialogue that follows it.

What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Jan 06, 202321:03
You've Got Five Pages, The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

Welp, we're back to prologues. Thankfully, the prologue is brief--a little over a page--and does accomplish two important things. First, there is a childhood memory used to establish the ominous mood and setting where the story takes place. Second, the narrator is very restrained and a little ominous in her word choices to the point where we can't--or shouldn't--trust her as a narrator. The first chapter shifts into the present time, a casual interrogation between a police detective and our narrator, Casey. The dialogue is very taut, and any exposition relays to the action, including the narrator realizing she has to lie to the police.

I'm not a fan of time-jumping between chapters, but I do appreciate Sager's choice in keeping the narrator's inner reveals to the bare minimum. Sager doesn't want readers to trust the narrator, so the narrator's language reveals very little. Some readers may not care for such a small amount of insights into our narrator, but a mystery can't remain a mystery for very long if too much is revealed too soon. So, if you are keen for an isolated mystery, then I think Sager's tale will set your nerves on edge perfectly.

And what will we find on the library's New Release shelf next week? I can't wait to find out. :) Cheers!

Dec 30, 202218:58
You've Got Five Pages, The Twelve Topsy-Turvy, Very Messy Days of Christmas by Tad Safran and James Patterson, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Twelve Topsy-Turvy, Very Messy Days of Christmas by Tad Safran and James Patterson, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

To be blunt, the first chapter of The Twelve Topsy-Turvy, Very Messy Days of Christmas by Tad Safran and James Patterson was infuriating. The first page begins with a lighthearted approach about the worst Christmas present being different kinds of socks--this is relatable and fine. Then the next paragraph goes in a different direction and says the worst Christmas present for two siblings was the death of their mom. This is a shock so early in the story, but also something many of us can relate to. We're even ready as readers to sympathize and perhaps even empathize with the characters.

But unfortunately, the exposition establishing this family's situation is so distracting that it turns off any desire to empathize and actually inspires us to abandon those kids to their fate, unread. The narrator wants to be lighthearted about their dead mom--don't worry, they didn't "technically" lose her because she's in a cemetery. Don't worry, she's not a zombie. Don't worry, she didn't spend all her time outside because she wasn't house-trained. What on earth was this supposed to be? Humor? I can appreciate that folks use humor to cope with grief. Again, completely understandable. But we are brand new to this story-world and this family. We want to meet this family and understand them, but we can't if we're only told poor jokes about the family member all of them love and miss so much. If anything, we only learn about the narrator in this first chapter, and what I've learned does not encourage me to stick around and get to know the narrator better. It's a shame, really, because there really are some lovely lines about the family at the end of the first chapter that, sadly, are soured by what came before.

Perhaps you are fine with this brand of humor. Please enjoy! As for me, I think I'll see what's on the library's new release shelf next week.

Cheers!

Dec 23, 202216:26
You've Got Five Pages, The Man Who Died Twice by Richard Osman, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Pages, The Man Who Died Twice by Richard Osman, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it! 

It's been a while since a story truly tickled me, and Richard Osman's The Man Who Died TWICE did exactly that. Here we watch a group of four friends having lunch after their "Murder Club" meeting, where they get together to study cold cases. I didn't even realize this was the second book of the series until I caught this brief exposition in the first chapter, and thankfully, that was all I needed to be brought up to speed. The chemistry and personalities of these characters will have readers chuckling before they've even gotten to the third page, let alone to any murder. When a writer can establish four unique characters through a single lunchtime conversation, then you know their writing is worth a study! For those who need a lift in the heart and spirit while also tucking into a good mystery, then I have a feeling Osman's Thursday Murder Club series will be the perfect fit for you. I know I'm excited to find the first book!

What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!

Dec 16, 202219:52
You've Got Five Page, Haven by Emma Donoghue, to Tell Me You're Good.

You've Got Five Page, Haven by Emma Donoghue, to Tell Me You're Good.

The first chapter can make or break a reader's engagement with a story. We as writers must craft brilliant opening pages in order to hook those picky readers, so let's study the stories of others to see how they do it!

When I first grabbed Haven by Emma Donoghue from my library's New Release shelf, I was admittedly hesitant because of my mixed feelings for her previous novel Room. Once I saw Haven is a historical novel featuring monks, though, my hesitation dissipated. I'm a big fan of Umberto Eco's Name of the Rose and the Cadfael series by Ellis Peters, so another mystery with monks? Sign me up!

And as a writer, Donoghue packs a lot in those first five pages for readers. We open with an active abbey meal from the perspective of a young, hungry monk. We see the importance of the abbey to a community and the power the abbot enjoys. Yet there is an outsider visiting the abbey who, as the rumors say, is far more intelligent, far stronger, and simply far more blessed than any resident of that abbey, and this conflict reveals itself in a brief public interaction between the abbot and the outsider. It's a terrific setup for a number of possible progressions of plot, especially since we know from the book's blurb three monks are going to essentially be stranded on a small island. Will that be by choice, or by punishment?

The worldbuilding, too, is artfully done. I mentioned earlier that we can see the abbey is a central part of life, but I particularly dug how Donoghue utilizes the vocabulary of the period with her prose so that modern readers can use context to know what she's talking about. This is one of the biggest challenges of historical fiction, and these early pages show that Donoghue conquered that challenge.

What will you make of these first five pages? Let's find out!


Dec 09, 202218:48