Skip to main content
Kentucky History & Haunts

Kentucky History & Haunts

By Jessie Bartholomew

History, true crime & bizarre happenings in the bluegrass state. Kentucky is a treasure trove of unique people, events, and places dating as far back as the mastodon! You don't have to be from Kentucky to appreciate these stories. Subscribe today and share with a friend. Please email topic suggestions to kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. Visit the website to browse our merch at kyhistoryhaunts.com. And please leave a review or rating wherever you're enjoying the show. Thanks for listening.
Available on
Amazon Music Logo
Apple Podcasts Logo
Castbox Logo
iHeartRadio Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

12. Police UFO Sighting- Louisville

Kentucky History & HauntsJan 07, 2021

00:00
12:49
143. The Preacher & The Felon- Part 2- Albert Fall

143. The Preacher & The Felon- Part 2- Albert Fall

Albert Bacon Fall, a Kentuckian, was the first US Cabinet member in history to be convicted of a felony. Albert, the grandson of Reverend Phillip Fall, moved out west, practiced law, got into politics and got mixed up with some less than virtuous characters, eventually leading to his involvement in the infamous Teapot Dome Scandal.
Mar 06, 202433:14
142. The Preacher & The Felon- Part 1- Reverend Phillip Fall

142. The Preacher & The Felon- Part 1- Reverend Phillip Fall

This is part one of a two part series about the Fall family. Part one discusses the life of Phillip Fall, preacher, teacher, Southern sympathizer. Phillip Fall made connections with major religious figures in Kentucky during the Reformation movement. One of Phillip's sons, William, would later have a son named Albert Fall, who holds the infamous title of being the first U.S. Cabinet member convicted of a felony. Part two will focus on the life of Albert Fall, Phillip's grandson, and let me tell you, it's a very different story.

Much of the research from part one was from the Phillip Fall biography written for the Kentucky Historical Society by P. Burnley and from therestorationmovement.com.

It is likely I made mistakes in this episode as I am not well versed in the topic of religion. If I need to make a correction, or you have a future topic suggestion, please email kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com

To buy Jessie a coffee for her work on this episode (remember, this is a one-woman show) you can send a tip through Paypal @kyhistoryhaunts or Venmo @kyhistoryhaunts

Feb 19, 202430:53
141. Who REALLY Murdered Rhonda Sue Warford? (Louisville/Brandenburg)

141. Who REALLY Murdered Rhonda Sue Warford? (Louisville/Brandenburg)

In the early 1990s, the Meade County police, Louisville police and Kentucky State police thought they had gotten it right when they arrested Garr Keith Hardin and Jeffrey Clark for the murder of Louisville native Rhonda Sue Warford. It took decades and assistance from the Kentucky Innocence Project to right the wrongs made during the investigation and trial. Let me know what you think. You can send mail to my work address- 9115 Leesgate Rd Suite A, Louisville, KY, 40222.

Send me your address to get on my mailing list!

Send your feedback and topic suggestions to kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com Connect with the show on Instagram @kyhistoryhaunts or search the show name on Facebook. Be sure to join the Facebook group- Kentucky History & Haunts & More. Please leave a rating or review if you haven't yet! Thanks!

Feb 01, 202440:26
140. Lucy Hicks Anderson- Baked Goods, Brothels, and Trouble with the Feds

140. Lucy Hicks Anderson- Baked Goods, Brothels, and Trouble with the Feds

From winning baking contests and cooking for wealthy families, to a federal indictment- welcome to episode 140, the fascinating life of Lucy Anderson Hicks. Lucy was born Tobias Lawson in Waddy, Kentucky in the 1880s. Lucy, a black, trans woman from rural Kentucky, baked award-winning desserts, cooked for the most prominent families in Oxnard, California, hosted benefits and parties of all kinds, and became a loved and respected figure in her community. She also operated a brothel and was involved in the sale of liquor during Prohibition. This episode includes content that may not be suitable for younger listeners (specifically, discussion of bordellos and more specifically, a sailor visiting a 'house of ill fame' and leaving with an STD), listener discretion advised. For topic suggestions or feedback, please email kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. Connect with the show on instagram @kyhistoryhaunts or find it on Facebook by searching 'Kentucky History & Haunts.' Be sure to join the Facebook group 'Kentucky History & Haunts & More.' Please leave a review or rating on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Thanks!
Jan 15, 202437:23
139. New Year's Traditions

139. New Year's Traditions

Cozy up with your bayberry candles, your Hoppin' John, your whiskey and your black buns. It's time to discuss New Year's traditions. I'm making sure you know how to prepare your meals, who to invite into your home, and how to clean your furniture as we enter the new year. HAPPY NEW YEAR TO ALL!

Dec 31, 202322:06
138. Ohio River Stories- Part One
Dec 26, 202357:41
137. A Century Ago in Kentucky- Dec. 1923

137. A Century Ago in Kentucky- Dec. 1923

Welcome to another installment of the A Century Ago in Kentucky series. This month we have fistfighting judges, yuletide bribes, a destructive cow, a Christmas tree accident, and much more! Please leave a review wherever you listen and be sure to follow the Facebook page at www.facebook.com/kyhistoryhaunts. Follow the show's Instagram @kyhistoryhaunts and if you have topic suggestions, feedback, or just want to say hello you can email kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. To send me, Jessie, a holiday or Happy New Year card, you can mail them to 9115 Leesgate Rd Suite A, Louisville, KY, 40222. Happy Holidays!
Dec 18, 202330:28
136. Eddyville Escape Attempt of 1923

136. Eddyville Escape Attempt of 1923

In October of 1923, a group of armed young men attempted to escape from Eddyville prison in western Kentucky. After shooting multiple prison guards, they realized their original plan wasn't going to work. They barricaded themselves in the dining hall in the center of the prison yard and the following days resulted in a standoff between the surrounded inmates and the prison guards, plus several Hopkinsville National Guardsmen summoned by Governor Morrow. As the incident came to an unfortunate end, authorities were left wondering, who provided the weapons? They learned exactly who it was. She even confessed, multiple times. But would she face the consequences?

Dec 03, 202301:01:27
135. A Century Ago in Kentucky- Nov. 1923

135. A Century Ago in Kentucky- Nov. 1923

Tarantula bites, jailhouse weddings, drunken traffic cops, voter fraud, post office heroes, safety pin mishaps, baptism confusion, and so much more! Time travel with me, to November 1923 in Kentucky. Connect with the show on Instagram @kyhistoryhaunts, find the show on Facebook under Kentucky History & Haunts, and be sure to join the Facebook group Kentucky History & Haunts & More! Please leave a rating or review wherever you listen, and share with a friend. Happy Thanksgiving!

Nov 23, 202340:16
134. Walter Campbell, Medical Mishaps and the Creation of the FDA

134. Walter Campbell, Medical Mishaps and the Creation of the FDA

Knox County native Walter Campbell graduated from the University of Kentucky in 1902 and the University of Louisville Brandeis School of Law in 1906. He was retained by the Kentucky Experiment Station at UK and worked prosecuting food law violations in Louisville, before being scouted by the federal government to help form and run what would later become the Food and Drug Administration. Walter was a key figure in pivotal events like the sulfanilamide disaster. For more on the early years of the FDA, I recommend the article 'Healthy Public Relations: The FDA's 1930s Legislative Campaign' by Gwen Kay.
Nov 14, 202343:01
133. Belle Gunness- Indiana Serial Killer- Part Two

133. Belle Gunness- Indiana Serial Killer- Part Two

Belle Gunness was born in Norway in the 1850s. Three decades later she moved to Chicago and started a family and business with her first husband. Tragically, their house and business mysteriously burned. The family collected the insurance money and moved to Texas. While living outside of Austin, Belle's family members began dying off one by one, in the strangest of circumstances. Then another house burned down. It seemed bad luck, in the form of death and fires, followed Belle wherever she went. Especially when she arrived in La Porte, Indiana, at the turn of the 20th century.

Oct 31, 202338:11
132. Belle Gunness- Indiana Serial Killer | Part One

132. Belle Gunness- Indiana Serial Killer | Part One

Belle Gunness was born in Norway in the 1850s. Three decades later she moved to Chicago and started a family and business with her first husband. Tragically, their house and business mysteriously burned. The family collected the insurance money and moved to Texas. While living outside of Austin, Belle's family members began dying off one by one, in the strangest of circumstances. Then another house burned down. It seemed bad luck, in the form of death and fires, followed Belle wherever she went. Especially when she arrived in La Porte, Indiana, at the turn of the 20th century.

Oct 31, 202335:34
131. Kentucky Haunts & Folklore- Halloween Special- Part 1

131. Kentucky Haunts & Folklore- Halloween Special- Part 1

It’s the time of the season, yall. Enjoy these stories about a 500 year old water moccasin, haunted houses, prohibition, evil creeks, spooky caves, and… Nazis. I have a little bit of everything to get you in the spooky mood this October!
Oct 15, 202335:28
130. Spiritualist Medium Mary Langley- Covington, Kentucky

130. Spiritualist Medium Mary Langley- Covington, Kentucky

Mary Langley was born Mary Hinderer in Ohio in the 1880s. In her early years, she and her family moved to Indiana near Camp Chesterfield, a popular community for spiritualists and mediums. By the 1920s, Mary was a successful medium, traveling regionally to offer her services. By the mid-1920s she was working in Covington, where she was arrested and put on trial for disorderly conduct. The local authorities believed Mary Langley was a fraud after exposing her by raiding a séance at her home. Her dedicated followers disagreed, and many continued to defend her in the days leading up to her trial. Most of my research for this episode came from The Kentucky Post archives. To support the show, send Jessie a Halloween card with $5 in it to her work address, 9115 Leesgate Rd, Suite A, Louisville, KY 40222. You can also Venmo or Paypal a one-time donation to @kyhistoryhaunts. Thank you for listening and for your support!


Oct 10, 202350:26
129. A Death at Lakeland Asylum, A Poisoning in Lawrenceburg
Oct 01, 202325:37
128. A Century Ago in Kentucky- September, 1923

128. A Century Ago in Kentucky- September, 1923

Back for another round of ‘A Century Ago in Kentucky!’ Listen to stories about the Kentucky state fair, terrifying automobile mishaps, hidden bootlegging operations in chimneys, a duel in northern Kentucky, a drunk mayor, gypsies, dynamite and more!


Sep 26, 202355:28
127. Did The KKK Almost Buy Valparaiso University?
Sep 18, 202349:12
126. Isaac Shelby- First Governor of Kentucky
Sep 06, 202337:01
125. Murder of Rosetta Warren | Part 2

125. Murder of Rosetta Warren | Part 2

One early morning in April 1923, Alfred Warren left his home on Clay St to go to work in downtown Paducah. A short time later, he heard an explosion in the distance. Unfortunately, the explosion came from his home. The research for this episode came from archives from The Paducah Sun and The Lexington Leader. Leave a comment and let me know what you think. Connect with Kentucky History & Haunts on Instagram & Facebook. Or send me an email: kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com
Aug 29, 202319:52
124. Murder of Rosetta Warren | Part 1

124. Murder of Rosetta Warren | Part 1

One early morning in April 1923, Alfred Warren left his home on Clay St to go to work in downtown Paducah. A short time later, he heard an explosion in the distance. Unfortunately, the explosion came from his home. The research for this episode came from archives from The Paducah Sun and The Lexington Leader. Leave a comment and let me know what you think. Connect with Kentucky History & Haunts on Instagram & Facebook. Or send me an email: kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com
Aug 29, 202330:37
123. The Mahan Shooting & The Crawley Murder

123. The Mahan Shooting & The Crawley Murder

Lots of family drama in Kentucky, 1923. A wife claims her stepdaughter attempted to murder her. The stepdaughter claims self defense. A drifting alcoholic harasses his younger brother and his family until the younger brother puts a stop to it. How will the court system handle these situations? Well it’s 1923, you just never know! Research from this episode comes from the Louisville Courier Journal Archives. Let me know what you think by leaving a comment on Spotify, or writing me at kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. The cover photo for this episode is Elijah Crawley, his wife Josie, and their children, Aileen & Melvin.
Aug 21, 202322:15
122. A Century Ago In Kentucky- August 1923

122. A Century Ago In Kentucky- August 1923

A century ago there was bootlegging, fortune telling, calculator pedaling, national park advocating, squirrel shooting, and much more! Sit back, relax and enjoy this trip back in time one hundred years. All articles read in this episode are from The Courier Journal archives. More at www.kyhistoryhaunts.com. Join the Facebook group- Kentucky History & Haunts & More!
Aug 14, 202327:16
121. What Happened to Kelly Hollan?
Jul 31, 202322:44
120. The Kentucky Secret Society That Helped Create The American Medical Association

120. The Kentucky Secret Society That Helped Create The American Medical Association

In the early 19th century, secret societies were having a moment. A professor at Transylvania University’s Medical Department decided it would be a good idea to start one for his students. The Kentucky Chapter of the Kappa Lambda Society of Hippocrates didn’t last long, but the seeds it planted spread all over the country, eventually influencing the formation of the American Medical Association. For more on this topic, visit https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2259138/ 🩺 For additional resources visit www.kyhistoryhaunts.com 🎙️ Be sure to follow the show on Instagram @kyhistoryhaunts & find the Facebook group- Kentucky History & Haunts & More! Please leave a review and share this episode with a friend. Thanks for listening!
Jul 17, 202332:22
119. The Time A Kentucky Judge Was Offended By Pants
Jun 19, 202325:24
118. Twice Tried & Still Unsolved- Chantell Humphries
Jun 05, 202329:06
117. Mistaken Identity & Organs in the Laundry Room- Part 2
May 10, 202320:56
116. Mistaken Identity & Organs in the Laundry Room- Part 1
May 10, 202326:46
115. Stories from Kentucky Explorer Magazine- Part 1
Apr 30, 202326:13
114. Geneva Hardman, Marshal Law, and Maybe A Serial Killer- Part 2

114. Geneva Hardman, Marshal Law, and Maybe A Serial Killer- Part 2

Chaos erupted in Lexington, Kentucky in 1920 after a young girl was brutally murdered on her way to school. The aftermath prompted General Marshall to declare Marshal Law. For more info on this topic grab a copy of The Murder of Geneva Hardman & Lexington’s Mob Riot of 1920 by Peter Brackney. https://kaintuckeean-800675.square.site/product/geneva-hardman/2?cs=true&cst=custom Send topic suggestions and corrections to kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. Visit www.kyhistoryhaunts.com for additional sources and photos
Mar 14, 202330:11
113. Geneva Hardman, Marshal Law, and Maybe A Serial Killer- Part 1

113. Geneva Hardman, Marshal Law, and Maybe A Serial Killer- Part 1

Chaos erupted in Lexington, Kentucky in 1920 after a young girl was brutally murdered on her way to school. The aftermath prompted General Marshall to declare Marshal Law. For more info on this topic grab a copy of The Murder of Geneva Hardman & Lexington’s Mob Riot of 1920 by Peter Brackney. https://kaintuckeean-800675.square.site/product/geneva-hardman/2?cs=true&cst=custom Send topic suggestions and corrections to kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. Visit www.kyhistoryhaunts.com for additional sources and photos
Mar 13, 202323:09
112. Pete ‘The Gladiator’ Browning
Feb 13, 202329:52
111. James 'Honest Dick' Tate Fooled Everyone in Frankfort

111. James 'Honest Dick' Tate Fooled Everyone in Frankfort

James William Tate was born near Frankfort, Kentucky in 1831. When he was seventeen he started working at the post office, but quickly transitioned to a career in politics. He was elected State Treasurer in 1867- a position he would maintain for the next two decades. He was loved, trusted and respected by his colleagues and the citizens of Kentucky. That is until 1888, when everything changed. This is the story of James ‘Honest Dick’ Tate.  To leave Jessie a tip for her hard work on this show, please use this link and scroll to the bottom of the page- https://bio.site/jessiebartholomew If you're listening on Spotify, please use the Q&A section in this or any episode to suggest future topics or to offer corrections. Thanks for listening!
Jan 23, 202326:55
110. Alvin Shipwreck Kelly
Dec 24, 202229:60
109. Octagon Hall- The Haunting
Dec 12, 202211:31
108. Octagon Hall- The History

108. Octagon Hall- The History

Episode 109: Octagon Hall- The History. This episode covers the history of a 175 year old building in Franklin, Kentucky, including the role it played in the Civil War. More information at www.octagonhallmuseum.com To leave Jessie a tip for her work on these episodes, please use this link and scroll to the bottom- https://bio.site/jessiebartholomew If you're listening on Spotify, use the Q&A section to leave suggestions for future episode topics.
Dec 11, 202220:24
107. Captain Mary Miller

107. Captain Mary Miller

Portland, Kentucky native Mary Millicent Miller was begrudgingly given a steamboat captain’s license in the 1880s. She was the first woman in the United States to obtain one. Check out the updated store at https://www.kyhistoryhaunts.com/merch. To leave Jessie a one-time donation for her work on the show, go to https://bio.site/jessiebartholomew and scroll down to ‘Buy Jessie A Coffee.’ To suggest an episode topic send an email to kyhistoryhaunts@gmail.com. Thanks for listening! If you're listening on Spotify, use the Q&A section to leave suggestions for future episode topics. Thank you!
Nov 14, 202224:37
106. Jessie Visits the Anderson Hotel
Nov 07, 202244:50
105. Nightmares, Bloody Mary & Percy Shelley’s Heart

105. Nightmares, Bloody Mary & Percy Shelley’s Heart

It’s the 2022 Halloween Special! Full disclosure: none of these stories are Kentucky related! I wanted to do something different for Halloween this year. Hope you like it! Eat lots of candy and enjoy the holiday! PS I misspoke in this episode when speaking about the Shelley’s traveling around Europe during WWI- I was in the wrong century! That was during the Napoleonic Wars. 100 years earlier. Oops!
Oct 31, 202219:12
104. Cemetery Road Murders- Part 2
Oct 29, 202238:44
103. Cemetery Road Murders- Part 1
Oct 28, 202246:33
102. Listener Stories- Three Haunted Houses
Oct 08, 202232:55
101. Haunted Newport
Sep 26, 202214:20
100. Newport Mob Stories- Part 2
Sep 19, 202238:55
99. Newport Mob Stories- Part 1
Sep 18, 202248:46
98. Who Killed Patrice Corley?

98. Who Killed Patrice Corley?

In the spring of 1990, a woman’s body was found behind a truck stop in central Ohio. It took twenty-seven years to identify her, but her killer’s identity remains a mystery. This episode discusses details of violence that some may find unsettling. Listener discretion advised.
Aug 19, 202222:11
97. Lottie the Triceratops

97. Lottie the Triceratops

When I saw an article about saving Lottie the triceratops, I knew there would be a good story. And here it is. Find out how a life-sized, fiberglass dinosaur from the 1964 World’s Fair ended up in Louisville, Kentucky.
Jul 26, 202217:11
96. Gaines Tavern- Kentucky Horror House

96. Gaines Tavern- Kentucky Horror House

Abner Gaines and his family built a large home in Walton, Kentucky that became a busy stop for the stage coach line running from Cincinnati to Lexington. Over the years, the murders and suicides that took place on the property led to the creation of the nickname ‘Kentucky Horror House.’ Episode 97 will cover the history and hauntings of the Gaines Tavern in Boone County, Kentucky.
Jul 12, 202221:02
95. The Ghost Ship- USS Sachem
Jul 07, 202221:41
94. Angel Bumpass Needs A New Trial
Jun 29, 202221:00