Skip to main content
We’ve Made a Mistake

We’ve Made a Mistake

By Cathy and Sara

We’ve Made a Mistake is a weekly podcast in which hosts, Cathy and Sara, explore their past experiences on a range of topics in a way that humorously highlights their vulnerabilities. They drink a lot of cheap wine too. New episodes every Tuesday!
Available on
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Currently playing episode

Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes (Part 1)

We’ve Made a MistakeAug 17, 2022

00:00
01:01:07
Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes (Part 1)

Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes (Part 1)

In this week’s episode, Cathy and Sara return from a 6 month hiatus and share updates and how their lives have changed.
Aug 17, 202201:01:07
Dating & Relationship Dealbreakers

Dating & Relationship Dealbreakers

This week Cathy and Sara explore some of their dating and relationship dealbreakers.
Feb 08, 202201:26:02
Reddit and Weep

Reddit and Weep

This week Cathy and Sara share thoughts on their Reddit story top picks, ranging from sweet to sensational to the truly bizarre.
Jan 26, 202201:10:01
Cheers to the New Year

Cheers to the New Year

This week, Cathy and Sara discuss how they’ve celebrated the New Year and their outlook on 2022.
Jan 11, 202201:02:11
Sex & Relationship Taboos (Part 2)

Sex & Relationship Taboos (Part 2)

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their opinions on societal taboos surrounding sex and relationships. *Disclaimer: We discuss topics that may be triggering to some listeners. Discretion is advised.
Dec 28, 202101:00:43
Sex & Relationship Taboos (Part 1)

Sex & Relationship Taboos (Part 1)

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their opinions on societal taboos surrounding sex and relationships. *Disclaimer: We discuss topics that may be triggering to some listeners. Discretion is advised.
Nov 16, 202154:60
Dirty Little (Phone) Secrets

Dirty Little (Phone) Secrets

This week Cathy, Sara, and guest host Ashley discuss their most scandalous phone related experiences, including sketchy dating stories and the explanation behind some of the random pictures in their photo albums.
Oct 20, 202101:19:06
Tales of Toxicity (Part 2)

Tales of Toxicity (Part 2)

This week Cathy and Sara share stories that highlight their own self toxicities and how they’ve (mostly) overcome it.
Oct 05, 202101:07:55
Tales of Toxicity (Part 1)

Tales of Toxicity (Part 1)

This week Cathy and Sara share stories that highlight their own toxic relationship behaviors and how they’ve (mostly) overcome it.
Sep 07, 202101:25:13
Sexless and the City

Sexless and the City

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their hot takes on the iconic series “Sex and the City” as almost 30 year olds and how the lessons they’ve learned from the show informed their own lives.
Aug 24, 202101:09:08
There’s Something About Traditions

There’s Something About Traditions

This week Cathy and Sara take a deep dive into some of societies’ most questionable traditions, from Bachelorette party favors to sitting on Santa’s lap. *Disclaimer: We share primarily from a heterosexual perspective, which includes a heavy use of the word penis.
Aug 10, 202101:18:37
In Da Club

In Da Club

This week Cathy and Sara talk their most embarrassing club and going out stories, including being young and dumb in PB, their classy transition to North Park, and a how-to guide for clubbing as you approach 30.
Jul 20, 202101:29:04
(Im)Proper Etiquette

(Im)Proper Etiquette

During the season 2 premiere episode, Cathy and Sara discuss all things etiquette on topics such as workplace behavior, texting, and dating.
Jul 13, 202101:20:39
Everything but the Bagel SEASONing Finale (Part 2)

Everything but the Bagel SEASONing Finale (Part 2)

This week Cathy and Sara discuss listener questions and reflect on their favorite and most challenging moments from the season.
Jun 01, 202101:21:55
Everything but the Bagel SEASONing Finale (Part 1)

Everything but the Bagel SEASONing Finale (Part 1)

This week Cathy and Sara discuss how they have confronted fear throughout their podcast journey and during milestone moments in their life.
May 25, 202101:09:35
Dumb Shit We’ve Done (and Maybe Still Do)

Dumb Shit We’ve Done (and Maybe Still Do)

This week Cathy and Sara discuss embarrassing memories of dumb shit they’ve done, from childhood diaries to feeling young and invincible.
May 04, 202101:34:19
Living our Best Life?

Living our Best Life?

This week, Cathy and Sara envision what their best lives would look like if they lived to their fullest potential, from dream career to lifestyle and health.
Apr 27, 202101:16:01
Missed Connections and ‘What-Ifs’

Missed Connections and ‘What-Ifs’

This week Cathy and Sara highlight Craigslist missed connections stories, their personal ‘what-if’ experiences, and their thoughts on fate.
Apr 13, 202101:16:33
The Ridiculous World of the Rich and Famous

The Ridiculous World of the Rich and Famous

This week Cathy and Sara discuss the bizarre lives of the rich and famous, from celebrity dressing room demands to weird baby names.
Apr 07, 202157:37
Women and Society (Part 2)

Women and Society (Part 2)

Happy Women’s History Month! Cathy and Sara continue the conversation surrounding women and society. Episode topics include experiences with microaggressions and misogyny, celebrating badass women who have changed the world, and ways you can support and uplift women.
Mar 30, 202101:12:06
Women and Society (Part 1)

Women and Society (Part 1)

Happy Women’s History Month! This week Cathy and Sara discuss some of the societal pressures women face from a critical perspective. Episode topics include sexual violence, objectification, and body image, which may be triggering to some. Listener discretion is advised.
Mar 16, 202101:14:10
Would You Rather?

Would You Rather?

This week Cathy and Sara explore the interesting world of would you rather, debating everything from truly bizarre dating scenarios to existential life questions.
Mar 09, 202101:08:43
Unpopular Opinions

Unpopular Opinions

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their unpopular opinions on a variety of topics including lifestyle, cancel culture, and the legendarily bad band Nickelback.
Mar 02, 202101:44:06
The First Cut is the Deepest (Part 2)

The First Cut is the Deepest (Part 2)

Cathy, Sara, and guest host Ashley continue to discuss a myriad of funny firsts.
Feb 23, 202101:43:29
The First Cut is the Deepest (Part 1)

The First Cut is the Deepest (Part 1)

This week Cathy, Sara, and guest host Ashley discuss their first romantic experiences and the impression it’s made on their lives. Warning* This episode may not be suitable for children. Actually it’s definitely not.
Feb 09, 202101:10:52
Bad Habit Behavior

Bad Habit Behavior

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their funny, random, and toxic bad habits, and how indulging in these behaviors has impacted their experiences.
Feb 02, 202101:18:52
The One Where They Talk About Friendships

The One Where They Talk About Friendships

This week Cathy and Sara discuss their earliest friends, funny memories, perspectives on toxic relationships, and some of the mistakes they’ve made with friendships.
Jan 26, 202101:15:40
Between Birthdays

Between Birthdays

This week Cathy and Sara discuss some of their most memorable Birthdays, what has changed as they’ve aged, their expectations about getting older, and notable Birthday mistakes.
Jan 19, 202101:22:50
That Was Unexpected: Expectation vs Reality

That Was Unexpected: Expectation vs Reality

Cathy and Sara get candid about expectations they’ve had on a variety of topics from lifestyle to adulting and follow up with the unexpected reality of these experiences.
Jan 12, 202101:17:36
New Year, New Us (and Other Lies)

New Year, New Us (and Other Lies)

Join Cathy and Sara as they discuss the best and worst of 2020, resolutions for 2021, and dive into their mistakes from quarantine and New Year’s past.
Jan 05, 202101:07:44
High School Never Ends

High School Never Ends

This week Cathy and Sara discuss all things high school, from expectations to the awkward reality, their take on the school system, some best and worst memories, and lessons they’ve learned from their schooling experiences.
Dec 29, 202001:07:35
Merry Christmas Ya Filthy Animals

Merry Christmas Ya Filthy Animals

In this Christmas-themed episode, Cathy and Sara talk about their discovery of the real Santa, favorite traditions, the best and worst of Christmas, and what they’ve learned from common Christmas mistakes.
Dec 22, 202059:25
The Dating Episode

The Dating Episode

Cathy and Sara discuss the positives and pitfalls of modern dating, embarrassing anecdotes, and dating mistakes to avoid. **DISCLAIMER- We speak from our perspective as heterosexual cisgender women based on dating experiences in San Diego, CA.
Dec 15, 202001:05:14
Embarrassing Introductions

Embarrassing Introductions

Cathy and Sara discuss the "why" behind We've Made a Mistake and the struggles of creating a podcast while serving you some embarrassing secrets.
Dec 08, 202028:09
Welcome to We’ve Made a Mistake

Welcome to We’ve Made a Mistake

We’ve Made a Mistake is a weekly podcast in which hosts, Cathy and Sara, explore their past experiences on a range of topics in a way that humorously highlights their vulnerabilities. They drink a lot of cheap wine too. New episodes every Tuesday!
Dec 07, 202000:40