Skip to main content
Not Adding Up

Not Adding Up

By Patrick Hassen

A true-crime podcast looking into disappearances, unsolved murders, unexplained phenomena, and other true crime stories that just don't add up. I always bring a co-host along for the ride who has never heard the story.
Available on
Amazon Music Logo
Apple Podcasts Logo
Castbox Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
iHeartRadio Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Episode 24: What Happened to Jennifer Kesse?

Not Adding UpJan 14, 2023

00:00
40:18
Episode 37: The Unbelievable Death of Michael Chambers

Episode 37: The Unbelievable Death of Michael Chambers

Michael Chambers was a pillar of his community. A retired firefighter, serving for over 30 years, a local deacon, and a handyman who loved fixing anything for anyone. Michael seemed like he had it all, a loving wife, a large family, and even a designated space (his workshop) to pursue one of his biggest passions, cars. So when Michael vanished from his workshop in March 2017, everyone who knew him was left dumbfounded. Confusion would only grow as police would come forward with a narrative that Michael staged his disappearance and committed suicide by jumping from a 5-foot-tall bridge. Police would give this recollection of the tragedy around the same time Michaels's wife was cashing in his $750,000 life insurance policy.

Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1IfSaufNHVwjjShv-TZ_DCr2r553m5HzP1D3u2jNzG_U/edit?usp=sharing

May 23, 202317:00
Episode 36: Alexis Ware's Mysterious Right on Red

Episode 36: Alexis Ware's Mysterious Right on Red

Alexis Ware was last seen by her ex-boyfriend after meeting him at a 7/11 in Anderson County, SC, on January 30th, 2022. She was meeting him there to drop off her two children and follow him to his mother's house; however, when the pair approached a red light after pulling out, she would go around him and make a right on red, never to be seen again. Alexis shared some unsettling information with her mother while visiting the previous weekend. By February 1st, her mother reported her missing to the Anderson County Police, and the very next day, they made a confusing discovery.


Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1p5PVY2nQAzo88EDBLIya0uEY7F1wdXn4qoyjufR7ijA/edit?usp=sharing

May 11, 202326:16
Episode 35: Gary Grant Jr.'s Mysterious Appointment
Apr 19, 202319:29
Episode 34: The Disappearance of Mark Himebaugh

Episode 34: The Disappearance of Mark Himebaugh

Mark Himebaugh was walking home from school just like any other November weekday. He lived with his mother, Maureen, and his older brother in Del Haven, New Jersey. However, on a fateful Monday in November of 1991, his attention was captivated by a brush fire taking place not far from his home. When he got his mother's permission to go get a closer look, she would have no idea this would be the last time she would see her child.


Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1oM6AnDE47EHHiTlBWiKn9bYwx72nINkY0DXu902P-j0/edit?usp=sharing

Apr 14, 202317:52
Episode 33: A Rabbit Hole in New Hampshire (Part 2)
Mar 25, 202343:06
Episode 32: A Rabbit Hole in New Hampshire (Part 1)
Mar 18, 202348:33
Episode 31: The Springfield Three

Episode 31: The Springfield Three

In June 1992, Suzanne "Suzie" Streeter and Stacy McCall celebrated graduating from Kickapoo High School in Springfield, Missouri. Their celebrations were short; however, the pair would vanish from Streeter's house in the early morning hours the day after graduation. Not only are the two teenage girls missing, but Suzie's 47-year-old mother, Sherill Levitt, when they neglect to show up for their plans the next day, their friends do a wellness check. After finding all of their belongings inside, their fears escalate. Nothing seemed out of place; nothing was missing except for the three women who had been inside the night before. Over 30 years later, this case still haunts Springfield as an unsolved mystery.
Mar 11, 202346:29
Episode 30: Carla Stefaniak's Disturbing Trip to Costa Rica.

Episode 30: Carla Stefaniak's Disturbing Trip to Costa Rica.

In November 2018, Florida native Carla Stefaniak decided to take a trip to Costa Rica to celebrate her 36th birthday. The majority of her trip would go as planned, and she would enjoy the tropical vacation spot for a little under a week. That is until November 27th, when her sister-in-law, who had taken the trip with her, had to return home as they had different airline tickets. While we can trace Carla's whereabouts to around 9 PM that evening, following this, none of her friends or family heard from her. The next day was not only her birthday but the day she was supposed to travel home. When she would remain silent all day and not depart from the plane she was supposed to board, her friends' and family's worries escalated. It is not for a couple of days that a grisly discovery was made, and while someone has been punished for what took place on the evening of November 27th, 2018, almost all of the evidence points to the fact that they did not work alone. 


Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_T8JPZ5qrDXjLtulkMK_HMnhyEQbg4pusleiXtO9MTk/edit?usp=sharing

Feb 25, 202353:41
Episode 29: Insidious Indianapolis: Two Young Women Vanish Into the Night

Episode 29: Insidious Indianapolis: Two Young Women Vanish Into the Night

Jessica Masker was last seen at a gas station in East Washington, Indianapolis, on April 15th, 2013. Shortly before vanishing, Jessica would make a concerning phone call to her brother asking for a ride; when he told her he could not as he was already on his way to work, he suggested calling their mom. However, this is not what she did; she would call her boyfriend and arrange a pickup spot. However, she would never arrive at this location and has never been seen since. 

 Almost eight years later, Kirsten Brueggeman vanished from a location just 10 minutes away from Jessica's last known place. Kirsten left a bar parking lot on food in the middle of the night after arguing with her friends. While detectives were able to briefly trace her steps following her leaving the parking lot, the CCTV camera that was capturing her malfunctioned while she was walking through its view, leaving us to wonder was this a technical malfunction or something more sinister? 

Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1CyCyrET9WbAaugCwWx3ZLJpY3FDCxwfX1s7wuqkNTbU/edit?usp=sharing

Feb 18, 202328:55
Episode 28: Natalee Holloway, Stephany Flores Ramirez, and Joran van der Sloot’s Unfortunate Encounters.
Feb 11, 202339:47
Episode 27: Amy Lynn Bradley's Chilling Cruise
Feb 04, 202337:04
Episode 26: Branson Perry's Trip to the Shed

Episode 26: Branson Perry's Trip to the Shed

 On April 11th, 2001, 20-year-old Branson Perry vanished from his front yard after spending the day cleaning up his house for his father. He would tell his friend that helped him that day that he was going to put some jumper cables away in their shed and run out for a minute and that he would return shortly. Over 20 years later, there has been no sign of Branson beyond the jumper cables mysteriously appearing in front of the shed a few weeks following his disappearance. While his family was confident he would not just run away, they were baffled at what would have happened to their loved one. 

Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ztSYCYuyWSKSx4gwO-Ge3rzmIYd-Am-GGMm0LU_AwHQ/edit?usp=sharing

Jan 28, 202332:34
Episode 25: Was Pravin Varughese Murdered?

Episode 25: Was Pravin Varughese Murdered?

  Pravin Varughese was in his sophomore year at Southern Illinois University and enrolled in the criminal justice program. Pravin planned a typical night on the town on the evening of February 12th, 2014; however, the popular college student mysteriously disappeared around midnight. Less than a week later, his remains were found in the woods; the original autopsy ruled no foul play; however, the family points to evidence that says otherwise. It is known that Pravin got a ride from a stranger that evening, and this stranger was the last person to see him alive. The stranger admits the two got into a fight but insists he played no part in Pravin's death. Over four years following Pravin's death, a conviction is made, and a perpetrator is named, however briefly. Unfortunately, a judge soon threw out the ruling due to confusing terminology used with the jury, and the case is waiting to be re-tried. 


Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1La1zfvS-tp25KHUpUAC4dkJPcCSPHkh8dtYzHRygZyk/edit?usp=sharing

Jan 21, 202356:06
Episode 24: What Happened to Jennifer Kesse?
Jan 14, 202340:18
Episode 23: What was Justin Burgwinkel's Secret Mission?
Jan 06, 202324:48
Episode 22: Solved with a Grain of Salt Case #1 The Disappearance of Robert Wykel

Episode 22: Solved with a Grain of Salt Case #1 The Disappearance of Robert Wykel

Robert Wykel was a retired sheet metal worker living in Burien, Washington. Our case begins in February of 1996 when Wykel doesn't return from a routine trip to purchase a vintage vehicle, which he fixed up and sold for profit to supplement income. Wykel has many friends in the area, so his disappearance does not go unnoticed; even his daughter, hundreds of miles away in Illinois, begins to worry when she doesn't hear from her father. Their worries escalated in March when they were notified Roberts's vehicle had been impounded with no sign of Robert anywhere. Detectives would work for the next 15 years to find out what happened to Robert and who was responsible. 

Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-V6BIHtmHj3vxRlqIqXd2sr6BMJW4Nq2W0mAt4WHYro/edit?usp=sharing

Jan 05, 202339:39
Episode 21: Brandon Swanson's "Oh Sh*t" Disappearance
Dec 31, 202248:59
Episode 20: Lindsay Buziak's Brutal and Bizarre Murder

Episode 20: Lindsay Buziak's Brutal and Bizarre Murder

 Lindsay Buziak was a hard-working 24-year-old realtor, the youngest at her company, working in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada. She would impress all those around her with her work ethic and charisma. In late January 2008, the opportunity of a lifetime fell into Lindsay's lap, and while she felt uneasy about taking it, she couldn't pass it up. Her intuition, however, served her well as this opportunity proved far good to be true. Then, in a series of events that remain a mystery, Lindsay was brutally murdered. The crime had been committed, and the scene was cleaned in under 15 minutes, indicating whoever did this knew exactly what they were doing. 


Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KgHetG_lRhK3JsTahZjh-HYo_aU1qi1Yx3N7R0nLd2M/edit?usp=sharing

Dec 23, 202237:10
Episode 19: The Frustrating Death of Mitrice Richardson

Episode 19: The Frustrating Death of Mitrice Richardson

Mitrice was a recent college graduate who lived with her great-grandmother in LA while working two jobs. She aspired to obtain a doctorate in child psychology and work with children in the foster system. Unfortunately, she did not get the opportunity to pursue these goals. Amid a seeming mental episode, Mitrice was arrested by the LA Sheriff's Department in September 2009. She was released with no cell phone, no wallet, and over 20 miles from her vehicle a little after midnight. While there was a sighting of Mitrice just a few hours after her release, it would be months before a more gruesome discovery would be made.

Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12SOAk97Q7hlkhiVI9XVKvjHTuev-SeHm6evE7TFaTJc/edit?usp=sharing

Dec 16, 202201:14:54
Episode 18: The Perplexing Disappearance of Brian Shaffer
Dec 09, 202244:22
Episode 17: The Harrowing Case of Debbie Collier

Episode 17: The Harrowing Case of Debbie Collier

Debbie Collier was found deceased on September 11th, 2022, in Habersham County, Georgia. The day before her body was found, she would send her daughter an eerie message and a Venmo for nearly $2,400. After months of speculation, the autopsy report would rule Collier’s death a suicide, but questions remain. Tune in to this week's episode, where I discuss these tragic events with my father. 

Also, I wanted to say thanks to Crime on the Record Podcast for your interview with Amanda and for getting back to me about the case. 

Sources: 

https://docs.google.com/document/d/19K_X3xY3a1WDX-sxv4BTdxS-4piKbnmfKGDVOQ4rPDo/edit?usp=sharing

Dec 02, 202257:56
Episode 16: Luke Stout's Heartbreaking Disappearance

Episode 16: Luke Stout's Heartbreaking Disappearance

Luke Stout has been missing since July 2012 from Buckhannon, West Virginia. Despite his family raising alarm bells immediately, police showed reluctance to look into this disappearance, even in the face of evidence that potentially linked Luke to a murder-for-hire plot. Police would even refuse the help of a volunteer search organization that wanted to help the family. While this case remains an unsolved disappearance, there is plenty of evidence to allow anyone who cares to put together a comprehensive picture of what happened to Luke over ten years ago. 

Sources: 

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uRXNuAOqP5TAXnbFMCFGrsL5yfjv35nozJyPmfx9EtI/edit?usp=sharing


Nov 25, 202243:52
Episode 15: Where Is Maura Murray?

Episode 15: Where Is Maura Murray?

This week I cover one of the most famous disappearances in recent history, that of 21-year-old Maura Murray. Maura would go missing from the side of the road after being involved in a one-car accident on Route 112 in North Haverhill, New Hampshire. Two 911 calls were made in response to the accident, one man even stopped to offer help, but Maura refused any assistance. Less than 15 minutes after the man offered her help, police arrived to find no trace of Maura. Despite gaining worldwide recognition, her case remains unsolved almost two decades later, and the incidents leading up to her disappearance make her case so much more upsetting. 

Sources: 

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1alwuod4AC2eD_ai1MkaxC5UPcaPTgHMF-E6SJTFJ74Q/edit?usp=sharing

Nov 19, 202255:55
Episode 14: The Confusing Case of Kayelyn Louder

Episode 14: The Confusing Case of Kayelyn Louder

Kayelyn Louder was 30 years old when she went missing from Murray, Utah, on September 27, 2014. Despite CCTV footage capturing her multiple times on the day of her disappearance, she would seemingly vanish without a trace for over two months. It was revealed to the public that Kayelyn acted very strangely in the days leading up to her disappearance, indicating she was possibly experiencing a mental break. However, her family reports no history of mental illness and insists this is very out of character for Kayleyn. Two months after her disappearance, Kayelyns's body was found; however, the discovery of her body has helped little to explain what happened on the evening of September 27 that caused Kayelyn to behave in the way she did. Losing Kayelyn is not the only tragedy the Louder family has had to endure, and they deserve a resolution to the tragic death of their daughter, siblings, and loved one. 

Sources: 

CCTV Videos: https://www.ksl.com/article/31889543

Suicide Hotline: https://blog.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines/

NBC: https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/missing-in-america/update-missing-america-kayelyn-louder-n219596

Deseret: https://www.deseret.com/2015/4/16/20562756/kayelyn-louder-autopsy-inconclusive-but-family-insists-death-was-not-an-accident

Salt Lake Tribune: https://www.sltrib.com/news/crime/2014/12/02/police-say-body-found-in-river-is-missing-kayelyn-louder/

Daily Mail UK: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2859441/Body-woman-30-vanished-home-without-shoes-money-phone-two-months-ago-Utah-river.html

Crime Pulse: https://crimepulse.com/2021/01/what-actually-happened-to-kayelyn-louder/

Mysterious Universe: https://mysteriousuniverse.org/2021/07/strange-behavior-and-the-bizarre-unsolved-death-of-kayelyn-louder/

KUTV: https://kutv.com/news/local/cause-of-death-remains-unclear-for-kayelyn-louder

Colton Louder Obituary: https://www.brownfamilymortuary.com/obituaries/colton-louder

Kayelyn Louder Obituary: https://www.brownfamilymortuary.com/obituaries/kayelyn-louder

Nov 11, 202239:20
Episode 13: The Haunting Disappearance of Brandon Lawson

Episode 13: The Haunting Disappearance of Brandon Lawson

While on his way to his parents late at night in August 2013, Brandon Lawson ran out of gas. What seemed like a simple inconvenience quickly turned into a seemingly urgent situation. Brandon began making panicked calls to his brother, telling him he was being chased out of town. Brandon even goes as far as to call 911, seemingly out of character. What makes this case genuinely haunting is that when Brandon's brother got to the designated meeting spot to help him with his truck, Brandon told him he could see him; however, he was never found by his brother. Nearly a decade later, Brandon's loved ones are still left wondering what happened that night. 

Sources: 

GoSanAngelo: https://www.gosanangelo.com/story/news/2022/02/04/brandon-lawson-missing-911-call-remains-possibly-found-family-says/6668447001/

911 Call: http://sites.gsu.edu/almaexampleblog/police-call/

Uncovered: https://uncovered.com/cases/brandon-lawson

Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/helpfindbrandonlawson

Thought Catalog: https://thoughtcatalog.com/jordan-windnagle/2020/02/heres-everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-disappearance-of-brandon-lawson/

All That's Interesting: https://allthatsinteresting.com/brandon-lawson

Grunge: https://www.grunge.com/1001479/inside-the-mysterious-2013-disappearance-of-brandon-lawson/

Oxygen: https://www.oxygen.com/crime-news/brandon-lawson-who-vanished-in-2013-after-911-call-found

Nov 04, 202244:29
Episode 12: The Supposed Disappearance of George Smith

Episode 12: The Supposed Disappearance of George Smith

In this episode, I take you on another cruise ship. This time we follow George and Jessica Smith on their honeymoon. Around a week into their cruise, Geroge goes overboard under very suspicious circumstances. Jennifer can remember nothing from the night before and was found passed out in the hallway. This story is almost too crazy to believe that it was an "accident," and it screams foul play to me.

(Sources will be updated)
Oct 29, 202254:10
Episode 11: The Infuriating Death of Kenneka Jenkins
Oct 21, 202256:02
Episode 10: The Unexplaniable Disappearance of the Jamison Family

Episode 10: The Unexplaniable Disappearance of the Jamison Family

The Jamison family vanished seemingly without a trace for over four years. Their truck was discovered shortly after they were last seen; however, the vehicle's contents would raise far more questions than they answered. Over four years later, the family's bodies were all discovered together just 3 miles from the location their truck had been left. With not much to go off other than statements and an unsettling clip from their security camera, theories have emerged pointing to all sorts of foul play. From demonic possession to white supremacists, this episode has a little bit of everything awful, including (once again) a possible cult influence. 

Sources:

All That's Interesting: https://allthatsinteresting.com/jamison-family

Mystery Unsolved: https://sites.psu.edu/heidimoustafapassionblog/2021/02/06/case-6-the-jamison-family/

Strange Outdoors: https://www.strangeoutdoors.com/mysterious-stories-blog/jamison-family-mystery

Ranker: https://www.ranker.com/list/jamison-family-facts/lea-rose-emery

Forensic Tales: https://forensictales.com/jamison-family-deaths/

Oct 14, 202250:16
Episode 9: The Baffling Disappearance of Rebecca Coriam
Oct 07, 202254:47
Episode 8: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 4)

Episode 8: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 4)

Just when you think the case couldn't get any crazier (or more confusing), more evidence comes to light. Among the evidence is DNA linking the same person to three of the four victims, a new witness who says they saw Kristine get into a police officer's car at 7/11 that awful day in January 1977, and even three mysterious deaths claimed to be suicides. I also go over the most recent evidence discussed by professionals surrounding the case, as well as the theories of myself and co-host Abby of what happened over 40 years ago in Oakland County. 


Sources:

The Snow Killings by Marney Keenan: https://www.amazon.com/Snow-Killings-Inside-Oakland-Investigation/dp/1476684006

(This book is a wealth of information on the case; I will discuss it in my second episode. The author has a connection to the area and also appeared on the 5 part series that the Detroit news made recently on this case.)

Oakland County Child Killer docuseries chapter 4: the investigation: https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/2019/02/14/oakland-county-child-killer-docuseries-chapter-4-the-investigation/

Click on Detroit Media Stories: https://www.clickondetroit.com/topic/Oakland_County_Child_Killer/

Sep 30, 202201:14:02
Episode 7: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 3)
Sep 23, 202252:04
Episode 6: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 2)
Sep 15, 202201:06:39
Episode 5: The Strange Disappearances of Cieha Taylor and Veronica Reyes-Diaz
Sep 13, 202249:18
Episode 4: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 1)

Episode 4: Oakland County Child Killer (Part 1)

  This case takes place in the late 1970s in Oakland county, Michigan. Oakland County was and continues to be an affluent area full of wealth and prosperity, but when children began to go missing in 1976, the community was turned upside down. In the first part of this series, I will be going over the details of the murders involved in this case. Along with me is my friend Abby who will be my co-host for the series.  

Sources: 

The Snow Killings by Marney Keenan: https://www.amazon.com/Snow-Killings-Inside-Oakland-Investigation/dp/1476684006

(This book is a wealth of information on the case; I will discuss it in my second episode. The author has a connection to the area and also appeared on the 5 part series that the Detroit news made recently on this case.) 

Oakland County Child Killer docuseries chapter 1: North Fox Island: https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/2019/02/14/oakland-county-child-killer-docuseries-chapter-1-north-fox-island/ 

Oakland County Child Killer docuseries chapter 2: Out in the cold: https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/2019/02/14/oakland-county-child-killer-docuseries-chapter-2-out-in-the-cold/

Oakland County Child Killer docuseries chapter 3: Timmy King: https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/2019/02/14/oakland-county-child-killer-docuseries-chapter-3-timmy-king/


Sep 08, 202241:07
Episode 3: The Tragic and Mysterious Death of Jaleayah Davis

Episode 3: The Tragic and Mysterious Death of Jaleayah Davis

In this episode, I go over the tragic case of Jaleayah Davis, who was found dead on the side of the interstate after a presumed car accident. While the police insist this was just a single car accident, the family of Jaleayah refuses to believe this and insists there is some foul play involved. I am joined by my good friend Joni as I work through the horrific details of this case. 


Sources: 

Facebook page with police reports: https://www.facebook.com/justiceforjaleayah

Still a Mystery: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10439784/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk

Aug 28, 202201:02:45
Episode 2: The West Memphis 3 (Part 2)

Episode 2: The West Memphis 3 (Part 2)

In this episode, I review what has happened since the West Memphis 3 were convicted. Including new DNA evidence, jury misconduct, and even a surprise appearance from the Dixie Chicks??? Buckle Up. 

New Source: 

https://www.cnn.com/2022/06/23/us/west-memphis-three-dna-court-hearing/index.html

(Sources also used from part 1, which are listed in the episode description of Episode 1)

Aug 24, 202246:45
Episode 1: The West Memphis 3 (Part 1)

Episode 1: The West Memphis 3 (Part 1)

In this episode, I discuss the case of the West Memphis Three with my sister, Lauryl. This is a tragic case of the murder of three little boys and a less than convincing conviction of three teenagers for their murders. 


Sources: 

Paradise Lost: https://www.hbo.com/paradise-lost/season-1/1-paradise-lost

Untying the Knot by Greg Day: https://www.amazon.com/Untying-Knot-Byers-Memphis-Three/dp/1475911718

Devils Knot by Mara Leveritt: https://www.amazon.com/Devils-Knot-Story-Memphis-Three/dp/0743417607/ref=pd_lpo_3?pd_rd_i=0743417607&psc=1


Aug 20, 202201:05:57