Skip to main content
Strange Like Me

Strange Like Me

By Strange Like Me

Three friends gather weekly to give a hilarious commentary on true crime, the paranormal, conspiracy theories, and all other strange activities.
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Overcast Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

35- The Titanic and the Missing Cohost

Strange Like MeApr 14, 2021

00:00
38:05
35- The Titanic and the Missing Cohost

35- The Titanic and the Missing Cohost

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Grab a cold one and settle in as we chat about an interesting theory regarding the sinking of the Titanic... or was it the Olympic? 

*insert dramatic yet intense music here* 

Apr 14, 202138:05
34- Underwater Archeology, Mushing, and the Lake Michigan Triangle

34- Underwater Archeology, Mushing, and the Lake Michigan Triangle

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Tune in as we chat virtually about some strange happenings around Lake Michigan. Grab a cold one, take a seat, and let's get strange! 

Mar 31, 202129:09
33 - Winter Storms and Parrot Crime Stoppers

33 - Winter Storms and Parrot Crime Stoppers

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! This week your favorite pack of weirdos gather to talk about an unsolved murder case, that is until, the world's most unlikely witness steps forward. Grab a drink and stay awhile!

Mar 17, 202131:15
32- Gourmet Pancakes and the Mineral Murders

32- Gourmet Pancakes and the Mineral Murders

Happy Wednesday, Strangers!

Welcome to the first episode of our new schedule! In case you missed our update last week, Strange Like Me episodes will be released on a bi-weekly schedule for the foreseeable future. We appreciate our incredible listeners and look forward to continuing to bring you the strangest of stories! 

Join us this week as we chat about the Mineral Murders and other unsolved Washington murders that seem to have an eery connection to Tacoma. 

Mar 03, 202132:54
SLM Update

SLM Update

Hey Strangers! Your favorite podcasters will be shifting to a bi-weekly upload schedule starting this week. Stay Strange, and we’ll see you next Wednesday!
Feb 25, 202100:41
31- Wine Charms, Cindy Paulson, and the Dirty Thirty-One

31- Wine Charms, Cindy Paulson, and the Dirty Thirty-One

Tune in for the courageous tale of Cindy Paulson.

Feb 17, 202139:57
30- Artists and Aliens

30- Artists and Aliens

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! With Valentine's day only a few days away, we want to take a moment to wish our lovely and loyal listeners a wonderful week of love! Whether it's loving another or loving yourself, we hope your day is filled with beauty and a moderate helping of weird activities. 

Join us as we explore a time when biblical and extra-terrestrial worlds collided whilst getting tipsy on random space facts and cosmopolitans. Settle in, grab your Valentine, and let's get strange. 

Feb 10, 202145:35
29- Snakes and The Cecil Hotel

29- Snakes and The Cecil Hotel

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Join us as we chat about Creighton's snake smuggling days and The Cecil Hotel, a Los Angeles hotel where strange things are bound to occur. Grab a drink, and let's get strange! 

Feb 03, 202153:06
28- Killer Clowns, 90's Technology, and the Moment of Truth

28- Killer Clowns, 90's Technology, and the Moment of Truth

Happy freakin' Wednesday, Strangers! We're coming at you this week with the case of Marlene Warren: a Florida wife and mother who was murdered in 1990 by a person dressed in clown attire. Join us as we chat about how terribly terrible clowns are, the wild technology that is VCR players, and attempt to outsmart the Mandala Effect with a special experiment. Settle in, grab a drink, and let's get strange! 

Jan 27, 202142:20
27- Boutique Garage, Strange Noises, and an Egyptian

27- Boutique Garage, Strange Noises, and an Egyptian

Alright, Strangers, you know the drill- it's Wednesday and we're getting strange. Join us as we try an IPA that definitely needs more grapefruit whilst chatting about the tale of Dorothy Eady and a boujee garage chandelier. 

Jan 20, 202153:04
26- Shazam, C-3PO, and Silence of the Lambs

26- Shazam, C-3PO, and Silence of the Lambs

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Join us as we collaborate on the theory that pisses us all off: the Mandela Effect. We're chatting about Sinbad's film Shazam, C-3PO's leg, and things Hannibal Lector may or may not have said in Silence of the Lambs. Grab your favorite adult beverage, settle in, and let's get strange. 

Also, if any of you have eyes on a VHS player, HMU. 

Jan 13, 202141:55
25- Mind Control, Reptile DNA, and Conspiracies

25- Mind Control, Reptile DNA, and Conspiracies

Happy New Year, Strangers! Let's all shotgun a beer and say a big 'ole thank you to the Lizard Gods that the dumpster fire that was 2020 is finally over! This week, your favorite weirdos are meeting over the inter-webs to deliver the bizarre circumstances of conspiracy theorist Max Spiers life and untimely death. Tune in as we talk mind control, Lizard Leaders, and the conspiracy theories that excite us the most. Stay Strange! 

Jan 06, 202157:47
24- Missing Marjorie West

24- Missing Marjorie West

Happy Wednesday, strangers! It is officially our last episode of 2020, and we want to thank you all for going on this wild ride with us. We started off as a quirky little podcast just five months ago and are going into the new year as an even quirkier podcast with the best friends, family, and fans in the whole wide world! Thank you for your support, and here's to 2021! 

This week, we are chatting about the mysterious disappearance of Marjorie West- you don't want to miss this virtual shitshow! Grab your favorite drink, settle in, and let's get strange! 

Dec 30, 202032:49
23- Eggnog Disaster and Robert the Doll

23- Eggnog Disaster and Robert the Doll

Happy Holidays, Strangers! This week we *tried* to drink spiked Eggnogg while chatting about the mysterious antics that seem to follow a doll named Robert. Untangle your tinsel by grabbing your favorite drink, kicking back, and relaxing to the sweet melodies of this week's strange tale! 

Dear Robert, we thank you for your time! 

Dec 23, 202030:30
22- Hot Toddies and Spontaneous Human Combustion

22- Hot Toddies and Spontaneous Human Combustion

It's Wednesday, so, therefore, we're getting strange. 

Join us as we get virtual and chat about a Christmas combustion while failing to make hot toddies- well, while host #3 fails to make hot toddies. Settle in, grab your favorite drink, and enjoy the debauchery of the strangest podcast in the galaxy. 

Dec 16, 202031:36
21- Stalker Update and the Bennington Triangle

21- Stalker Update and the Bennington Triangle

Happy Wednesday! Tune in as we talk about mysterious disappearances in the Bennington Triangle while drinking Don Ercilla's Cabernet Sauvignon.

Dec 09, 202042:50
20- A Creepy Home Renovation and Thanksgiving Updates

20- A Creepy Home Renovation and Thanksgiving Updates

Happy (late) Thanksgiving, Strangers! This year we are thankful for YOU! This podcast has been nothing less than a wild ride, and we love our Strange Like Me family, who has supported us every step of the way.

This week, we are chatting about the strange things that a couple of new homeowners found when renovating their basement while sipping on Kona Brewing's Big Wave Golden Ale. Tune in and saddle up as we chat about deep-frying turkeys, dinners over Zoom, and creepy hidden rooms.

Dec 02, 202036:58
19- Chelsea's Stalker and The Watcher

19- Chelsea's Stalker and The Watcher

Watchers and stalkers and bears- oh my! 

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! We're back to chat about The Watcher, a mysterious being who terrorized a New Jersey family, and a possible secret admirer who has been sending Chelsea backpacks. Grab a can of Icicle Brewing Company's Alpenhaze Hazy IPA, and let's get strange. 

Nov 25, 202001:03:37
18- Laphroaig and Death by Whisky

18- Laphroaig and Death by Whisky

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! This week we are chatting about a mysterious death by Whisky while sipping on 19 Crimes' Snoop Dogg Cali Red Blend. Tune in as we ask Creighton what he's wearing, learn about the tale of two Whisky makers, and discover how to not cook chicken via the Yellowstone geysers.

Stay Strange! 

Nov 18, 202040:22
17- Strange Ciders, Dreams, and A Phone Call

17- Strange Ciders, Dreams, and A Phone Call

What's up, Strangers?! Grab yourself a can of Independent Perry Company's Lavender Perry and tune in as we chat about the strange flyers, creepy calls, and the people who may want to steal your dreams. Lock your windows and get out your sage because we're about to get strange! 

Nov 11, 202043:13
16- Sweet Sixteen, MTV Shows, and the Bloody Benders

16- Sweet Sixteen, MTV Shows, and the Bloody Benders

Greetings, Strangers! It's Wednesday, which means it's time to for y'all to come get strange with us. This week we are sipping on Dru Bru's Hop Session IPA and diving in to the terrifying tale that is the Bloody Benders. Grab your water wings, and let's get weird.
Nov 04, 202039:05
15.5- A Strange Like Me Halloween

15.5- A Strange Like Me Halloween

Happy Halloween, Strangers! We skipped the tricks this year and brought you a special treat: A Strange Like Me Halloween! Join us as we chat about poisoned candy, a Halloween disappearance, and decorations that look a little too human. Grab yourself a hardy glass of Jones of Washington 2014 Sangiovese, dust off the 'ole ouija board, and let's get strange. 

Oct 31, 202048:56
15- Mushroom DNA, Oakville Blobs, and Jellyfish

15- Mushroom DNA, Oakville Blobs, and Jellyfish

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Grab a glass of Fossil Point Cabernet Sauvignon and tune in as we sit down to chat about the strange blobs that once rained down on a Washington city. 

Oct 28, 202034:43
14- A Disappearing Father, Smelly Barn, and Jersey Shore

14- A Disappearing Father, Smelly Barn, and Jersey Shore

Hello, Strangers! It's Wednesday, and at Strange Like Me, that means it's time to gym, tan, and talk about murders. Tune in as we go over the strange disappearance and death of a new father while drinking Riverbend Brewing's Life's a Peach and Then You Die Peach Milkshake IPA.

Oct 21, 202042:27
13- Scrunchies, Pumpkin Spice, and Pigman

13- Scrunchies, Pumpkin Spice, and Pigman

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Your favorite weirdos are back and stranger than ever this week as we chat about the legend of Pigman while sipping on Elysian's Pumpkin Ale. Tune in and listen closely as we tell you how to avoid your hometown monsters (spoiler alert: it may include sombreros and not wearing them in a goofy fashion). 

Oct 14, 202045:05
12- Beer Review, an Avalanche, and Reality Shows

12- Beer Review, an Avalanche, and Reality Shows

Happy Wednesday, Strangers! Grab a can of Golden Road Brewing's Mango Cart and pull up a chair as we chat about the Dyatlov Pass Incident. Join us as we discuss missing climbers, strange deaths, and the end of the Kardashian era. 

Oct 07, 202045:41
11- Friends, Torture, and The Blood Countess

11- Friends, Torture, and The Blood Countess

What's up, Strangers? We're back and better than ever, drinking a 2018 Cabernet Sauvignon by 19 Crimes. Join us as we chat about the Countess Bathory, her strange beauty practices, and Friends (the TV show, of course). 

Sep 30, 202032:57
10- A Deadly Smiley Face and Hockey

10- A Deadly Smiley Face and Hockey

Hey Strangers! This week we're chatting about the Smiley Face Killer Conspiracy while sipping on New Belgium Voodoo Ranger American Haze. Saddle up as we take you through the wild theories of two retired police detectives and their professor sidekick. 

Sep 23, 202056:55
9- A Bloody Battle, Ghost Hospital, and OnlyFans

9- A Bloody Battle, Ghost Hospital, and OnlyFans

Hey Strangers! This week the gang is going back in time to discuss one of the bloodiest battles in U.S. History. Grab a glass of Boomtown by Dusted Valley and settle in with us as we chat about the ghosts that still haunt a Tennesse mansion.

Sep 16, 202043:30
8- A Lighthouse, Evil Spirits, and Sheep Snatching Pterodactyls

8- A Lighthouse, Evil Spirits, and Sheep Snatching Pterodactyls

Ahoy, Strangers! We're back and better than ever, talking about a spirit infested island off the shores of Scotland. Tune in and sip some Pyramid Apricot Ale as we take a deep dive into the mysterious disappearances of lighthouse attendants and some sheep. 

Sep 09, 202040:44
7- Witches, A Sacrifice, and Homemade Halloween Candy

7- Witches, A Sacrifice, and Homemade Halloween Candy

Hey Strangers! Your favorite podcasters are back at it, chatting about black magic, Halloween myths, and fleshy forearms. Join us as we chat about a strange occurrence in New Jersey while sipping on a lovely Pinot Noir from Ancestry Cellars in Chelan, Washington. 

Sep 02, 202028:54
6- A Field, Two Murders, and Tiny Tacos

6- A Field, Two Murders, and Tiny Tacos

Hey Strangers! Kick-off your loafers and grab a drink as we walk you through the tale of the Erdington Murders. This week the gang talks about eerie similarities, mishaps at Jack in the Box, and the way to our hearts (spoiler alert: it's tiny tacos). 

This week we're drinking Kendall-Jackson's Chardonnay.  

Aug 26, 202039:41
5- Sibling Fights, Slender Man, and an Attempted Murder

5- Sibling Fights, Slender Man, and an Attempted Murder

Hey Strangers! Your favorite weirdos are back to chat about the Slender Man phenomenon and a slumber party that turned dark. Tune in to hear us chat about teenage antics and all the ways that we've almost killed our siblings. 

This week we are sipping Skyfall Vinyard's Cabernet Sauvignon. 

Aug 19, 202031:41
4- Airplanes, Games, and A Guy Named Steve

4- Airplanes, Games, and A Guy Named Steve

This week we're discussing the strange disappearance of Pilot Frederick Valentich and a possible UFO abduction. Tune in to find out why you shouldn't play chicken in an airplane. 

This week we're drinking Eleven Winery's delicious Cabernet Sauvignon. 

Aug 12, 202034:26
3- Ghost Babies and a Haunted Amusement Park

3- Ghost Babies and a Haunted Amusement Park

We're back with the chilling tale of the Lake Shawnee Amusement Park and its hauntings. Join us as we chat about haunted land, pink party dresses, and ghost babies. 

This week we're drinking Sonoma County Decoy Sauvignon Blanc.

Aug 05, 202041:09
2- A Cow, a Sheriff, and UFO Sightings

2- A Cow, a Sheriff, and UFO Sightings

This week the gang is back to chat about Montana UFO's and their love for beef. A sheriff tries to track the flying culprits down, discovering strange things along the way. 

Jul 29, 202031:44
1- Randonautica, TikTok, and a Suitcase

1- Randonautica, TikTok, and a Suitcase

This week we cover a grisly discovery that Washington teens made while using the popular app, Randonautica. 

Jul 22, 202027:44