Skip to main content
Scam City

Scam City

By Cass Alcide & Taylor Davis

Scams rule everything around us. Cass and Taylor, your sisters in scam, unpack the most notorious grifts and biggest downfalls.
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Overcast Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Slicing Up the Fruitcake Fraud: Sandy Jenkins Embezzles $17 million from Collin Street Bakery

Scam CityMar 14, 2022

00:00
01:05:02
Slicing Up the Fruitcake Fraud: Sandy Jenkins Embezzles $17 million from Collin Street Bakery

Slicing Up the Fruitcake Fraud: Sandy Jenkins Embezzles $17 million from Collin Street Bakery

Corsicana, Texas is home to four things: Exxon, the Navarro Cheer team, the largest fruitcake manufacturer in the world, and the embezzlement of said largest fruitcake manufacturer in the world.
Over the course of 10 years, Sandy Jenkins, Collin Street Bakery's executive comptroller and sole person in charge of all accounting, wrote 888 checks from O.P.P. (Other People’s Pocketbooks) totaling $17 million. Why? So that he and his wife, Kay, could live that jet-set life, drive lavish cars, and buy out a Neiman Marcus.
Stealing from a #SmallBusiness is anything but sweet. Especially when you’re in a small town and everyone is in the business of being in everyone else’s business.
Question of the Scam: You're are a scammer and millions of dollars have fallen into your lap, you waste no time spending this money on lavish luxuries (as scammers do!) BUT people in your small town begin to question where this money came from. What's your lie?
In each episode, Cass and Taylor rate the scam! Here are this week's results.
OVERALL RESULTS
Taylor: 1, 4, 3
Cass: 5, 1, 4
Mar 14, 202201:05:02
Leave Room for Jesus: Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker Scam Evangelists Out of $150 Million

Leave Room for Jesus: Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker Scam Evangelists Out of $150 Million

Question of the scam: We all live for an experience or at least a 4-day vacation - but what if your experience was at a religious-themed theme park? Would you spend $1,000 to attend a Christian version of Disneyland? Scam City is back for season two with “Leave Room for Jesus: How Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker Scammed Evangelists Out of $150 Million”!
The apostle Paul called himself the “Chief of Sinners,” and then Jim Bakker said hold my beer. Between 1966 and 1987, beloved televangelical, Tammy Faye Bakker, and her husband, Jim Bakker were peddling the good Lord’s Word for profit and power on through their own religious network, PTL aka Praise the Lord/People that Love. Endeared by millions of viewers across the country and world, their meteoric rise to Evangelist celebrity status was made possible by the faith and generosity of countless believers, who tuned into PTL’s television programs and donated to its telethons. What their viewers didn't know was that they were paying for the Bakker's life of luxury which included multiple houses, expensive cars, an ac-equipped dog house and more money than God, until their empire all came crashing down amid sex and financial scandals.
Digressions include The Surreal Life, Bet Uncut, waterslides and whether or not Kanye is the new Jim Bakker.

Follow Scam City on Instagram.
Sep 19, 202101:22:18
Don’t Hate the Player, Hate the Game - How Jerome "Uncle Jerry" Jacobson McScammed $24 Million from McDonald's Monopoly

Don’t Hate the Player, Hate the Game - How Jerome "Uncle Jerry" Jacobson McScammed $24 Million from McDonald's Monopoly

Question of the scam: We all have a friend who seems to know someone who knows someone. So imagine that your homegirl presents you the opportunity to “win” a contest for a million dollars. You have to decide three things: do you do it, yes or no?

Do you take your money upfront in a lump sum or in small payments of $50,000/yr for 20 years? Finally, do you pay the $50,000 finders fee she’s demanding to her and all of the “someones” involved upfront or ask that you have a year to pay them back?

Don’t Hate the Player, Hate the Game - How Jerome "Uncle Jerry" Jacobson McScammed $24 Million from McDonald's Monopoly 

It all began in 1987 with a little nationwide Monopoly game McDonald's cooked up, which saw customers feverishly collecting game pieces attached to drink cups, french fry packets, magazine ads and...selling on Bay.  The game promised lavish vacation, cars, and the chance to win $1 million,  but no one ever actually won anything more than a double serving of fries, and that's because the game was rigged for 12 years by a former cop named Jerome "Uncle Jerry" Jacobson.  In deep dive published by The Daily Beast (most recently optioned to be the blueprint for an upcoming film chronicling the grift a la Hustlers) Uncle Jerry had insider access to the pieces while working as director of security for Simon Marketing, the company in charge of producing the game pieces. What started as just stealing one small fry piece, turned into a network of scamming with accomplices that included the mob, psychics, ex-cons, drug dealers, strip club owners, housewives, and a Mormon family, all guilty for falsely claiming more than $24 million in cash and prizes.

Digressions include Titanic, The Wolf of Wall Street, Black mothers asking about your "McDonald's money," and why this grift could've only been executed by a white man. 

Each episode Cass and Taylor rate the scam! Here's this week's results.

OVERALL RESULTS 

Taylor: 2.6 

Cass: 3 

Follow today's sponsored brand, By Santos on Instagram and don't forget to visit By-Santos.com to get a discount using the code featured in this episode! 

Follow Scam City on Instagram 


Nov 26, 201956:53
"Love In This (Scores Strip) Club": Hustlers Movie Recap

"Love In This (Scores Strip) Club": Hustlers Movie Recap

*Spoilers Ahead (even though you  already know the story since you listened to our "Make That Money, Don't Let It Make You" episode, right?!)*

In this very special bonus episode of Scam City, Taylor and Cass discuss Lorene Scarfaria's masterpiece, Hustlers starring Jennifer Lopez, Constance Wu, Lily Reinhart and Keke Palmer. Digressions include Constance Wu's wig,  J.Lo resurrecting her Juicy couture, Usher's cameo, and why Will Ferrell and Adam McKay are the only white men we stan. 

Now that this is a professional podcast, we've got our very first sponsor! Listen for the code mentioned in the ad for 15% off your first pair of Mosley Jackson handcrafted clay earrings. While you're waiting for your earrings to made and sustainably shipped to you, follow Mosley Jackson on IG.

If you want to read any of the articles we referenced, you can find them here:

The Oral History of Hustlers 

How Roselyn Keo's Story inspired Hustlers 

How Hustlers Pulled Off the Meta Cameo of the Year

Sep 14, 201901:09:04
Make That Money, Don't Let It Make You: The Real Life Hustlers at Scores
Aug 01, 201949:55
Scamming, But Make It Fashion: Anna Delvey Takes Things From Rich People

Scamming, But Make It Fashion: Anna Delvey Takes Things From Rich People

With her oversized black sunglasses, Supreme athleisure, and Rimowa suitcase, Anna Delvey (real name Anna Sorokin) posed a German heiress and scammed hoteliers, influencers, NYC elite, and the damn SWISS BANK in order to social climb in Manhattan.

Landing in 'Merica at the age of 28, Sorokin, the daughter of a former truck driver from Russia, migrated from Germany to the United States in 2014. After her arrival, she got a little creative with her backstory and recreated her entire identity, claiming to be a wealthy socialite,  and the daughter of an oil baron...or a diplomat, depending on who asked. She got in with the NYC elite socialite scene and scored even more investment and clout by pretending to raise money to startup her own artsy social club. Anna was kicked out of the NYC scene and thrown into Rikers when her lies finally caught up to her, and her inner circle began to discover that the German heiress was really a broke scammer with good fashion taste. Delvey is now serving 4-12 years in jail and will be deported after her release. Both Lena Dunham and Shonda Rimes are creating shows based on Delvey's hot girl summer. 

This week we talk about about Delvey's whirlwind summer, the trip that cost her everything (and by her, we mean her friend who was left with the bill) and her infamous courtroom looks. 

Cassandra's Overall Scam Score: 2 

Taylor's Overall Scam Score: 2.6

Anna Delvey content 

How Anna Delvey Tricked New York 

My Misadventure with The Magician of Manhattan

Anna Delvey Trial Looks 

Jun 10, 201901:07:06
The S In Theranos Stands For Scam
Apr 19, 201901:03:22
It Be Your Own Parents: The College Admission Scandal

It Be Your Own Parents: The College Admission Scandal

Applying to college is a laborious task. For most people it means sobbing while you re-write your common app essay 19 times or questioning if losing your sanity is worth your parent's ability to flex to their friends with where you're pursuing a fancy piece of paper. Unless you're one of the kids wrapped up in "Operation Varsity Blues", a scam in which wealthy parents paid their kids' way into colleges and then got caught. Talk about embarrassing. 

This week we talk about how beloved TV Moms/Aunts and a bunch of random CEOs made rookie moves in what is the largest college admission scam pursued by the DOJ. 

Cassandra's Overall Scam Score: 3.6

Taylor's Overall Scam Score: 3.3



Mar 15, 201901:09:37
Trailer: Scam City

Trailer: Scam City

Welcome to Scam City, a new podcast where two regular girls who love a good story about a conman (or con woman) break down the wildest scams and what led to its downfall. 


Join pop culture writers Cass Alcide and Taylor Davis every week for dissections, reflections, and deep dives into scams. 

Feb 20, 201900:49