Mysteretical Podcast

In this week's episode Lynne and JP discuss the Redhead Murders of the 1970's and 1980's. Is it a serial killer? A trucker? Or a bunch of different people? With several jurisdictions, the FBI and a killer or killers on the loose this Bible Belt Mystery has remained unsolved for forty years. Thankfully, some of the Jane Does have been identified even as of 2022 and hopefully that brings us closer to finding the killer!

In this weeks episode Lynne and JP dive into a case from the turn of the 20th century...with the creator of the worlds most famous fictitious detective on the case this episode truly sounds like a famous crime novel. A rich older woman is murdered and her diamond brooch is missing while thousands of dollars worth of jewelry is left untouched. With a ten minute window for the crime to take place, this truly is a head-scratcher...or is it?

In this weeks episode Amanda and Lynne discuss the Lane Bryant murders. This, seemingly unorganized, crime has somehow remained unsolved for the past 15 years... this strange incident has left people continuing to call tip-lines after it rocked a small, seemingly safe community outside of Chicago. We even play the 911 call that took place during the incident. Make sure to reach out to the Lane Bryant tip line if you have any pertinent information!

In this weeks episode of Mysteretical Lynne and JP dive into the abduction of Betty and Barney Hill. Travel back in time with us to 1961 in the White Mountains of New Hampshire where a young couple is faced with a UFO, small gray men, and a weird orange orb. Is it really aliens? Or is it a claim to fame? Or some other traumatic experience that caused missing time, and weird memories? Let's find out together!

In this week's episode JP and Lynne discuss the case of Leigh Occhi. A 13 year old girl who went missing from Mississippi in 1992. From jumping suspicions, to not much to go on, Leigh deserves to have her story told. Is she still out there somewhere? No one knows! Let's help her and her family find justice. 

If you have any information call the Tupelo Police or the Crime Stoppers division of North East Mississippi. 

In this week's episode of Mysteretical Amanda dives into the horrible story of Nikki Fitts and her 2 year old daughter Arianna. The case of a hard working, beloved, and compassionate young mother finds herself in a sticky situation that leads to her untimely death. Not only that, but no one knows what happened to her precious child Arianna. Join us to discuss this heartbreaking case and its potential suspects. Hopefully Arianna can be found, and Nikki's family can have justice. 

In this weeks episode Perry and Lynne dive (hehe) into the story about the Mary Celeste. Don't worry, we compare everything to Pirates of the Caribbean, since that is our only knowledge on the sea in the 1800's, and we dive into theories about curses, a family annihilator, sea monsters, and for some reason the most important theory: squids. Join us as we explore the alleged ways these 10 people disappeared out at sea! 

In this week's episode Amanda and Lynne go back to the late 80's to discuss Tara Calico, a missing New Mexico teen, and the infamous polaroid that was found in a parking lot in Florida. This case is filled with twists and turns...was it the sheriffs son that the sheriff's department covered up? Who are the people in the polaroids? Is their any truth in the deathbed confession, and Tara was left in some basement in her own neighborhood? Let's find out what happened to this sweet 19 year old student, and hopefully bring whatever happened to her to light. 

Welcome to Mysteretical and our final Winter Break series... It's Actually Just Theories. This week we're joined by our first guest we ever had on the show Robyn Nast who joined us for the episode "Bag Full of Worms". JP is still not with us but we will both be back to our regular scheduled programming soon. Robyn and Lynne discuss Dyatlov Pass, The Zodiac Killer, everyones favorite cryptid: Mothman and, naturally, Flat Earth Theory. Join us to find out our favorite theories and have a fantastic New Year!

Welcome to Mysteretical's Winter Break series "It's Actually Just Theories" where we discuss less case and more theories. This week we are joined by our friends Perry and Shannon from PS We Have Orders Podcast. Sadly, JP is not recording with us again but he's still alive and will be back ASAP. In this weeks episode we cover the Disappearance of Agatha Christie, the murder of Elizabeth Short AKA the Black Dahlia, the murder of the Moore Family AKA the Villisca Axe Murder, and the Lost Colony of Roanoke. 

Email us for any infamous cases you want to hear our unsolicited opinions about at mysteretical@gmail.com

Welcome to Mysteretical! For week 2 of Mysteretical's Winter Break we had to shuffle it up a little bit. Due to some unforeseen circumstances JP has not joined us this week (don't worry - he's alive). Fingers crossed he'll be back with us soon! So Lynne has brought our occasional research assistant Amanda onto the show to discuss some of her favorite cases and theories (plus keep an eye out for Amanda in the future...we allegedly have something in the works). Speaking of alleged! In this week's episode Amanda and Lynne discuss the S.S. Ourang Medan, the Somerton Man, the Boy in the Box and the murder of Kathleen Peterson which is also known as the Staircase. 

Email us ideas for cases you want to hear our unsolicited opinions about at mysteretical@gmail.com

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne talk about the disappearance of Australian Prime Minister, Harold Holt. Suicide? Planned Vanishing? Or kidnapped by political rivalries in other countries?

In this week's episode Lynne and JP dive deep into the 1970's and the case of the Eleven Who Went to Heaven and Edward Harold Bell. He's definitely a serial rapist and flasher...but is he also a serial killer? Is there a slew of serial killers or are we just barking up the wrong tree?

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne talk about the mysterious death of Mateusz Kawecki - Murder? Suicide? You decide...

In this week's episode Lynne and JP discuss a horrific serial killer Belle Gunness and her many unfortunate victims (and houses). But, did she fake her own death and escape? Or did she really die in that one fire? Join us to find out!

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne talk about another case - Ursula and Sabina Eriksson. Twin sisters that caused chaos and murder in the United Kingdom. Was MK Ultra at play or could it be something we’ve discussed before?

In this week's episode Lynne and JP head up and out to Alaska to discuss the disappearance of Valerie Sifosof, the murder(s) of Desiree Lenkoff and Michelle Rothe and several other Native and non-Native women in Anchorage Alaska. For the state with the most missing people, why aren't we hearing about them? Are serial killers running rampant? Are attacks not being reported? Are the elements your worst enemy? Listen to find out!

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne review the three cases that need attention - Keeshae Jacobs, Daniel Robinson & Jelani "JJ" Day.

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne review the mysterious disappearance of Lars Mittank. Where did he run off to and why hasn’t he been found?

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP welcome their very first guest onto the show! We take a deep dive with our guest Robyn Nast into Morgellons Disease, which has affected her life very personally and all of the controversies and harmful misconceptions set against it. Will we ever narrow down what it is? Will we ever find a cure? We sure hope so!

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne look into the disappearance of David Guerrero Guevara also known as the Boy Artist. Where did he go?? Did he run away? Did someone take him? Or perhaps… could his disappearance be tied to the visitation of Queen Sofia that very same day...

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP discuss the mysterious case of Mark V Dennis a POW from the Vietnam war? Or a brave, young man who was killed in action? Is the Navy hiding a giant screw up or is it just about a family struggling with grief over a lost loved one?

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne… go to Massachusetts in ‘89 where Melanie Melanson went missing from a High School party. Small town rumors spin up but are they true? And why won’t the kids from the party cooperate?

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP discuss a horrific kidnappers' den outside of Ibadan, Nigeria. A mark of ritualistic killings? A politically charged market? You decide.

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne travel back to the 90’s where yet again Satanic Panic was blamed for the murders of Michael Johnston and Rochelle Robinson. Was the devil involved? Or could this be the case of another stalking gone wrong?

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP head out to the open sea to discuss the case of an infamous pirate called “La Bouche” and his mysterious cryptogram. Is there really hidden treasure off of Madagascar? Or is it all a big hoax?

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne look into missing trucker Devin Williams and the mysterious and bizarre events that lead to his disappearance…

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP go way back in time to discuss the first serial killer in Ireland, Dorcas “Darkey” Kelly. Or was she innocent? Or was she a witch?

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne chat about the Tromp Family Road Trip… The bizarre journey they took - do they return? Do they stick together? What made them leave unplugged in the first place?

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP jump into a time machine to head back to 1908 to discuss the Seal Chart Murders. A robbery gone wrong? A jealous friend? Or a serial killer looking for the goods? You decide!

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne cover the murders of influencers Natalia Pronina and Alexis Sharkey - Worlds apart and unrelated, we talk through the facts and theories of each case...

In this week’s episode Lynne and JP cover the case of Thomas “TJ” Hickey. A young boy whose death was covered up by police? Or just a tragic accident handled poorly?

In this week’s episode JP and Lynne put a cherry on top of the Octopus trilogy episodes. Robert Booth Nichols gets the spotlight - Was he in the CIA? Did he really think he was? … Is he actually dead? Who knows!

In this week's episode, JP and Lynne discuss the multiple disappearances and murder of Charles “Chuck” Morgan… Who is Green Eyes? Was this a mafia hit - or an affair gone wrong?

In this week's episode, Lynne and JP discuss the controversies surrounding Nikola Tesla. A huge case of whitewashing a brilliant man out of history? A government conspiracy? Aliens? Pigeons? You decide...

In this week’s episode, JP and Lynne discuss the disappearance of Juan Pedro Martinez… A tragic accident during a family road trip… but the child was never found?

In this week's episode, Lynne and JP discuss the murder of Charles Self in honor of Harvey Milk Day. One of Ireland's infamously unsolved LGBTQ+ crimes that helped spark a need for change…

In this week’s episode, JP and Lynne discuss the Iguala kidnappings, murders, and assaults of over a hundred college students in one night… Who ordered the hit? And Why? And where are the 43 kidnapped students? 

In this week’s episode, Lynne and JP discuss a string of missing teens from South Africa and a convicted pedofile and his girlfriend who may be involved...or maybe not? But if they are involved, then to what degree and how many victims did they really claim?