Skip to main content
Reel Disagreement

Reel Disagreement

By Amy and Rob

Two friends with vastly different taste in movies make each other watch movies they can't believe the other one hasn't seen yet. Some are classics, some are guilty pleasures, but the chat is always contentious. Warning! Spoilers and naughty words.
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Castbox Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Overcast Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Reel Disagreement #4: Kevin Kline

Reel DisagreementMar 04, 2018

00:00
01:03:42
Quarantine Recommendations

Quarantine Recommendations

We're back! In this episode we talk about things to watch, read, or listen to during this unprecedented time. Please enjoy and stay tuned for more regularly scheduled episodes! We hope...

Apr 18, 202001:13:23
Brendan Fraser Lost in Time

Brendan Fraser Lost in Time

In this episode we discuss two "lost in time" movies both starring our new favorite, Brendan Fraser. Okay, he was always a favorite and "Blast from the Past" and "Encino Man" make it very clear why we love him. Also, PAULY SHORE. 

Dec 28, 201901:17:57
Loud Voices

Loud Voices

This episode we take a look at two films with clear authorial voices, two films that come from a distinct and pronounced culture - ok, really we just wanted to force each other to watch these. "My Big Fat Greek Wedding" and "Dolemite." Put some windex on it, muthaf*cka!

Sep 27, 201901:16:20
Twin Crap

Twin Crap

We tried to talk about twin films "Deep Impact" and "Armageddon" but we just couldn't. So instead, we talked about general ideas regarding movies and art, trying hard and still making a bad movie, jam bands, and codpieces. We hope you enjoy! SPOILER ALERT! At about the 32 minute mark we talk about "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood" and totally give away the ending. Rejoin at 43 minutes. 

Sep 13, 201901:01:03
Summer Break

Summer Break

More apologies for not being timely.
Aug 08, 201903:13
Vampires and Ham

Vampires and Ham

This episode we look at some 1980s vampire movies "Once Bitten" and "Vampire's Kiss". We get very silly and there is a lot of giggling - oh! And vulva eruptions!

Jun 17, 201901:42:43
S2Ep1: Keanu Double Sequel Feature

S2Ep1: Keanu Double Sequel Feature

In the first episode of our second season, we DON'T discuss two of Keanu Reeves's best movies; we discuss their sequels! Listen to us slog through "Matrix: Reloaded" and "Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey" in this long episode featuring favorite guest, Tom Buck from The Enthusiasm Project. 

Apr 28, 201901:39:53
Season 2 Teaser and Latkes

Season 2 Teaser and Latkes

It's been a whole year! We can't believe it. It's been so much fun and we're going to keep doing this, whether anyone is listening or not. This is a quick nugget of us being goofy and not talking about our assigned movies and previewing our next pairing which will kick off season 2 of Reel Disagreement.

Apr 08, 201919:12
The One that Shoulda and the One That Did

The One that Shoulda and the One That Did

In this episode, we look at the 2003 Oscars for Best Picture - the one that won "Chicago" and the one that maybe should've won: "Gangs of New York." We also describe Rob's dance moves and talk about the weird meme cat. And we look for Ana. 

Mar 19, 201901:40:44
Episode 26: Two movies from 2018

Episode 26: Two movies from 2018

In this episode we look at two movies from 2018 that we picked mainly because Amy's list was really short. Turns out, "Venom" and "Sorry to Bother You" are both about megalomaniacal jerks who want to take over the world - so it was a good pairing. 

Mar 05, 201901:31:30
Episode 26 teaser

Episode 26 teaser

Make sure to find us wherever you listen to podcasts and like, rate and review us. Also, find and share us on Facebook and Twitter (@reelfights).

Thanks!

Feb 26, 201900:55
Reel Disagreement #25 Part 2: Sandy B and Her Boy Ben

Reel Disagreement #25 Part 2: Sandy B and Her Boy Ben

This is part 2 of a very long episode discussing "Miss Congeniality," "Demolition Man," and Rob's inappropriate relationship with Amy's mom. 

Dec 27, 201801:05:53
Reel Disagreement #25: Sandy B and Her Boy Ben

Reel Disagreement #25: Sandy B and Her Boy Ben

This episode is part one of a deep dive into two films starring Sandra Bullock and Benjamin Bratt. Part one examines "Miss Congeniality" and Rob makes some off-putting jokes about Amy's mom.
Dec 15, 201843:28
Episode 24: Roaring Girl

Episode 24: Roaring Girl

This episode looks at two Melanie Griffith movies, Roar and Working Girl. One has animals covered in hair and the other is Roar! (That's an Alec Baldwin hairy chest joke). Enjoy!
Nov 18, 201801:36:57
Episode 23: Halloweenies

Episode 23: Halloweenies

In this episode we discuss two beloved Halloween films. One is a Halloween film and the other is a classic zombie movie, so that counts! Dawn of the Dead and Hocus Pocus are facing off. We also have a special guest! Please enjoy.
Nov 04, 201801:36:50
Reel Disagreement Episode 22: High School Movies

Reel Disagreement Episode 22: High School Movies

Back after a month-long medically induced hiatus, Amy and Rob take on 80's high school movies. Just One of the Guys and Better Off Dead are put under the microscope in this episode and, well, it's hard to tell how the hosts feel about them because of all the time they spend talking about other things from the 80's.
Oct 13, 201801:17:37
Reel Disagreement Episode 21: Blowin' Stuff Up

Reel Disagreement Episode 21: Blowin' Stuff Up

In this episode we talk about censorship, parenthood, fascism... oh, and Independence Day and Starship Troopers.
Sep 04, 201801:26:04
Episode 20: So Bad They're Good

Episode 20: So Bad They're Good

In this episode we struggle through a couple of so bad they're good movies: Wild Things and Miami Connection. If you like ninjas, fighting, and girl on girl action, well this is the episode for you.
Aug 20, 201801:21:13
Reel Disagreement Episode 19: When Objects Kill!

Reel Disagreement Episode 19: When Objects Kill!

In this episode, we discuss movies about inanimate objects turning on their human masters: Rubber and Maximum Overdrive. We also discuss the relationship between an artist and the audience and what responsibilities exist in that exchange.
Aug 05, 201801:28:28
Episode 18: Summer Fun

Episode 18: Summer Fun

In this episode, we are just trying not to melt. The heat is so bad that we stayed in our houses and entertained ourselves with The 'Burbs and Doctor Detroit. It worked for a while.
Jul 26, 201801:11:27
Reel Disagreement Episode 17: mothers!

Reel Disagreement Episode 17: mothers!

This episode, we discuss movies about mothers with our SPECIAL GUEST! We take a look at Aronofsky's mother! and the Herbert Ross classic, Steel Magnolias. We also examine Rob's dead soul.
Jul 16, 201801:24:20
Episode 15 Part 2: Movies We Loved When We Were 13

Episode 15 Part 2: Movies We Loved When We Were 13

In part two of Movies We Loved When We Were 13, we take a look at the Schwarzenegger classic, Commando. We also discuss Rob's thighs quite a bit, as well as sing a little Danzig.
Jul 07, 201843:41
Reel Disagreement #15 part 1: Movies We Loved When We Were 13

Reel Disagreement #15 part 1: Movies We Loved When We Were 13

In this two parter, we discuss the movies that adolescent us loved and that adult us are a tad embarrassed about.
Jun 27, 201801:09:50
Reel Disagreement Episode 14: This One Goes to 11

Reel Disagreement Episode 14: This One Goes to 11

Episode 14 goes to 11...while doves cry. We decided to tackle musical movies, one we both had never seen and one we both love. One is a dumpster fire and the other is a perfect movie. Listen while we take apart This is Spinal Tap and Purple Rain. We also firmly establish that Rob has never been a 13 year old girl.
Jun 13, 201801:23:21
Reel Disagreement #12.2: Dueling Dozen Part 2: El Topo

Reel Disagreement #12.2: Dueling Dozen Part 2: El Topo

This is part two of our conversation with Evan Unruh. In part 1 we talked about Clueless and in this one we tackle El Topo, and really, the nature of Art. Yeah. It's a big deal.
Jun 01, 201801:14:33
Reel Disagreement #12: Dueling Dozen Part 1

Reel Disagreement #12: Dueling Dozen Part 1

We decided to go back to our roots and pick movies that would definitely have us fighting. Too much agreement lately. But when we added a special guest, we talked for too long! So here is part one in which we discuss Clueless, Emma, Real Housewives of Whatever, and Dostoyevski.
May 20, 201855:25
Reel Disagreement #11: Fearless Feminists

Reel Disagreement #11: Fearless Feminists

This episode we take a look at two movies with feisty females and feminist story lines: 9 to 5 and Tootsie. We talk about looking at these movies in the #metoo era, Mike Pence, and shark teeth.
May 06, 201801:12:36
Reel Disagreement #10: Musical Masks

Reel Disagreement #10: Musical Masks

This week, we let other people do the singing since neither of us can. Frank and Hedwig and the Angry Inch are up for discussion and you can sing along!
Apr 24, 201801:16:22
Reel Disagreement #9: Old Monsters, New Twists

Reel Disagreement #9: Old Monsters, New Twists

This week we fight about two movies that take old monsters and approach them in new, more modern ways: Frankenhooker and Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
Apr 17, 201801:09:27
Reel Disagreement #8: Science Fiction Double Feature

Reel Disagreement #8: Science Fiction Double Feature

This week we discuss Fire in the Sky and The Fly, but until after we discuss a bunch of other stuff. It's a long one, but our departures are fun and make us and you question how you like a story to be told.
Apr 12, 201801:32:37
Reel Disagreement #7: By Hook or by Crook

Reel Disagreement #7: By Hook or by Crook

Disclaimer: There are about 10 seconds of sound missing at about 14 minutes in. Sorry! Not sure what happened... still learning!
In this very special episode, we discuss only one film, a film that inspires love or hate, nothing in between - Hook. Grab your Lost Boys and get ready for a heated debate. Bangarang!
Mar 27, 201801:06:18
Reel Disagreement #6: Smooth Swayze

Reel Disagreement #6: Smooth Swayze

This week we explore Patrick Swayze's various contributions to cinematic history by discussing Dirty Dancing and Roadhouse.
Mar 20, 201801:15:55
Reel Disagreement #5: Slice and Ice

Reel Disagreement #5: Slice and Ice

In this episode, with our new name, we discuss The Cutting Edge and Bone Tomahawk. The commentary is... sharp. We hope your response isn't... cold. Warning: Major spoilers and inappropriate cuddling talk.
Mar 14, 201801:10:12
Reel Disagreement #4: Kevin Kline

Reel Disagreement #4: Kevin Kline

Who doesn't love Kevin Kline? Not us. We felt like talking about this American treasure and so we watched A Fish Called Wanda and French Kiss.
Mar 04, 201801:03:42
Reel Disagreement #3: Meanies

Reel Disagreement #3: Meanies

This week's selections were about mean people: Rob watched Mean Girls and Amy watched Green Room. Skinheads and socialites. Apologies in advance, the sound is a bit wonky on this one. Sorry!
Mar 04, 201801:04:33
Reel Disagreement #2: The Devil

Reel Disagreement #2: The Devil

For our second episode, the theme was very loosely The Devil. Amy watched The Exorcist and Rob watched The Devil Wears Prada. We said it was loose.
Mar 04, 201801:06:11
Reel Disagreement #1: Sinful Songstresses

Reel Disagreement #1: Sinful Songstresses

In our first episode, Amy makes Rob watch Pitch Perfect and Rob makes Amy watch Beyond the Valley of the Dolls. Sex, drugs, and a cappella.
Mar 04, 201801:08:04