Skip to main content
Spoopy Creppy

Spoopy Creppy

By Natalie DeYoung

Hear spoopy and creppy stories from Katie and Natalie. Two best friends with a passion for crimes, conspiracy theories, hauntings, and food (that doesn't have to do with anything, but we just both really like to eat).
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Overcast Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

20. Can I See Your Clown License, Please?

Spoopy CreppyJun 25, 2021

00:00
02:13:45
20. Can I See Your Clown License, Please?

20. Can I See Your Clown License, Please?

Katie and Natalie visit John Wayne Gacy's former house. On this special episode, Katie dives deep into the truth about the killer clown.
Jun 25, 202102:13:45
19. Sorry I Told Everyone You're a Prostitute

19. Sorry I Told Everyone You're a Prostitute

This week, Katie covers the tragic life of Sylvia Likens and Natalie discusses the strange case of Romell Broom.
Aug 05, 202002:25:00
18. Beard Pouch

18. Beard Pouch

This week we are covering the unusual, odd, unique, kinda funny in a morbid way, Final Destination style crazy deaths! Natalie shares about a lady who was killed by Taco Bell (but not in the way you think) and a man who was killed by Natalie and Katie's greatest fear. Katie shares multiple murders involving a beard pouch, a cactus, eating yourself to death, being too clean, and dying on the toilet.
Jul 22, 202001:55:60
17. Get Their Cum!

17. Get Their Cum!

This week we re-tell our favorite Forensic Files episodes! Katie shares about "Purebread Murder," the death of Christina Sanoubane. Natalie recounts "Shot of Vengeance," the arrest of Dr. Richard Schmidt.
Jul 15, 202001:44:00
16. Mmm... Smallpox

16. Mmm... Smallpox

This week we cover international serial killers. Natalie recounts the horrors of Tsutomu Miyazaki, the Otaku Murderer, and Katie dishes on the evil acts of Mary Ann Cotton.
Jul 08, 202001:42:15
15. Not F*cking Headlights

15. Not F*cking Headlights

This week's topic is not a murder. Katie recounts her experience with the mysterious Paulding lights and Natalie shares the story of a massive sports scandal, between Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding.
Jul 02, 202001:27:50
14. Essential Oil Peddlers

14. Essential Oil Peddlers

This week's theme is missing persons. Natalie shares the story of six-year-old Etan Patz, who became the first missing milk carton kid. Katie reveals the connection between the disappearances of Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos.
Jun 25, 202001:22:27
13. #BlackLivesMatter

13. #BlackLivesMatter

In a break from our usually funny and witty banter, we share with you two cases to represent the #BlackLivesMatter movement. Katie details the life and assassination of Medgar Evers and Natalie goes over the mysterious case of Kendrick Johnson's death.
Jun 17, 202001:56:05
12. I Know You're Trying to Shop for Eggplants, But Can I See Yours?

12. I Know You're Trying to Shop for Eggplants, But Can I See Yours?

In this Pride Month themed episode, Natalie tells the tragic tale of Brandon Teena, whose murder was the basis for the movie Boys Don't Cry. Katie recounts the details of the nasty Bayou Strangler.
Jun 10, 202001:48:31
11. The Most French Way to Die

11. The Most French Way to Die

This week's theme is nostalgic fast food and murderers who share a birthday with us (or almost do). Buckle up to hear Katie tell all about Andrei Romanovich Chikatilo, The Butcher of Rostov and Natalie covers the real life Bluebeard, aka Henri Desire Landru.
May 27, 202002:20:30
10. Dick Butts

10. Dick Butts

This random week, Natalie dishes about Dennis Nilsen, the British Jeffrey Dahmer, and Katie recounts the creppy tale of The Watcher. This episode is dedicated to all the Dick Butts out there!
May 21, 202001:59:23
9. A Little Murder Lullaby

9. A Little Murder Lullaby

This week's theme is ghosties! Katie recounts the haunting tale of the Bell Witch and Natalie shares about the Stanley Hotel.
May 13, 202001:38:43
8. Ectoplasm Cooler

8. Ectoplasm Cooler

Another episode with no theme! Natalie enchants us with the story of Helen Duncan, the last witch in Scotland and Katie recounts the disappearance and murder of Skylar Neese.
May 06, 202001:41:56
7. The Spankalicious Peach Fuzz Experience

7. The Spankalicious Peach Fuzz Experience

This week we are talking local. Katie covers the tragic death of Karen King in Saginaw, MI and Natalie details the Brown's Chicken Murders in Palatine, IL.
Apr 29, 202001:25:34
6. Do You Even Watch Crocodile Hunter?

6. Do You Even Watch Crocodile Hunter?

This week we tell each other short stories of spoopiness and creppiness. Natalie tells the tale of Blanche Monnier and Katie dives into the Hinterkaifeck murders.
Apr 22, 202052:24
5. Joust, Joust Motherf*cker

5. Joust, Joust Motherf*cker

In an episode with no theme, Katie starts with the story of Australian killer Katherine Knight, and Natalie dishes on her "Electric Love" for the story of Topsy the Elephant and Thomas Edison.
Apr 15, 202001:35:02
4. Did They Have Squirt Guns in 1893?

4. Did They Have Squirt Guns in 1893?

This week we go on lots of rants and talk about cryptids. Natalie reveals the story behind the Hodag of Rhinelander, Wisconsin, and shares our first hometown story from Rhinelander natives, Lindsay and Ryan Lieck. Katie explains the legend of the Wendigo and reads a spoopy story.
Apr 08, 202001:12:17
3. Chlamydia Recipe

3. Chlamydia Recipe

This week's episode theme is not a murder. Literally anything that's not a murder. Katie relays the story of the missing Sodder children and Natalie shares a collection of conspiracy theories about the Denver International Airport.
Apr 01, 202001:34:60
2. Spunky Bitch

2. Spunky Bitch

Our theme is: The Year You Were Born. Natalie covers 1994 serial killer, Gary Ray Bowles aka the I-95 Killer. Katie relays the tragedy of Shanda Sharer's 1992 murder.
Mar 25, 202001:35:41
1. Mining Lords and Mormons

1. Mining Lords and Mormons

In our first episode, Katie covers the Italian Hall Disaster of Calumet and Natalie discusses the murder of Brenda Wright Lafferty.
Mar 18, 202001:17:04