Skip to main content
Rate, Debate, Recreate

Rate, Debate, Recreate

By Sammie Purcell and Logan Keller

Welcome to Rate, Debate, Recreate – a musical podcast where Sammie and Logan discuss the merits of their favorite Broadway shows and make them better. Because you know, we're the experts.
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Supporting Actor Zac Efron Helps Solve Racism: Hairspray vs. The Greatest Showman

Rate, Debate, RecreateOct 27, 2022

00:00
01:00:53
Supporting Actor Zac Efron Helps Solve Racism: Hairspray vs. The Greatest Showman

Supporting Actor Zac Efron Helps Solve Racism: Hairspray vs. The Greatest Showman

Zac Efron is many things: actor, singer... strong mover. But can we add anti-racist to that list? Check out the latest episode to hear about Zac's efforts to solve racism in Hairspray and The Greatest Showman. 

Oct 27, 202201:00:53
Historical Figure Cameos: Ragtime vs. Something Rotten

Historical Figure Cameos: Ragtime vs. Something Rotten

This week, Logan and Sammie discuss two shows with multiple cameos from real life historical figures. Omelette you guess which historical figures are in these shows! 

Oct 27, 202253:03
Guided by Riches: Anastasia vs. Spamalot!

Guided by Riches: Anastasia vs. Spamalot!

In Episode, Sammie and Logan discuss 2 shows where... at least SOME characters are guided by riches. What are the effects of wealth as your North Star? Find out in this ep :) 

Oct 14, 202201:03:56
The Artist's Struggle: Tick, Tick... Boom! vs. A Chorus Line

The Artist's Struggle: Tick, Tick... Boom! vs. A Chorus Line

No one loves to write more about the artist's struggle than... the struggling artist. Check out this week's episode where Logan and Sammie discuss 2 shows that explore what it means to be an artist, and the struggles that come along with it. Are you team Tick, Tick... Boom! or team A Chorus Line?

Oct 06, 202201:00:22
Old vs. New: Carousel vs. The Band's Visit

Old vs. New: Carousel vs. The Band's Visit

Musicals have changed their shape, form, content, choreography... well, just about everything since they began! This week, Logan and Sammie will discuss 2 shows, one representing the "old" and one representing the "new". Check this episode out and let us know what you think!

Sep 29, 202201:04:57
Makover! My Fair Lady vs. The Prom

Makover! My Fair Lady vs. The Prom

Who doesn't love a good makeover! Tune in this week as we discuss two shows where the protagonist receives quite the makeover, in My Fair Lady and The Prom!

Sep 25, 202201:07:41
Sondheim

Sondheim

This week, Sammie and Logan discuss two musicals by the late, great Stephen Sondheim (note: yes, these probably aren't the most typical Sondheim shows. We've already done most of the others!! Check them out :)) Tune in as we discuss A Little Night Music and Gypsy!

Sep 16, 202258:57
The Metaphor is the Point: A Strange Loop vs. Chess

The Metaphor is the Point: A Strange Loop vs. Chess

Pretty much every major musical is drowning in metaphors... but in this case, the metaphor is not only necessary - it's the point of the show! Join us for episode 3 as we discuss 2022 Tony Award Winner A Strange Loop and classic musical Chess!

Sep 08, 202259:24
Song Cycles: Songs for a New World vs. Fugitive Songs

Song Cycles: Songs for a New World vs. Fugitive Songs

In this episode, Logan and Sammie take a slight turn off of traditional musicals, and discuss two song cycles! Check out this episode to hear our thoughts on Songs for a New World and Fugitive Songs! 

Sep 01, 202201:13:28
Disney! Beauty and the Beast vs. Coco

Disney! Beauty and the Beast vs. Coco

We're back back BACK again for Season 3 of Rate, Debate, Recreate! This episode, we'll be discussing 2 iconic Disney shows - one old, one new. Are you team Beauty and the Beast or team Coco? 

Aug 26, 202201:18:31
Where would you rather live?: Oklahoma vs. Hadestown

Where would you rather live?: Oklahoma vs. Hadestown

In this episode, we pose an age old question to our listeners. Where would you rather live? On one hand, there's beautiful, barren, and (sometimes) backwards Oklahoma. On the other hand, there's the greek representation of hell itself, Hadestown. Tune in to find out where we want to live!

Sep 09, 202101:12:48
Sobfest: Falsettos vs. Parade

Sobfest: Falsettos vs. Parade

Get your tissues ready, cause this week, we're GOING THERE. Tune in as Logan and Sammie discuss two sob-worthy musicals, Falsettos and Parade!

Sep 03, 202101:12:00
Kindness of Strangers: Come From Away vs. Annie!

Kindness of Strangers: Come From Away vs. Annie!

Sometimes the kindness of strangers can be the simplest but most effective tool to spread love. Is that necessarily the case in BOTH of these musicals? That's for you to decide. Tune in as Sammie and Logan discuss Come From Away and Annie!

Aug 28, 202101:06:51
Based on a True Story: The Sound of Music vs. Hands on a Hardbody

Based on a True Story: The Sound of Music vs. Hands on a Hardbody

This week, Logan and Sammie discuss two shows that... to an extent, are based on a true story! Are you team #traversethemountainsmadeofmusic or #texansputtingtheirhandsonachevy? Listen and let us know!

Aug 19, 202101:09:51
Sk8r Bois! Xanadu vs. The Drowsy Chaperone

Sk8r Bois! Xanadu vs. The Drowsy Chaperone

"He was a sk8r boi, she said see you l8r boi" These wise words by pop princess Avril Lavigne... kind of apply to the two shows we talk about. They both involved sk8ing in SOME way! Tune in as Logan and Sammie rate, debate, and recreate Xanadu and the Drowsy Chaperone

Aug 13, 202101:03:04
Party Gone Wrong: The Wild Party vs. Carrie

Party Gone Wrong: The Wild Party vs. Carrie

Parties don't always go as planned, in at least 2 cases, people die!!! Tune in this week as Sammie and Logan discuss Andrew Lippa's version of "The Wild Party" and the musical adaption of cult classic horror movie "Carrie"

Aug 05, 202101:15:12
Colors! Moulin Rouge vs. The Color Purple

Colors! Moulin Rouge vs. The Color Purple

What's your favorite color? In this episode, we discuss colors and some of our favorite musicals that showcase colors in their title. Tune in as Sammie and Logan rate, debate, and recreate 2 iconic shows: Moulin Rouge and The Color Purple.

Jul 15, 202101:08:38
Fan Chosen Episode: Les Miserables vs Book of Mormon

Fan Chosen Episode: Les Miserables vs Book of Mormon

This week was all up to our fans! Shout out to everyone who voted on our instagram, tune in as we discuss two indie, lesser known shows: Les Miserables and Book of Mormon.

Jul 09, 202151:02
BONUS EPISODE: In the Heights Movie Reactions

BONUS EPISODE: In the Heights Movie Reactions

In our first ever BONUS episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss their thoughts on In the Heights! What changed from the musical to movie? What did they get right and wrong? Tune in to find out our thoughts on this and more. 

Jul 01, 202146:41
Spooky-Ooky! Phantom of the Opera vs. Ghost

Spooky-Ooky! Phantom of the Opera vs. Ghost

It may not be Halloween but it IS Cancer season so let's get Spooky-ooky! Tune in this week as Sammie and Logan discuss Ghost the Musical and Phantom of the Opera.

Jun 25, 202151:10
Working Girls: Waitress vs. 9 to 5

Working Girls: Waitress vs. 9 to 5

This week, Logan and Sammie discuss their favorite Broadway musicals about werkin girls. Tune in as Sammie unpacks the joys and traumas of playing "Double D" Doralee from 9 to 5 in high school, while Logan fangirls over the wonderful orchestrations of Sara Bareilles. Let us know which is your favorite Working Girl musical!

Jun 17, 202150:32
The Future Liberals Want: Hair v. Passing Strange

The Future Liberals Want: Hair v. Passing Strange

What are the pillars of "Hippie-ism?" Who is Stew? What IS the future that liberals want? All these questions and more will be answered on this week's episode, where Sammie and Logan debate Hair and Passing Strange.
Jun 10, 202101:08:56
Once (Not Once the Musical): Once Upon a Mattress vs. Once on this Island

Once (Not Once the Musical): Once Upon a Mattress vs. Once on this Island

Tune in as Sammie and Logan discuss Once (but not that musical about the Irish (?) pub.) Listen as they Rate, Debate, and Recreate Once Upon a Mattress and Once Upon this Island. Will Wilifred's shyness or Ti Moune's patience (waiting... get it?) win?! That's for you to decide.

Jun 03, 202101:16:02
I'm a Motherf*ckin Starkid: A Very Potter Musical v. Firebringer

I'm a Motherf*ckin Starkid: A Very Potter Musical v. Firebringer

It's getting niche! This week, Logan and Sammie discuss A Very Potter Musical and Firebringer.
May 27, 202101:19:05
Life's a Drag: Kinky Boots v. Cabaret

Life's a Drag: Kinky Boots v. Cabaret

On this episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan gush over Cabaret and Kinky Boots!
May 20, 202101:23:18
Musicals We HATE: Cats v. Grease

Musicals We HATE: Cats v. Grease

On this hatred-filled episode of Rate Debate Recreate, Logan and Sammie discuss Cats and Grease.
May 14, 202101:09:48
It's All About The Green: Wicked v. The Wedding Singer

It's All About The Green: Wicked v. The Wedding Singer

We're BACK for Season Two! On the first episode, Logan and Sammie discuss the merits of being green – we're talking Wicked and The Wedding Singer. Enjoy!
May 06, 202101:08:13
Episode Sixteen: Shows Where the Protagonist Has Surprise Children

Episode Sixteen: Shows Where the Protagonist Has Surprise Children

On the final episode of season one, Logan and Sammie discuss South Pacific and Dreamgirls.
Dec 31, 202001:09:55
Episode Fifteen: White Boy Tries to Find Himself (Ends Poorly)

Episode Fifteen: White Boy Tries to Find Himself (Ends Poorly)

On this episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss Pippin and Spring Awakening!
Dec 24, 202001:02:58
Episode Fourteen: Questionable That These Shows Made the Cut

Episode Fourteen: Questionable That These Shows Made the Cut

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss Bridges of Madison County and [title of show]!
Dec 17, 202001:04:58
Episode Thirteen: Shows Where the Protagonist Sees Things That Aren't There

Episode Thirteen: Shows Where the Protagonist Sees Things That Aren't There

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss Sunday In the Park With George and Next to Normal.
Dec 10, 202001:12:04
Episode Twelve: Musicals With Numbers in the Title

Episode Twelve: Musicals With Numbers in the Title

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee and Six!
Dec 03, 202050:23
Episode Eleven: Musicals That Begin and End With a Vowel

Episode Eleven: Musicals That Begin and End With a Vowel

On this episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss Aida and Evita!
Nov 26, 202001:06:05
Episode Ten: Shows About War

Episode Ten: Shows About War

On this week's episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss "Dogfight" and "Miss Saigon."
Nov 19, 202001:19:10
Episode Nine: LGBT

Episode Nine: LGBT

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss "Heathers: The Musical" and "Fun Home."
Nov 12, 202058:08
Episode Eight: We're Poor and Everything Sucks...Also in New York!

Episode Eight: We're Poor and Everything Sucks...Also in New York!

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Logan and Sammie discuss Rent and Little Shop of Horrors.
Oct 29, 202057:53
Episode Seven: New York!

Episode Seven: New York!

On this episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss Company and Thoroughly Modern Millie!
Oct 22, 202056:47
Episode Six: Non-Broadway Shows

Episode Six: Non-Broadway Shows

This week on Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss two of our favorite shows that never made it all the way to Broadway.
Oct 15, 202053:57
Episode Five: Strong Female Ensembles

Episode Five: Strong Female Ensembles

In this episode of Rate, Debate, Recreate, Sammie and Logan discuss the power of women – whether they be in Greece or in habits!
Oct 08, 202052:40
Episode Four: Lin Manuel Miranda

Episode Four: Lin Manuel Miranda

This week, Sammie and Logan discuss the one, the only.....Lin Manuel Miranda! Featuring a special appearance from Sammie's dog!
Oct 02, 202051:10
Episode Three: Forbidden Love

Episode Three: Forbidden Love

This week on Rate Debate Recreate, things get steamy and romantic with "West Side Story" and "Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812."
Sep 24, 202050:46
Episode Two: Musicals about High Profile Trials re: Murderous Women

Episode Two: Musicals about High Profile Trials re: Murderous Women

Welcome back to Rate Debate Recreate! This week, Sammie and Logan dive into "Chicago" and "Legally Blonde."
Sep 24, 202044:30
Episode One: Fairy Tales Gone Wrong (Or Right?)

Episode One: Fairy Tales Gone Wrong (Or Right?)

Welcome to Rate Debate Recreate, a podcast where we rate our favorite musicals, discuss their merits and shortcomings, and make them better. In episode one, Sammie and Logan discuss "Into The Woods" and "Shrek The Musical."
Sep 24, 202047:25