Skip to main content
NYY Takes

NYY Takes

By NYY Takes

The NYY Takes podcast is the result of putting two disgruntled season ticket holders, a father of 5, and a long-distance Yankee fan in the same room, each equipped with a microphone.
Available on
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Ep.40: The Yankees Can't Stop Winning, Aaron Judge Made a Really Good Bet, and is Kyle Higashioka on the Clock?

NYY Takes May 04, 2022

00:00
42:57
2024 Will Be The End Of The Ho-Hum Yankees

2024 Will Be The End Of The Ho-Hum Yankees

On this episode of NYY Takes Coles, Toh, Les and Matt discuss the Jon Berti acquisition and his potential to be a key part of the roster. Then, they do 'Three Up, Three Down' to discuss players they are 'high' and 'low' on heading into the 2024 season including Caleb Ferguson, Luis Gil, Nick Burdi, Nestor Cortes and Anthony Volpe before finishing with another 'Unhinged Comment of the Week Segment'

Mar 28, 202456:09
John Brophy Shares His Best Spring Training Stories, Another Round of 'RRR' and Unhinged Comment of the Week

John Brophy Shares His Best Spring Training Stories, Another Round of 'RRR' and Unhinged Comment of the Week

On this episode of NYY Takes John Brophy joins the pod to discuss his Spring Training experience (6:56) including his '99 Burger Review' (8:10), joining NYY Undeground (15:20) and an amazing story about his selfie with Hal Steinbrenner (25:49). Then Les, Toh and Coles do a round of "Right On, Realistic or Ridiculous' (45:00) and Unhinged Comment of the Week (58:30).

Mar 22, 202401:04:13
Why 'Tax Reasons' are the Yankees' X-Factor

Why 'Tax Reasons' are the Yankees' X-Factor

On this episode of NYY Takes the crew plays another game of 'Right on, Ridiculous or Realistic' to recap the recent Spring Training news and notes including Carlos Rodon's Spring (6:39), Spencer Jones' rise (11:14) and why Tax Reasons will be to thank for the Yankees' 28th ring (15:50). Then, they wrap up with a new segment called 'Unhinged Comment of the Week' (27:30).

Mar 08, 202434:59
Name That Spring Training Quote

Name That Spring Training Quote

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh, Coles and Matt breakdown the biggest Spring Training stories through quotes, and guessing who said what.

Feb 21, 202440:01
Guessing Yankees Players Based on Their FanGraphs Projection

Guessing Yankees Players Based on Their FanGraphs Projection

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh, Coles and Les recap a trip to Hideki Matsui's favorite restaurant. Then, they discuss what the 90s Yankees and Scott Proctor have in common before finishing up with 'guessing Yankee players based on their Steamer projections'. Also, authentic Yankee Jerseys are very expensive.

Jan 31, 202440:22
Part Two of 'Right On, Realistic or Ridiculous?'

Part Two of 'Right On, Realistic or Ridiculous?'

On this episode of NYY Takes the full panel is back to play another game of 'Right On, Realistic or Ridiculous?' where we discuss some NYY Takes that are (or are not) ridiculous or right on.

Jan 17, 202440:44
The Yankees Are Back, and Three Yankees Fans Talked About it

The Yankees Are Back, and Three Yankees Fans Talked About it

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt, Toh and Coles discuss the Yankees' acquisition of Juan Soto, the possible signing of Yoshinobu Yamamoto and whether or not Aaron Boone can lead a star-studded clubhouse.

Dec 09, 202336:32
Two Yankees Fans Play a Game Called "Right-on, Realistic, or Ridiculous?"

Two Yankees Fans Play a Game Called "Right-on, Realistic, or Ridiculous?"

On this episode of NYY Takes, Toh and Coles introduce a brand new game called "Right-on Realistic, or Ridiculous?" to discuss some of the offseason's biggest storylines. And yes, they even go as far as to defend Brian Cashman.

Nov 23, 202329:29
Three Yankees Fans Discuss Brian Cashman Losing It

Three Yankees Fans Discuss Brian Cashman Losing It

On this episode of NYY Takes, Toh, Matt and Les discuss Brian Cashman's out-of-character press conference, and what it means for the upcoming off-season into next year. Is there any hope for the future? Also, Les makes an incredible revelation...

Nov 09, 202341:05
Part 2: Three Yankee Fans Conduct an Internal Audit

Part 2: Three Yankee Fans Conduct an Internal Audit

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt, Coles and Les come together to discuss the poorly watched World Series and all of its connections to the Yankees (00:00-14:50). They then talk about Sean Casey’s departure and Aaron Boone’s leash in 2024 (14:50 -20:50) before finishing off with Part 2 of their Audit (of the Yankees’ Audit) (20:50-43:50).
Nov 03, 202342:29
A Farewell to Pinstriped Prospects, Checking Egos at The Door and Yankee Fans Did a Survey

A Farewell to Pinstriped Prospects, Checking Egos at The Door and Yankee Fans Did a Survey

In this episode of NYY Takes, Coles and Toh bid farewell to Pinstriped Prospects, discuss Hal Steinbrenner's meeting with 15 high-ranking officials, and go over Yankee fan responses to The Athletic's team-related poll.
Oct 18, 202331:12
Part 1: Three Yankee Fans Conduct an Internal Audit

Part 1: Three Yankee Fans Conduct an Internal Audit

It's officially the off-season for the Yankees and Les, Toh and Coles came together to talk about the Yankees' upcoming internal audit, the organization's communication problems and the rise of Aaron Judge as a Player-GM.
Oct 04, 202343:26
A Rose, Thorn, and Bud for the 2023 and 2024 Yankees

A Rose, Thorn, and Bud for the 2023 and 2024 Yankees

Matt, Coles and Les talk about why sports are stupid (sometimes), their respective NBA and NFL fanhood, and finish up with what they are most looking forward to and dreading most for the 2024 Yankees season.

Sep 22, 202333:50
Three Yankees Fans Bid Farewell to Josh Donaldson

Three Yankees Fans Bid Farewell to Josh Donaldson

Toh, Matt, and Les put a bow on the New York Yankees tenure of Josh Donaldson. They also discuss if this means that the front office is finally admitting that the recent moves have been failures.


***SETUP AUTOMATIC DOWNLOADS***

Aug 30, 202326:07
Four Yankees Fans Ponder Brian Cashman’s Future

Four Yankees Fans Ponder Brian Cashman’s Future

On this episode of NYY Takes, the crew is joined by their #1 listener to discuss Brian Cashman's job security, the 'obvious' issues with the Yankees that weren't addressed in the offseason, and if the championship window is closed, closing or re-opening.
Aug 25, 202356:54
Four Yankees Fans Talk About Corporate Leadership

Four Yankees Fans Talk About Corporate Leadership

The NYY Takes Crew discusses all things 'off' about the Yankees including delusions of success, poor coaching habits, toxic corporate leadership and being more of a company than a baseball team.

Aug 18, 202347:46
Ep. 89: The 2023 Yankees 'Disaster Draft'

Ep. 89: The 2023 Yankees 'Disaster Draft'

On this episode of NYY Takes, the crew got together to warm up for Fantasy Football season by drafting the worst Yankee moments and story lines of the 2023 season. The choices were nearly endless.

Aug 10, 202354:02
Ep. 88: What's in front of us?

Ep. 88: What's in front of us?

Toh and Les try to make sense of everything that's been going on in the world of the New York Yankees. They discuss Brian Cashman's lack of activity moving at the trade deadline and Hal Steinbrenner's involvement in baseball operations before dissecting the bizarre situations involving Domingo German and Anthony Rizzo. Finally, an ode to Oracle Park and Clear.

Aug 04, 202334:10
Ep. 87: It's All In Front of Us

Ep. 87: It's All In Front of Us

Toh, Coles and Les talk about the Yankees' recent struggles, the lack of benefits that Season Ticket Holders receive, Carlos Rodon blowing a kiss, the end of Josh Donaldson's career, and what it might take for people to believe in this team again.

Jul 21, 202347:28
Ep. 86: Let's Talk About The Weirdest Week In Recent Yankees Memory

Ep. 86: Let's Talk About The Weirdest Week In Recent Yankees Memory

On this episode of NYY Takes, Toh and Coles delve into their preseason predictions to see how right (and wrong) they were, discuss the 'tension' within the Yankees' locker room, analyze the hiring of Sean Casey, examine the trolling of Brian Cashman, touch upon the MTA and Starr Insurance, and explore a plethora of topics unrelated to baseball, but related very much so to the New York Yankees.


Jul 14, 202349:29
Ep. 85: Recapping the MLB Draft with John Brophy + Bryan Hoch Brings Us Behind The Scenes of His New Book

Ep. 85: Recapping the MLB Draft with John Brophy + Bryan Hoch Brings Us Behind The Scenes of His New Book

On this special episode of NYY Takes, John and Rob discuss the Yankees' 2023 draft class, including George Lombard Jr., Kyle Carr, and Roc Riggio. They also highlight a catching prospect to keep an eye on from the later rounds. Later in the episode, MLB.com's Bryan Hoch joins the podcast (23:30) to provide a behind-the-scenes look into the process that led to his new book, 62: Aaron Judge, the New York Yankees, and the Pursuit of Greatness.

Jul 13, 202342:33
Ep. 84: Did The Yankees Have Any All-Star Snubs?

Ep. 84: Did The Yankees Have Any All-Star Snubs?

On this episode of NYY Takes Robert discusses whether or not Gleyber, Rizzo and some members of the Yankees' bullpen were snubbed from this year's All-Star Game.

Jul 03, 202310:58
Ep. 83: We Asked John Brophy About Feet

Ep. 83: We Asked John Brophy About Feet

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt, Toh and Coles were joined by John Brophy to discuss Josh Donaldson's bright future (?), Aaron Judge's potential season-ending injury, Carlos Rodon Feet-Gate, Immaculate Grid and Alek Manoah struggling in the FCL.

Jun 28, 202358:50
Ep. 82: Aaron Boone's First Temper Tantrum of 2023

Ep. 82: Aaron Boone's First Temper Tantrum of 2023

On this episode of NYY Takes, Les and Coles discuss Aaron Boone's recent temper, whether his job should be on the line, and why they take some solace in stepping away from Yankees baseball from time to time.

Jun 21, 202333:33
Ep. 81: Judge And The Yankees Have Trust Issues?

Ep. 81: Judge And The Yankees Have Trust Issues?

On this episode of NYY Takes Les, Toh and Coles discuss Aaron Judge's injury saga and what Judge's career tells us about his relationship with the Yankees organization. They also talk about Clay Holmes' recent success, Anthony Rizzo's struggles, the mundane nature of Yankees games, the Warrior John Sterling, and not optioning Anthony Volpe.

Jun 14, 202351:13
Ep. 80: What do Outfield Walls, Aaron Judge and Cameron Toh All Have in Common?

Ep. 80: What do Outfield Walls, Aaron Judge and Cameron Toh All Have in Common?

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt and Rob talk Aaron Judge To(h)e-gate and the need to update outfield walls, Nestor Cortes' career possibly heading into its downturn, Jake Bauers' golden opportunity, some worrying Gerrit Cole stats, and the sentimental feelings that Tommy Kahnle and Gary Sanchez provide.

Jun 07, 202356:14
Ep. 79: Reinforcements are on the Way

Ep. 79: Reinforcements are on the Way

On this episode of NYY Takes Les and Robert discuss Oswaldo Cabrera getting sent down, concerns surrounding Harrison Bader's durability, how the 2019 juiced balls got DJ LeMahieu a payday, the Gary Sanchez Resurgence bandwagon, and the Yankees being the best team in baseball in the month of May. Also, the returns of Kahnle, Donaldson and Stanton may give us a better idea of the identity of this team moving forward.
Jun 02, 202343:23
Ep. 78: Let's Eulogize Aaron Hicks and Talk About the Private Equitization of Baseball

Ep. 78: Let's Eulogize Aaron Hicks and Talk About the Private Equitization of Baseball

On this episode of NYY Takes the full panel is back together to fawn over the Yankees’ recent success, talk about Aaron Hicks' Yankees career and baseball's streaming problem. They also go Three Up, Three Down where they discuss DJ LeMahieu's struggles, Anthony Rizzo's standout season and why the Yankees need to do better for their season ticket holders.
May 24, 202346:46
Ep. 77: The Yankees Cheat Their Way to a Series Win in Toronto!

Ep. 77: The Yankees Cheat Their Way to a Series Win in Toronto!

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh and Coles discuss all the wackiness from the Yankees this week including Donaldson slicing his hand open, cheating allegations, Ben Rortvedt's return, Carlos Rodon throwing a baseball and who the famed 'fat boy' was. They also do their weekly Three Up, Three Down segment where they talk about the normalcy and swag Aaron Judge brings, the extra-innings rule and the Yankees' sloppy defense.
May 19, 202346:58
Ep. 76: A Season Defining Week?

Ep. 76: A Season Defining Week?

On this episode of NYY Takes Cam and Coles talk about the Yankees' lack of fire, years of injury confusion, outspoken player wives, and reasons for hope with a big weekend ahead.

May 10, 202343:45
Ep. 75: Panic Button Chatter, Clay Holmes' Command Issues and a Lesson on Accountability

Ep. 75: Panic Button Chatter, Clay Holmes' Command Issues and a Lesson on Accountability

On this episode of 'NYY Takes', Matt and Rob discuss whether Yankees fans should be close to the panic button. They then go into Three Up Three Down (14:47) which includes some tough Brian Cashman quotes and where it's all going wrong for Clay Holmes. They also mix in some positivity with a dive into Gerrit Cole's dominant start to the year and Anthony Volpe's steady improvement.
May 04, 202343:47
Ep. 74: The Going is Getting Tough

Ep. 74: The Going is Getting Tough

The Yankees are struggling and Toh, Matt and Coles had to talk about it. Segments include over/under for injuries, three up and three down, and a shout-out to the other New York sports teams.
Apr 26, 202347:52
Ep. 73: Will The Yankees' Injuries Cost Them the AL East?

Ep. 73: Will The Yankees' Injuries Cost Them the AL East?

Matt and Coles talk about the Yankees' injury woes, run through 'Three Up Three Down', and opine on the Bombers' chances of catching the Rays in the AL East.

Apr 21, 202335:33
Ep. 72: The Yankees are Revolutionizing Base Stealing

Ep. 72: The Yankees are Revolutionizing Base Stealing

On this episode of NYY Takes: Toh and Coles talk more about the ho-hum Yankees, Season Ticket complaints, the Yankees' base stealing prowess, and the future of Franchy Cordero.

Apr 12, 202334:52
Ep. 71: The Ho-Hum Yankees?

Ep. 71: The Ho-Hum Yankees?

On today's episode, the NYY Takes Crew recaps the Yankees 4-2 start to the season, and talks about why it's good to be boring, Gerrit Cole's dominance, Gleyber Torres' great start, the Aaron Hicks Drama, and Aroldis Chapman being back. It's also the first Three Up, Three Down of the 2023 season!

Apr 06, 202336:42
Ep. 70: 'Twas The Night Before Christmas

Ep. 70: 'Twas The Night Before Christmas

Opening Day is Here! The NYY Takes crew discusses Anthony Volpe's Major League Moment, where the concern should be for this (very injured) team, a big year ahead for Giancarlo Stanton and everyone's One Big Prediction.

Mar 30, 202354:08
Ep. 69: John Brophy Joins the Pod, Volpe Opening Day Chatter, Martian Hype Train, Position Battles, and Gary Sanchez is Back?

Ep. 69: John Brophy Joins the Pod, Volpe Opening Day Chatter, Martian Hype Train, Position Battles, and Gary Sanchez is Back?

John Brophy (@jbrophybaseball) joins Rob, Less and Matt this week to talk Jasson Dominguez' and Anthony Volpe's hot Springs, positional battles, what happened to Estevan Florial, and is Gary Sanchez re-entering our lives? 

Mar 08, 202345:53
Ep. 68: A Season of Change, And Much of the Same, Awaits

Ep. 68: A Season of Change, And Much of the Same, Awaits

On today's episode, the NYY Takes Crew is back after a long offseason to discuss the Yankees' potentially redundant roster heading into the 2023 campaign, how the rule changes will change the game of baseball, and what they are most excited about heading into another campagin.
Mar 01, 202337:27
Ep. 67: The Free Market Reigns Supreme

Ep. 67: The Free Market Reigns Supreme

On this episode of NYY Takes, Toh, Less, Rob and Matt discuss Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees, what it means to be named Yankee Captain, and what they want the Yankees to do next. 

Dec 08, 202228:54
Ep. 66: The Aaron Judge Sweepstakes and Volpe 2 NYY? Plus Trading Gleyber and Josh Donaldson is Here to Stay

Ep. 66: The Aaron Judge Sweepstakes and Volpe 2 NYY? Plus Trading Gleyber and Josh Donaldson is Here to Stay

On this episode of NYY Takes Les, Toh and Coles discuss Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone's quotes following the 2022 season, and take some guesses on what will be different about the 2023 roster. 

Nov 09, 202235:43
Ep. 65: A Tame Dismantling Of The New York Yankees

Ep. 65: A Tame Dismantling Of The New York Yankees

Matt, Toh, Coles and Les got together to eulogize the 2022 Yankees season in the tamest fashion possible. 

Oct 25, 202253:26
Ep. 64: The Yankees Are Off To Houston!

Ep. 64: The Yankees Are Off To Houston!

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt, Toh and Coles recap a wacky ALDS, give their ups and downs for the series, and wonder if the Yankees are ready to go into Houston and steal a game. 

Oct 19, 202232:55
Ep. 63: Is Aaron Boone's Job On The Line in Game 5?

Ep. 63: Is Aaron Boone's Job On The Line in Game 5?

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh and Coles break down Aaron Boone's head-scratching decision-making in game three of the ALDS, and how it's a microcosm of the New York Yankees as a whole. But even with all of that, they are confident in a Game 5 win. 

Oct 17, 202223:01
Ep. 62: It's That Time of Year Again...

Ep. 62: It's That Time of Year Again...

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh, Less and Matt discuss Aroldis Chapman's flame-out as a New York Yankee, preview the ALDS and share their hopes and fears, and finish it off with predictions, as always. Give us a follow on Twitter! @pinstripepers. 

Oct 11, 202226:05
Ep. 61: Have the Yankees Won the World Series Yet?

Ep. 61: Have the Yankees Won the World Series Yet?

The first POSTSEASON episode of NYY Takes! Matt, Toh, Les and Robert discuss Aaron Judge's insane season, their favorite and least favorite parts of the 2022 season, and debate who they would rather face in the ALDS between the Guardians and Rays. Also, who is the most likely to be this year's postseason hero? You can follow the playoff run along with us on Twitter, @pinstripepers!
Oct 07, 202247:45
Ep. 60: Burning Playoff Roster Questions, Somerset Wins it All, and Judge Gets 61

Ep. 60: Burning Playoff Roster Questions, Somerset Wins it All, and Judge Gets 61

On this episode of NYY Takes Matt, Rob and Toh break down their ideal playoff rosters for both the ALDS and ALCS, discuss how the two-seed is a blessing in disguise, and make now irrelevant predictions on when Aaron Judge would his his 61st home run. As always, remember to follow us on Twitter @pinstripepers and thank you for listening! 

Sep 29, 202246:06
Ep. 59: Does Judge’s Home Run Chase Need More Attention?

Ep. 59: Does Judge’s Home Run Chase Need More Attention?

On this episode of NYY Takes the full panel of Les, Matt, Rob and Toh is back together to discuss all things Aaron Judge, the MVP Debate, what's cooler between 70 home runs and the Triple Crown, and do their ups and downs of the week. As always, please rate and subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss an episode and give us a follow on Twitter @pinstripepers!
Sep 20, 202251:57
Ep. 58: An Awkward Derek Jeter Ceremony, The Yankees Avoid Collapse and Jordan Montgomery's R2C2 Appearance

Ep. 58: An Awkward Derek Jeter Ceremony, The Yankees Avoid Collapse and Jordan Montgomery's R2C2 Appearance

On this episode of NYY Takes Toh and Coles discuss their experience at Derek Jeter's Hall of Fame Ceremony on Friday night (including a live unboxing!), the Yankees saving their own season, and Jordan Montomery's choice words during his appearance on the R2C2 Podcast. 

Sep 14, 202256:60
Ep. 57: What Would it Take for Brian Cashman to Lose His Job?

Ep. 57: What Would it Take for Brian Cashman to Lose His Job?

On this episode of NYY Takes Les, Matt and Rob discuss why Aaron Judge's MVP case is so much more riveting than Shohei Ohtani's, what it would take for Brian Cashman to lose his job, and of course go three up, three down and preview a huge upcoming series against Tampa. 

Sep 08, 202256:14
Ep. 56: Do the Yankees have Jet Lag? And Where Would They be Without Aaron Judge?

Ep. 56: Do the Yankees have Jet Lag? And Where Would They be Without Aaron Judge?

On this episode of 'NYY Takes' Matt, Toh and Rob break down one of the worst months of Yankees baseball in their lifetimes, assess the true value of Aaron Judge to this, and have some surprise three up, three down takes. 

Sep 01, 202257:36