Skip to main content
So Psych-illogical: a Psych Rewatch Podcast

So Psych-illogical: a Psych Rewatch Podcast

By susieandlizzie

Two friends investigate the world of Psych episode by episode, delving into the personal development and interpersonal relationships of the characters we all love, along with other interesting facts, tidbits and randomness. It's a joyride of analysis!
New content every Monday.

Join us on the socials:
Twitter: @susieandlizzie
Instagram: So_Psychillogical
Facebook: So Psychillogical

We'd love to hear from you!
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

S1, E13 Aftercast: Falling Through the Ice

So Psych-illogical: a Psych Rewatch PodcastMay 18, 2022

00:00
27:31
S1, E13 Aftercast: Falling Through the Ice

S1, E13 Aftercast: Falling Through the Ice

In this aftercast episode, Susie and Lizzie try to help prevent all of our ending scene lines from falling flat like Gus's did, by offering up a list of all-purpose conclusions for your edification.  Then it's all about the ice... we're talking diamonds, real and fake, with a slight detour through the arctic and antarctic regions.  We ponder the mistakes of the criminal's camera work enough to investigate the series' camera work with some continuity errors before trust falling into our own work retreat experiences. 

May 18, 202227:31
S1, E13: Game, Set... Muuurder?

S1, E13: Game, Set... Muuurder?

This week, Susie and Lizzie put their own topspin on this episode of Psych. They'll serve up a conversation about an interesting trio of frustration that bounces onto the court and find an advantage in Shawn's relationships with Juliet and Gus.  They also double fault with surprising fun facts about Gus's grandma and Shawns' diamond knowledge. To complete the set, they'll comment on moments and add their favorite quotes as usual. 

May 09, 202239:24
S1, E12 Aftercast : What's in a Name?

S1, E12 Aftercast : What's in a Name?

In this aftercast, Susie and Lizzie briefly share their own thoughts on the kidney stone issue. Then it's down the roster for an occupational roll call of sorts, for themselves and for everyone's favorite psychic detective duo. Finally, they take a moment to appreciate those hidden talents, accumulated knowledge, or whatever is hidden in one's back pocket ready to be instrumental in saving the day.
May 03, 202223:16
S1, E12: CLoudy... With a chance of Murder

S1, E12: CLoudy... With a chance of Murder

This week Susie and Lizzie deliberate over this double themed episode of Psych.  We witness the development of support systems, established and new.  We also present a case for the nature of our leads' skillsets as their talents are on display.  We get caught in a whirlwind of weatherman names, spy on the real Michael Weston, and have a bit of fun wither further examination of moments and citations of quotations.

Apr 26, 202253:48
S1, E11 Aftercast: Come hungry, leave happily rested.

S1, E11 Aftercast: Come hungry, leave happily rested.

In this aftercast episode, Susie and Lizzie, like Shawn, focus on their tots a little too much.  They follow through in great Henry stye though, with stories about grilling and personal thoughts and tips on self care.  Lest ye leave hangry, the ladies give a final offering of a potential recipe for Blarney Stone Fajitas.

Apr 18, 202227:16
S1, E11: He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not, He Loves Me, Oops He's Dead!

S1, E11: He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not, He Loves Me, Oops He's Dead!

This week, Susie and Lizzie use the gift of the gab as they discuss this episode. They charm their way through the many dates of our favorite Psych and SBPD detectives, learn all about how speed dating began, and separate blarney from baloney regarding St. Patrick. They also chat about the new-to-Shawn version of Henry we are discovering and the difficulty of recognizing how parents grow as people outside of their parenthood. Shanhooligans, as Susie likes to say, are bound to happen along the way, with fun tidbits and of course favorites quotes.
Apr 12, 202255:43
S1: E10 Aftercast Engines on in T minus 27 minutes.

S1: E10 Aftercast Engines on in T minus 27 minutes.

In this aftercast, Susie and Lizzie discuss Space Camp, the movie and the camp and Lizzie issues a fun challenge to our listeners.  

Apr 07, 202227:20
S1, E10 From the Earth to the Starbucks

S1, E10 From the Earth to the Starbucks

In this Episode, Susie and Lizzie explore more of Shawn and Gus's working relationship.  We tell you what we've heard about Pluto and how much we loved the Psych team rallying around Carlton!  Lizzie dived into the pop culture references and even leaves a few of her own. 

Mar 29, 202258:07
S1 E10 Aftercast You can't buffalo a buffalo from Buffalo

S1 E10 Aftercast You can't buffalo a buffalo from Buffalo

In this episode, Susie and Lizzie discuss wild animal encounters, the importance of paraphrasing and trustworthiness of our own memories.

Mar 21, 202235:48
S1, E9: Forget Me Not

S1, E9: Forget Me Not

This week, Susie and Lizzie engage in a discussion of trust as we remember the events of Forget Me Not. We take note of Henry's and Capt. Conner's different parenting styles. We then get a little more psych-illogical as we break down various trust break downs in the episode. We also recall the various and ever changing states of maturity of our beloved characters. We'll pull from the language bank part of our brains as we revisit the iconic clicking scene, as well as taking a look back at this episode's guest stars as they've crossed paths before. Rambling antics and non-sense/ery ensue as expected.
Mar 14, 202201:03:44
S1,E8 Aftercast: With great enthusiasm comes mediocre pop culture knowledge

S1,E8 Aftercast: With great enthusiasm comes mediocre pop culture knowledge

In this aftercast, we discuss Lizzie getting conned, before attempting to discover our own superhero identities.   We dare to add our own commentary to some of the most notable Super Hero roles.  You may also have the opportunity to hear the pitter patter of little feet in the background.

Feb 28, 202232:55
S1,E8: Shawn vs. the Red Phantom

S1,E8: Shawn vs. the Red Phantom

This week, Susie and Lizzie suit up for their own panel discussion of Shawn vs. the Red Phantom. We’ll unmask secret identities, reveal flirty Shules undercurrents, and take a look at the changing dynamics between Carlton and Chief Vick. We’ll throw in a brief detour to Comic Con and be sure to wham, bap, and pow you with some references from the episode. As usual, we’ve prepped our speech bubbles with our favorite quotes and padded the strips with plenty of banter.
Feb 22, 202201:01:51
So Psych-illogical is back in the studio

So Psych-illogical is back in the studio

Just a quick update to let you know where we are in completing the episodes for Psych Pseason 1.

Feb 15, 202206:56
Midseason Update and This is Gus Trailer Reaction

Midseason Update and This is Gus Trailer Reaction

This week, we give a brief update for So Psych-illogical's analysis through Season One of Psych, as well as our reactions to the trailer for the imminent movie Psych 3: This is Gus.  We look forward to adding your input into episodes for the back half of the season, so contact us at susieandlizzie@gmail.com

Nov 08, 202108:07
S1, E7 Aftercast: We'll have to call you back

S1, E7 Aftercast: We'll have to call you back

In this aftercast episode, we communicate our new found appreciation for this episode of Psych.  We also inform each other about various revelations from recent episodes, Susie shares her experience with Jaws, and we bust out the details behind one of the hottest videos of the 80's because we ain't afraid of no ghosts.

Nov 01, 202126:05
S1, E7: Who Ya Gonna Call?

S1, E7: Who Ya Gonna Call?

This week, we give up the ghost and haunt the talk instead.  We take note of all the ways our lads do and don't communicate, we get a little emotional with Lassie, and we watch as Gus asserts himself in the agency.  Of course you can expect the usual repartee, along with some fun references, a little six degrees of Psych, and favourite quotes.  

Oct 25, 202101:07:56
S1, E6 Aftercast: "Whatever you are, be a good one" --Lincoln

S1, E6 Aftercast: "Whatever you are, be a good one" --Lincoln

In this aftercast episode, Susie and Lizzie discuss their personal rocket launching stories, civil war reenactment stories, and touring Washington, DC stories.  We also attempt to decide who would play us in a Susie and Lizzie version of "Psych".  

Oct 18, 202132:18
S1,E6: Weekend Warriors

S1,E6: Weekend Warriors

This week, we have a civil discussion about all things Weekend Warriors.  In this sixth episode of Psych, the So-Psych-Illogical gals break down the sublter things between the skirmishes; Shawn and Henry, why Juliet seems to come to the rescue so often and all the little things that make this episode so deliciously rewatchable. Of course, you can expect edifying fun facts, witty repartee and our favorite quotes thrown onto the field.  

Oct 11, 202101:04:32
S1, E5 Aftercast: Can we always land on our feet?

S1, E5 Aftercast: Can we always land on our feet?

In this episode, we discuss various cat myths and use some So Psych-illogical thinking to "prove" some our favorites true!  The origins of why cats have 9 lives is left a mystery.  We also consider the importance of reaching out to a friend or counselor, when help is needed.  Unlike cats, humans don't have a righting reflex, so we often need help to land on our feet.  

Oct 04, 202134:22
S1, E5: 9 Lives

S1, E5: 9 Lives

This week, we land on our feet as Shawn and Gus's working partnership settles onto firm ground.  We discuss this process as well as the third associate in the case, with whom Gus goes toe to toe bean, Little Boy Cat.  Another key support role is more intensely discussed as we begin to truly understand how valuable Buzz McNab is to the Psych team.  Fan favourite fun facts and references are thrown in along with conversational hijinks as usual.

Sep 27, 202101:05:22
S1, Ep 4 Aftercast: What's with all the Stanchions?

S1, Ep 4 Aftercast: What's with all the Stanchions?

In this aftercast, we discuss the police codes from this fourth Psych episode,  (which causes Susie to think doing voices is a good idea....) legal techinicalities and try to decide our official "stanchion" on an unrevolved plot point.  Crimes will be revealed and hearts will be broken (or maybe just Lizzie's!) 

Sep 20, 202129:53
S1, E4: Woman Seeking Dead Husband: Smokers Okay, No Pets

S1, E4: Woman Seeking Dead Husband: Smokers Okay, No Pets

This week, we stakeout the fourth episode of the season and take a closer look at Gus's strange fancies when it comes to the ladies.  We also examine the partner relationship being established between Lassie and Jules, and take note of Shawn's ease at befriending criminals. As usual we throw in some Psych fun facts, our own special blend of banter, and favourite quotes.

Sep 18, 202151:08
S1, Ep 3 Aftercast: Ya Dig It?

S1, Ep 3 Aftercast: Ya Dig It?

In this aftercast episode, we discuss the origins of hide and Go seek, possible solutions for finding diamonds rather than the thievery and murder seen in the third episode of season one Psych, and you can hear Lizzie's "fake American accent". 

Sep 06, 202132:24
S1, E3: Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Piece

S1, E3: Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Piece

This week, we join the wedding party in this season's third episode of Psych.  After a brief summary, we take a look at a certain Head Detective, lay out some of what Gus's special skills, and challenge Shawn's confidence with the ladies.  Of course, there's plenty of other fun along the way as we meet other recurring guests, reference references, and give some favourite quotes as usual.  

Aug 31, 202138:49
S1, E2 Aftercast: Word Nerds

S1, E2 Aftercast: Word Nerds

In this Psych influenced aftercast, we go full on Gus, talking more about the Bee and sharing personal spelling stories.  We also discuss observations on the changing nature of words, with some specific original meanings that will surprise you!

Aug 23, 202137:27
S1, E2: The Spellingg Bee

S1, E2: The Spellingg Bee

This week, we take a look at the iconic second episode of Psych, season 1.  After a brief summary, we dive deep with a new character introduction, some stretching comfort zones, and an unexpected character - the bee itself.  Fun facts, quirky commentary, and favourite quotes along the way as usual.  

Aug 16, 202145:33
S1, E1 Aftercast: It's Aphantastic!

S1, E1 Aftercast: It's Aphantastic!

Our Aftercast is a bonus, less formal companion episode, where we get more personal! This week we discuss aphantasia having been inspired by both the visualising of clues we se Shawn do on Psych and a recent conversation about a research study.  We also ponder the question of lying honestly, that is, telling people you are lying.

Aug 09, 202128:20
S1, E1: The Pilot Episode

S1, E1: The Pilot Episode

In this first podcast, join us as we briefly summarise the events and then discuss the characters introduced in the pilot episode of Psych....Fun facts and antics interspersed along the way.   

Aug 09, 202142:57