Skip to main content
Listen Carefully: The Jon Benet Story

Listen Carefully: The Jon Benet Story

By Sam and Lindsey

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. Jon Benet Ramsey was a 6 year old pageant queen who went missing on Christmas 1996. However, a prolific kidnapping case quickly turned into a murder investigation when her body was found in the basement of her childhood home. "Listen Carefully" examines the common misconceptions of the case while extrapolating on the evidence, theories and suspects surrounding this 24 year old mystery.
Currently playing episode

04. The Sleep Walking Defense

Listen Carefully: The Jon Benet Story Nov 29, 2022

00:00
50:34
04. The Sleep Walking Defense

04. The Sleep Walking Defense

In this episode, Sam and Lindsey dive into the Brooke Preston case. They talk about the validity of the sleep walking defense and share alternative theories. 

Nov 29, 202250:34
03. Lindsey is a part of SPA

03. Lindsey is a part of SPA

In the third and final installment of the Scott Peterson case, Lindsey and Sam go over alternative theories and discuss why Lindsey fell down the conspiracy hole. 

Nov 25, 202254:27
02. I saw Lacy walking her dog in Rome

02. I saw Lacy walking her dog in Rome

In this episode of Listen Carefully, Sam and Lindsey go through the Scott Peterson trial and discuss the defense and prosecution arguments.

Oct 28, 202201:07:28
01. Eating Pizza and Milk is Psychopathic

01. Eating Pizza and Milk is Psychopathic

In this episode, Sam and Lindsey do a deep dive on the Scott Peterson case. Was he really innocent??? or are documentaries and movies swaying the public's reaction? Find out more about the chilling Christmas where Lacy Peterson went missing and the media frenzy began. 

Oct 28, 202201:13:12
Interview with Jill McReynolds: A Man Who Just Believed in Magic

Interview with Jill McReynolds: A Man Who Just Believed in Magic

In this special episode, Sam and Lindsey interview Jill McReynolds, daughter of the infamous Santa Bill. Jill talks about her father's legacy, his experience as the Ramsey's Santa Clause and how the investigation affected his life. 

May 31, 202258:22
10. Armchair Detectives

10. Armchair Detectives

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode of Listen Carefully, Sam and Lindsey talk latest developments in the JonBenet Case - Including John Ramsey's petition to retest the DNA. 

May 30, 202201:02:11
 09. Grand Ol Jury

09. Grand Ol Jury

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode of Listen Carefully, Sam and Lindsey complain relentlessly about the District Attorney Alex Hunter and the politics surrounding the case. They also talk about how to get free merchandise and offer a chance to be on the show!

May 30, 202201:15:21
08. Don't Talk to Me, Steve Thomas

08. Don't Talk to Me, Steve Thomas

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, In the last of the theory episodes, Sam and Lindsey discuss the validity of the bed wetting theory and the sex game theory.

May 30, 202201:06:35
07. We Clearly Don't Watch Dragon Ball Z

07. We Clearly Don't Watch Dragon Ball Z

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, Sam and Lindsey cover the infamous Pineapple Theory, discussing its validity along with past violence between the siblings.


May 27, 202201:00:36
06. The Stealthiest Clumsiest Intruder

06. The Stealthiest Clumsiest Intruder

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode Sam and Lindsey discuss the intruder theory and Lou Smit's theories. They outline the theory in its entirety while questioning its validity. This is the first of many theory episodes!

May 27, 202201:05:02
05. Justice for Santa Bill

05. Justice for Santa Bill

TW/CW: this podcast contains sensitive subjects such as violence and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, Sam and Lindsey outline the potential suspects of the case, including: Tod Fuss, Bill McReynolds and Chris Wolf.

May 27, 202201:03:02
04. Prints and Pineapples

04. Prints and Pineapples

TW/CW: this episode contains strong language and sensitive topics such as violence, kidnapping and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, Sam & Lindsey go over the evidence of the case, including: the ransom note, pineapple bowl and the DNA evidence that ended up clearing the Ramseys.


May 27, 202201:19:46
03.Birefringent foreign material

03.Birefringent foreign material

TW/CW: this episode contains strong language and sensitive topics such as violence, kidnapping and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, Sam & Lindsey cover the autopsy of JonBenet Ramsey and examine the common misconceptions of the case.

May 27, 202201:07:23
02. Don't Try to Grow a Brain

02. Don't Try to Grow a Brain

TW/CW: this episode contains strong language and sensitive topics such as violence, murder and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, hosts Lindsey and Sam will analyze the notorious 2 1/2 page ransom note left on the Ramsey's staircase.


May 27, 202201:00:26
01. We Have a Kidnapping

01. We Have a Kidnapping

TW/CW: this episode contains strong language and sensitive topics such as violence, kidnapping and sexual abuse of a child. In this episode, Lindsey and Sam will cover a timeline of events that happened at the Ramsey's house on the morning of December 26, 1996. Within this episode, they will discuss the mistakes made by the Boulder Police Department during the first crucial moments of the case, the consequences of allowing people to wander through the home and how this went from a kidnapping to a homicide investigation within hours.

May 27, 202201:05:25