Way Too Early Oscar Podcast

Way Too Early Oscar Podcast

By Way Too Early Oscar Podcast

Hosts Marisa Carpico and Matt Taylor discuss the current Oscar race from the surprises and snubs to the unrewarded gems.
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

2025 Tony Awards Reaction

Way Too Early Oscar PodcastJun 09, 2025
00:00
24:38
2025 Tony Awards Reaction

2025 Tony Awards Reaction

Matt and Marisa continue their "pilot program" of turning this into an EGOT podcast with their reactions to this year's Tony Awards. In the episode, they discuss their favorite speech of the night, the constant sound issues and completely forget to mention the incredible Hamilton 10th anniversary performance.

Jun 09, 202524:38
The 2025 TONY (!) Award Nominations

The 2025 TONY (!) Award Nominations

Marisa and Matt pivot into a whole new awards season: The 2025 Tony Awards! The duo talk about all the buzzy shows this season like Oh Mary!, Maybe Happy Ending, and the controversial Othello revival. Find out what show this season is one of the worst they've ever seen. And which Broadway star inspired them to take the show in a new direction?

May 23, 202501:10:04
The 2025 Academy Awards Reaction Episode!

The 2025 Academy Awards Reaction Episode!

Well, that's all folks... Matt and Marisa are joined by Alex Marcus to talk about the 2025 Academy Awards! Were they charmed by Conan? Were they surprised by the Anora sweep? What did they think of Timmy's yellow suit? Find out!

Mar 03, 202534:51
2025 Oscars: Best Sound

2025 Oscars: Best Sound

Surprise! Matt and Marisa are back because they forgot to do a category: Best Sound. In the episode, they discuss why Wicked is superior to other recent live-sung musicals and marvel at the work it must take to create all the sound from scratch in something like The Wild Robot.

Feb 28, 202520:24
2025 Oscars: Best Director and Best Picture

2025 Oscars: Best Director and Best Picture

Matt and Marisa wrap up their individual category breakdowns with two of the biggest. In the episode, they discuss how The Brutalist and Emilia Pérez went from front runners to also-rans, how Sean Baker's recognition feels like it's been a long time coming and once again encourage you to see The Count of Monte Cristo.

Feb 28, 202501:05:45
2025 Oscars: Best Supporting and Lead Actresses

2025 Oscars: Best Supporting and Lead Actresses

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with their favorite categories: Actresses. In the episode, Marisa confesses to being a longtime Ariana Grande fan, Matt speaks for both of them on how great Isabella Rossellini and they talk about how exciting the Lead race is.

Feb 27, 202501:09:25
2025 Oscars: Best Supporting and Lead Actors

2025 Oscars: Best Supporting and Lead Actors

Matt and Marisa tackle their first set of major categories with the boys. In the episode, they wonder how a Sing Sing actor failed to make the list, discuss Succession brain and disagree on the Timothée of it all.

Feb 27, 202544:04
2025 Oscars: Best Production Design and Best Visual Effects

2025 Oscars: Best Production Design and Best Visual Effects

Matt and Marisa finish off the technical categories. In the episode, the marvel at the visual in Dune: Part Two,and talk about their love for two ape-centric movies.

Feb 26, 202531:37
2025 Oscars: Best Cinematography and Best Editing

2025 Oscars: Best Cinematography and Best Editing

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with Cinematography and Editing. In the episode, they discuss whether The Brutalist was the visual marvel it promised to be, highlight the subtle comedy of Conclave and Marisa continues her hate campaign against Nosferatu.

Feb 25, 202548:20
2025 Oscars: Adapted and Original Screenplays

2025 Oscars: Adapted and Original Screenplays

Matt and Marisa continue their individual category breakdowns with the writing nominations. In the episode, they discuss how cool The Substance is, marvel that September 5 didn't get more nominations and once again bring up The Count of Monte Cristo.

Feb 24, 202501:08:53
2025 Oscars: Best Original Score and Best Original Song

2025 Oscars: Best Original Score and Best Original Song

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with the music categories. In the episode, Matt wonders how Wicked's score earned a nomination but Dune 2 didn't, Marisa names some wild alternate nominees for Song and they both lament a major snub for Score.

Feb 22, 202542:14
2025 Oscars: Best Makeup and Hairstyling and Best Costume Design

2025 Oscars: Best Makeup and Hairstyling and Best Costume Design

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with more technical categories. In the episode, Marisa begrudgingly compliments Nosferatu, Matt jokes about dressing his bridesmaids as the Bene Gesserit from Dune and they both wonder what Gladiator II is doing anywhere near the Oscars.

Feb 21, 202549:35
2025 Oscars: Animated Film, International Film, and Documentary Feature Film

2025 Oscars: Animated Film, International Film, and Documentary Feature Film

Marisa and Matt break down three more 2024 Oscar categories: Best International Film, Best Animated Film, and Best Original Score.

Feb 19, 202501:10:57
2025 Oscars: The Shorts Categories

2025 Oscars: The Shorts Categories

Matt and Marisa launch their annual breakdown of all the Oscar nominees with the Live Action, Documentary and Animated Short Film categories. Thanks again to ShortsTV for providing us with viewing links for all the films. The showcases hit theaters 2/14.

Feb 12, 202553:52
The 2024 Golden Globes Wins, SAG and DGA Nominations

The 2024 Golden Globes Wins, SAG and DGA Nominations

In this episode, Matt and Marisa reflect on this year's Golden Globes (Demi is running! They ate pasta and gossiped while watching together!). They also react to the SAG and DGA nominations and the current status of the big six Oscar races. Tangents include: Marisa's dad's love for Maria, our enthusiasm for The Fall Guy, and the random Amazon Prime Original Series that Matt's fiancé loves.

Jan 08, 202538:35
Golden Globes Nomination Thoughts

Golden Globes Nomination Thoughts

Marisa and Matt sound off on the silliest award show: the Golden Globes, which just announced their nominations this week. Tune in to hear them debate what counts as a "comedy" these days, try to predict whether The Substance is a serious Oscar contender, and speculate on whether or not an icon of 1970s cinema will make an appearance on the red carpet (which icon? the answer will surprise you).

Dec 12, 202436:07
New York Film Festival w/ Tom Moore

New York Film Festival w/ Tom Moore

Marisa and Matt are joined by Tom Moore to discuss some of the highlights from this year's New York Film Festival including Anora, Emilia Perez, Queer, Maria, and The Brutalist.

Oct 15, 202453:40
2024 TIFF Recap w/ Sean Cordy

2024 TIFF Recap w/ Sean Cordy

Staff writer Sean Cordy joins co-host Marisa Carpico to talk TIFF. In the episode, we discuss the films he saw and reviewed, the overall experience and how the festival shifted the Oscar conversation.

Oct 12, 202454:18
2024 Venice Film Festival w/ Sam Niles

2024 Venice Film Festival w/ Sam Niles

In the kick off to our season, PopBreak podcaster and writer Sam Niles joins Marisa to recap his second year at the Venice Film Festival. He gives a rundown of all the films he saw as well as an overview of what it's like to attend the Fest.

Oct 02, 202401:04:10
2024 Oscars Post-Ceremony

2024 Oscars Post-Ceremony

Matt and Marisa are joined by the winners of The Pop Break's annual Oscar pool, Kat Manos and Chris Diggins to chat surprises, highs, lows and Kimmel's hosting performance.

Mar 11, 202430:17
2024 Oscars: Best Animated Feature, Directing and Picture

2024 Oscars: Best Animated Feature, Directing and Picture

Matt and Marisa wrap up their annual category breakdowns with their weirdest grouping yet: Animated Feature, Directing and Picture. In the episode, they discuss the movie that had them recording down to the wire, Christopher Nolan's momentum and whether anything can beat Oppenheimer at this point.

Mar 10, 202422:02
2024 Oscars: The Acting Categories

2024 Oscars: The Acting Categories

Matt and Marisa start to wrap up their category breakdowns with some of the favorites each year, Best Lead and Supporting Acting. On the Actress side, they discuss the dead heat between Emma Stone in Poor Things and Lily Gladstone in Killers of the Flower Moon. For the Actors, they wonder if Paul Giamatti in The Holdovers might pull a win out from under Cillian Murphy in Oppenheimer.

Mar 09, 202429:08
2024 Oscars: The Shorts Categories

2024 Oscars: The Shorts Categories

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with one of their perennial favorite episodes of the season, the Animated, Live Action and Documentary shorts.

Mar 08, 202438:27
2024 Oscars: Best Documentary Feature and International Feature

2024 Oscars: Best Documentary Feature and International Feature

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with some of the harder films to watch this year, Documentary and International Feature. In the episode, they rave about seeing Perfect Days together at NYFF and Marisa tries to hide her bias in the Doc category.

Mar 07, 202426:48
2024 Oscars: Best Cinematography, Sound Effects and Makeup and Hairstyling

2024 Oscars: Best Cinematography, Sound Effects and Makeup and Hairstyling

Matt and Marisa return for another supersized episode with 3 technical categories: Cinematography, Sound Effects and Makeup and Hairstyling.

Mar 07, 202430:10
2024 Oscars: Best Editing, Production Design and Costuming

2024 Oscars: Best Editing, Production Design and Costuming

Matt and Marisa deliver another supersized and super rushed episode of their category breakdowns for this year's Oscar nominees. This time, they rave about the costumes and sets in Barbie and Poor Things, talk editing and wonder why Napoleon keeps popping up.

Mar 04, 202417:25
2024 Oscars: Adapted and Original Screenplays, Score and Original Song

2024 Oscars: Adapted and Original Screenplays, Score and Original Song

Matt and Marisa kick of this year's category breakdowns with a supersized episode. They cover both Screenplay categories, both Adapted and Original, Best Score and the category that haunts them every year, Best Original Song.

Mar 03, 202423:24
SAG 2024 Reactions

SAG 2024 Reactions

Matt and Marisa record live and in-person mere minutes after this year's SAG Awards to talk high, lows and Anne Hathaway crying during Barbra Streisand's speech.

Feb 27, 202416:52
2024 Oscar Nominations

2024 Oscar Nominations

Matt and Marisa give their initial reactions to this year's Oscar nominations, the surprises, the snubs and all the rest. In the episode, they lament the few nominees they still have to watch, celebrate the love for Maestro and note that there's still a way for an ex-Riverdale actor to win an Oscar this year.

Jan 24, 202426:16
2024 SAG Nominations

2024 SAG Nominations

Matt and Marisa finally kick off Awards Season with an in-depth analysis of the SAG Nominations for the film categories. In the episode, they defend Maestro, begin to analyze the cultural touchstone that was Barbenheimer and wonder what the hell happened with Ferrari.

Jan 15, 202436:14
2023 Oscars Post-Show

2023 Oscars Post-Show

Matt and Marisa are joined by winner of ThePopBreak.com's Oscar pool aka the site's Editor in Chief, Bill Bodkin, to break down the highs and lows of last night's Academy Awards.

Mar 13, 202344:38
2023 Oscars: Best Picture

2023 Oscars: Best Picture

Happy Oscar Sunday! We’re breaking down the 10 nominees for Best Picture.
Mar 12, 202354:53
2023 Oscars: Best Director

2023 Oscars: Best Director

A breakdown of the 2022 Best Director category.
Mar 12, 202325:40
2023 Oscars: Lead and Supporting Actors

2023 Oscars: Lead and Supporting Actors

Matt and Marisa return to talk about the boys. In Lead, they worry about the Brendan Fraser situation to the point that Marisa does a heel turn on Austin Butler. In Supporting, they surprise each other with their takes on the boys from The Banshees of Inisherin and wonder if anyone could possibly beat Ke Huy Quan.

Mar 10, 202350:10
2023 Oscars: Lead and Supporting Actresses

2023 Oscars: Lead and Supporting Actresses

Matt and Marisa return to talk about their favorite categories of every year: the actresses. In the Supporting category, they discuss the rapidly changing narrative for predicting who will win and list some of their favorite performances of the year in their alternates. In the Lead category, they break down the Andrea Riseborough controversy and pray for a Michelle Yeoh win.

Mar 09, 202301:03:36
2023 Oscars: Original and Adapted Screenplays

2023 Oscars: Original and Adapted Screenplays

Matt and Marisa tackle their last set of the non-major categories: Best Original and Adapted Screenplays. In the Adapted category, they relish the chance to praise Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery, hype up Top Gun: Maverick once again and put their weight behind Sarah Polley's work with Women Talking. In the Original category, they use The Fabelmans to once again worship last year's West Side Story, Marisa argues Tár's epilogue ruins the whole movie and Matt suggests The Banshees of Inisherin is Martin McDonagh's best work.

Mar 08, 202344:01
2023 Oscars: Best Score and Song

2023 Oscars: Best Score and Song

Our breakdowns of this year's categories continue with a double feature of some of our most unhinged categories: Score and Song. We complain (again) about All Quiet on the Western Front's many nominations, dissect the Diane Warren of it all and Marisa teases the dark evil that is her Spotify Wrapped.

Mar 07, 202345:23
2023 Oscars: International Feature

2023 Oscars: International Feature

Today's second episode focuses on a category we struggled to see before the ceremony: International Feature. Matt and Marisa once again complain about All Quiet on the Western Front, discuss the shocking twist of Close and Marisa goes to bat for The Quiet Girl.

Mar 06, 202322:12
2023 Oscars: Documentary Feature

2023 Oscars: Documentary Feature

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with Documentary Feature. In the episode, they talk about being devastated by A House Made of Splinters, marvel at the footage in Navalny and offer up another movie that could have earned a nomination.

Mar 06, 202330:49
2023 Oscars: Cinematography and Editing

2023 Oscars: Cinematography and Editing

Matt and Marisa return to discuss some of the bigger technicals: cinematography and editing. They discuss their surprise over Bardo and ponder what Empire of Light is doing here.

Mar 06, 202342:12
2023 Oscars: Costuming and Makeup and Hairstyling

2023 Oscars: Costuming and Makeup and Hairstyling

Matt and Marisa return to talk two more technicals. In Costuming, they delight over Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris and marvel at Ruth Carter’s fashion forward work in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. In Makeup and Hairstyling, they lament the battle of the fat suits.
Mar 05, 202340:10
Oscars 2023: The Shorts
Mar 03, 202301:04:24
2023 Oscars: Best Animated Feature

2023 Oscars: Best Animated Feature

Matt and Marisa continue their category breakdowns with this year's nominees for Animated Feature. In the episode, they lament having to watch yet another Pinocchio adaptation, praise the sweetness of Marcel the Shell with Shoes On and wonder if The Sea Beast was created by an AI.

Mar 02, 202321:56
2023 Oscars: Production Design

2023 Oscars: Production Design

Matt and Marisa continue their category with another technical: Best Production Design. They discuss Babylon's hedonism, Elvis's maximalism and Marisa fixates on the proverbial clay pots of Avatar: The Way of Water.

Mar 02, 202328:42
2023 Oscars: Best Sound and Visual Effects

2023 Oscars: Best Sound and Visual Effects

Matt and Marisa kick off their annual tradition of breaking down every category with a technical category double header. They ponder over All Quiet on the Western Front's multiple nominations, gush over Top Gun: Maverick and once again express their love for The Batman.

Mar 01, 202329:58
2023 Oscar Nominations Reaction

2023 Oscar Nominations Reaction

Matt and Marisa try to process this year's Oscar surprises and snubs. From Andrea Riseborough's lightning fast campaign to the love for everything from RRR to Top Gun: Maverick.

Jan 24, 202335:00
The Return of the Golden Globes, SAG Nominations and More

The Return of the Golden Globes, SAG Nominations and More

Matt and Marisa discuss the baffling resurrection of the Golden Globes, what the SAG nominations may mean for the Oscars and catch up on the last few awards contenders of 2022.

Jan 18, 202301:09:43
2022 Oscar Season Opener

2022 Oscar Season Opener

Matt and Marisa finally return to recap this year's Oscar hopefuls, from the staying power of Everything Everywhere All at Once to Tár's last act problems.

Dec 20, 202201:21:06
2022 Oscars Post-Show

2022 Oscars Post-Show

Matt and Marisa are joined by the winners of ThePopBreak's annual Oscars pool, Tommy Tracy and DJ Chapman (host of our podcast on all things Bachelor Nation, Roses and Rejections), to talk about this year's chaotic telecast. In the episode, they discuss the Chris Rock/Will Smith situation, CODA's Best Picture win and the moments from the ceremony that made them smile and cringe.

Mar 28, 202239:31
2022 Oscar Category Breakdown: Best Picture

2022 Oscar Category Breakdown: Best Picture

Matt and Marisa conclude their annual breakdown of all the Oscar nominees with the most important category of all: Best Picture. Listen as they ridicule Don't Look Up one last time, disagree on The Power of the Dog and rave about Spielberg's West Side Story.
Mar 27, 202201:04:14