Skip to main content
Mysteries, Murders, Monsters, and Your Mom

Mysteries, Murders, Monsters, and Your Mom

By Julia and Nichole

True crime, conspiracy, paranormal, and all things strange and unusual. Hosted by moms! That's right moms! Because mom's can be weird too. Warning* this podcast and it's episodes therein discuss things of graphic nature, and will more often than not use vulgar language. So if you're sensitive to any of those things put on some armor or maybe just skip this one.

If you like what you hear please leave us a review on Apple Podcast, and follow us on Spotify.

Have a story of your own that you'd like to hear in a future episode? Email us at mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Listen on SpotifySend voice message
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Google Podcasts Logo
Pocket Casts Logo
RadioPublic Logo
Spotify Logo
Report content on Spotify
Currently playing episode

Ammons Hautning & Mona Lisa Mystery

Mysteries, Murders, Monsters, and Your MomOct 17, 2023

00:00
01:36:58
Ammons Hautning & Mona Lisa Mystery

Ammons Hautning & Mona Lisa Mystery

Today we start October with a story of a family haunted. Then we discuss the mystery behind the Mona Lisa.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Oct 17, 202301:36:58
Art & Murder: Caravaggio & Hollywood Ripper

Art & Murder: Caravaggio & Hollywood Ripper

This week we discuss the art of Caravaggio but also the man he murdered. Then we cover the case of what is known as the Hollywood Ripper.


LogoL Autumn Rumsey

Sep 17, 202301:25:09
History of Tarot

History of Tarot

Happy Labor Day! Today we are discussing the kinda confusing history of the now well beloved Tarot card.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Sep 04, 202359:19
Sausage Fest and Woman Hit By A Horse: Bohemian Club & Emily Davison

Sausage Fest and Woman Hit By A Horse: Bohemian Club & Emily Davison

Today's episode is a mix of crazy, conspiracy, and martyrdom. We discuss the Bohemian club and women's suffrage support Emily Davison.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Aug 20, 202352:59
Not A Lifetime Movie: Disappearance of Misty Cospey

Not A Lifetime Movie: Disappearance of Misty Cospey

Today's episode we go through all the twists and turns and very Lifetime Movie-esq drama behind the unsolved disappearance of Misty Cospey.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Jul 30, 202301:06:51
Haunted Statues & Cold Cases

Haunted Statues & Cold Cases

Today we discuss the statue known as "Black Aggie" and it being haunted. Then we discuss the cold case of the Kiddie Cabin Murders.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Jul 10, 202301:11:29
On The Road: Leah Roberts & "Bella"

On The Road: Leah Roberts & "Bella"

Welcome back! This week we cover the mystery behind missing persons case of Leah Roberts and the unsolved mystery asking the question who put Bella down the witch elm.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Jul 02, 202359:12
The short Episode: Frederich Valentich; Ghost Stories

The short Episode: Frederich Valentich; Ghost Stories

This week's episode is a quick one. We cover the disappearance of not-so-good pilot Frederich Valentich. Then we give you a few short ghost stories. Happy Memorial Day!


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

May 29, 202348:42
Legally Haunted: Ackley House & Disappearance of Glen & Bessie Hyde

Legally Haunted: Ackley House & Disappearance of Glen & Bessie Hyde

Happy Mother's Day!!! Today the Mom's discuss the story of the first and only legally haunted house in the US. And we explore the disappearance of married explorers Glen and Bessie Hyde.


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

May 14, 202301:10:35
Missing/Murdered Indigenous Woman

Missing/Murdered Indigenous Woman

In honor of May 5th we are discussing Indigenous Woman who have been either murdered or are missing, and the lack of data concerning this.




May 08, 202301:29:32
Live From MU It's...Us.

Live From MU It's...Us.

Our very first live recording held at Mansfield University! This week we discuss the case of Gabby Petito, we go through the details of her murder, there

aftermath, and why this case matters. Didn't make this live recording no worries we will be doing another in the future so stay tuned!

Thanks to the Mansfield Women*s Center for hosting us!


Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Apr 02, 202301:10:49
Black Widow & Amie Harwick

Black Widow & Amie Harwick

This weeks episode comes with a double TRIGGER WARNING!  Both episodes discuss domestic violence and assault.

The first story this week is about Lena Thompson aka Black Widow (not the Marvel character) and her swindling schemes.

The second we discuss the life and murder of Dr Amie Harwick.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey 


Mar 05, 202301:22:28
The Most Hated Woman In America: Zack & Addie, Madalyn Murray O'Hair

The Most Hated Woman In America: Zack & Addie, Madalyn Murray O'Hair

This week we discuss a case of murder/suicide from New Orleans Zack & Addie.  (Don't eat and listen).  Then we discuss a woman who did some cool things, but maybe wasn't that cool Madalyn Murray O'Hair.  Also the last 20 minutes is us discussing movies and the future of the DC movie universe.  Just fair warning.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Feb 26, 202301:11:45
Vatican Girl

Vatican Girl

This week we discuss the still unsolved case of the girl who is now known as the "Vatican Girl", Emanuela Orlandi.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey

Feb 21, 202301:22:34
Martin Luther King Jr: Pt2

Martin Luther King Jr: Pt2

Today is the second part of our two part series on the assassination of Dr Martin Luther King Jr. If you haven't already, be sure to catch up and listen to part 1.
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Feb 05, 202301:10:52
Martin Luther King Jr: Part 1

Martin Luther King Jr: Part 1

This week we start part one of a two series episode focusing on the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. This is a deeper dive into that day in Memphis and all the circumstances surrounding his death, and the civil trail that took place in 1998 where more light was shed on the events of that day.
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Jan 30, 202301:22:54
Occutist #2: Helena Blavatsky

Occutist #2: Helena Blavatsky

Today we continue our journey with the occult and discuss the very travel filled life of Helena Blavatsky.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Jan 16, 202339:42
Aleister Crowley & Fairy Coffins Scotland

Aleister Crowley & Fairy Coffins Scotland

After many mentions in previous episodes we finally discuss the man, Aleister Crowley. Then we discuss the mystery behind Scotlands tiny coffins.
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Jan 08, 202301:51:02
Phantom Time Hypothesis

Phantom Time Hypothesis

This week we discuss the conspiracy and arguments regarding the "missing" time. If you've seen the tik Tok about a week missing in the calendar then you know what this is.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Dec 20, 202201:21:31
The Exorcist Curse & Update Delphi Murders

The Exorcist Curse & Update Delphi Murders

For this Sunday service with the Moms we discuss the happenings during the filming of the classic horror movie The Exorcist. Then we discuss the updates and recent breakthrough of the Delphi Murders Case.
Dec 04, 202201:17:54
Wendigo-Lore& WitchesVillage

Wendigo-Lore& WitchesVillage

Today's episode we cover the folklore, history, and metaphors of the creature known as the Wendigo. Then we travel to Spain and cover the village excommunicated and cursed by the Catholic Church.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Get the shirt Nichole mentions at www.twistedgorilla.com use code mysterymompodcast at checkout
Nov 15, 202259:06
Halloween Pt 2: Amityville House Murders & Haunting

Halloween Pt 2: Amityville House Murders & Haunting

Although it's the day after Halloween, oops, we still have our part 2 Halloween episode. To conclude our Warren themed October we end at the most infamous case dubbed The Amityville Horror. We cover both the DeFeo murders, conspiracy, and the experience of the Lutz Family.
Nov 01, 202201:10:44
Halloween Pt 1: Elisa Lam

Halloween Pt 1: Elisa Lam

Part one of our two part Halloween episode we dive into the mystery and conspiracy behind the death of Cecil Hotel patron Elisa Lam.
Oct 30, 202201:07:03
Serial Spooks: Smurl Family & Night Stalker

Serial Spooks: Smurl Family & Night Stalker

Our second October episode we discuss our first Warren case and cover the Smurl family haunting. Our next Cecil Hotel case covers 2 serial killers including The Night Stalker.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Oct 23, 202201:35:57
Halloween the Beginning: Cecil Hotel & Ed/Lorraine Warren

Halloween the Beginning: Cecil Hotel & Ed/Lorraine Warren

Welcome to Halloween/spooky season aka October!! This episode we introduce you to the stories we will be telling for the rest of the month. First Nichole discusses the Cecil Hotel and the tragic end of "Pigeon Goldie". Second Julia give you the background of Ed and Lorraine Warren as a prequel for the stories that will follow. We also open with a listener story!

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Affilate: www.twistedgorilla.com code: mysterymom 15% off
Oct 02, 202201:09:00
The Lost Girls: Lisa Holm & Monique Daniels

The Lost Girls: Lisa Holm & Monique Daniels

This Sunday episode is another missing story of two missing girls.  One solved one not.  First is the story of the murder of a girl from Sweden named Lisa Holm.  The second is a still missing person, and totally suspect case, of Monique Daniels.   Logo: Autumn Rumsey Affiliate Link: mysterymom 15% mercy as www.twistedgorilla.com Instagram & Facebook: 4mpodcast Tic Tok: mysterymompodcast Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Sep 26, 202201:00:07
Sad Sunday Stories: Maria Blee & Nettie Fornario

Sad Sunday Stories: Maria Blee & Nettie Fornario

Today's stories are a double whammy of sad. First we discuss the disappearance and lack of investigation of Maria Blee. The second is a story about a suspicious death of Nettie Fornario.
Affiliate code: www.twistedgorilla.com mysterymom for 15% off
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Tik Tok: mysterymompodcast
Sep 11, 202246:37
Playmates to Popes; Dorothy Stratten & Pope Joan

Playmates to Popes; Dorothy Stratten & Pope Joan

Checkout Twisted Gorilla use code: mysterymom for 15% off your purchase!
Today's episode we discuss the murder of Playmate Dorothy Stratten and we discuss to possible only woman Pope, named Pope Joan.
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Tik Tok: Mysterymompodcast
Instagram: 4mpodcast
Sep 04, 202201:09:12
Brandon Swanson & New Orlean Vampire

Brandon Swanson & New Orlean Vampire

Today's episode we discuss the case of Brandon Swanson who disappeared without a trace. The second story we cover is the Count of St Germain who is possibly a vampire.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Aug 28, 202258:09
Cult House/Devil’s Road & Dorothy Kilgallen

Cult House/Devil’s Road & Dorothy Kilgallen

Today we discuss superstitious legends from PA of the Cult House on Devi's Road. The second story is true story part conspiracy about journalist Dorothy Kilgallen what she accomplished and the questions to how she died.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Aug 16, 202201:20:40
The Happy Face Killer, & Gates To Hell

The Happy Face Killer, & Gates To Hell

After a quick break the moms return with two new stories. The first covers the serial killer who became dubbed the "Happy Face Killer." The second story takes a trip around the world to deliver tales of so-called gates that lead straight into Hell.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Aug 01, 202253:11
Conspiracy Corner: The Oakville Blobs & The Georgia Guidestone

Conspiracy Corner: The Oakville Blobs & The Georgia Guidestone

Today's episode we discuss the phenomenon and conspiracies of what is now known as the Oakville Blobs. Then we keep the conspiracy going with the story of the Georgia Guidestones and their current condition.
Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Instagram/Facebook: 4mpodcast
Tik Tok: MysteryMomPodcast
Jul 11, 202201:12:27
Happy Pride!! The Doodler & Los Feliz Murder Mansion

Happy Pride!! The Doodler & Los Feliz Murder Mansion

Happy pride month! For this episode Nichole found a true crime, which is kinda solved but not, that even she hadn't heard. The first story is about the serial killer dubbed "The Doodler" (yes we laughed too). The second story we have Julia's 3rd house story (it's becoming a thing) about the mysteries surrounding the house now known as the Los Feliz Murder Mansion.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Jun 26, 202201:04:15
Springfield 3 & The Shining

Springfield 3 & The Shining

Today's episode we discuss the case of what is known as the Springfield 3 or 3 women who went vanished without a trace. The second is a discussion to the conspiracy theories behind the movie The Shining.

Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Jun 06, 202201:12:55
Lake Bodom Murders

Lake Bodom Murders

Today's episode is a one story episode. Which doesn't usually happen, but we will explain. Both Mom's discuss the infamous and unsolved case of Finland's Lake Bodom Murders.
May 29, 202201:10:06
Happy Mother’s Day: Giulia Tofana & Leonarda Cianciulli

Happy Mother’s Day: Giulia Tofana & Leonarda Cianciulli

Happy Mother's Day!!! Today we bring you stories of two mothers. The first is Giulia Tofana who's accused of poisoning and killing 600 men. The second is Leonarda who killed women and made them into soap to save her son.
We want to say thank you to all our Momsters for supporting us and for taking care of business everyday!
May 08, 202242:11
Conspiracy Episode: D.B. Cooper & Marilyn (Again)

Conspiracy Episode: D.B. Cooper & Marilyn (Again)

This episode is gonna be a long one! Today we cover two conspiracies. The now legendary tale of D.B Cooper and who he could be. Then we re-visit the case of Marilyn Monroe thanks to the new Netflix documentary.
May 01, 202201:51:44
Vampires & Conspiracies: Casket Girl & Ray Gricar

Vampires & Conspiracies: Casket Girl & Ray Gricar

Welcome back! To you and us. Sorry for the delay in episodes. Today we discuss the Casket Girls who became known as vampires...kind of. The second story covers the conspiracy and disappearance of Pennsylvania DA Ray Gricar.
Apr 24, 202201:25:15
Metal, Mayhem, and Leprechauns: Black Metal Murders & Leprechaun Legends

Metal, Mayhem, and Leprechauns: Black Metal Murders & Leprechaun Legends

Welcome back!  Today we discuss the Norwegian black metal band Mayhem and their crazy ride and destruction.  Then in honor of St Patrick's Day we discuss the history and legend of Leprechauns.   Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com Instagram & Facebook@ 4Mpodcast Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey
Mar 27, 202201:20:30
Girls Just Wanna: Nellie Maddison, & Elizabeth Bathory

Girls Just Wanna: Nellie Maddison, & Elizabeth Bathory

In today's episode we look at multifaceted women. One good, and one bad. The first is the story of Nellie May Maddison accused of killing her husband. The second story is the "blood Countess" Elizabeth Bathory.

Logo: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Mar 13, 202201:13:19
Witches & Triangles: History of Witch Trials & Bennington Triangle

Witches & Triangles: History of Witch Trials & Bennington Triangle

Today we honor Women's history month with re-visiting the witch trials that took place throughout the world. Then we visit New England to discuss the odd disappearances happening in the dubbed "Bennington Triangle."
Mar 07, 202201:16:26
Haunted Homicide/Sodder Children

Haunted Homicide/Sodder Children

Today's episode we cover the murders and hauntings of Fox Hollow Farm, as well as the mystery of the Sodder Children.
Feb 27, 202201:22:36
Urban Mandala Effect Legend: The Mandala Effect and Urban Legend

Urban Mandala Effect Legend: The Mandala Effect and Urban Legend

This week we discuss the theories behind the Mandala Effect and explore examples. As well as going into the origin of the Urban Legend of the Babysitter. Grab a drink and join the Mom's for another fun episode!

Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey
Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com
Feb 20, 202201:10:35
Valentines From Your Moms: History of Valentines Day & Lovers Lane Murders

Valentines From Your Moms: History of Valentines Day & Lovers Lane Murders

Welcome to our new host site! Today's episode, which is a few days late...but what can ya do, in honor of Valentines Day we discuss the weird history of the holiday and the Lovers Lane Murders.
Feb 18, 202201:03:01
Bourbon Catacombs: Bardstown Murders & Paris Catacombs

Bourbon Catacombs: Bardstown Murders & Paris Catacombs

In our fun with audio episode we cover the unsolved murders (yes plural) of Bardstown Kentucky.  As well as the history and creepy stories of the Paris Catacombs.  

Intro Audio: Emmie Reese

Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey

Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com

Instagram & Facebook: 4mpodcast

Be sure to rate us, like, and share with your friends.

Feb 06, 202201:32:49
Bourbon Catacombs: Bardstown Murders & Paris Catacombs

Bourbon Catacombs: Bardstown Murders & Paris Catacombs

In our fun with audio episode we cover the unsolved murders (yes plural) of Bardstown Kentucky. As well as the history and creepy stories of the Paris Catacombs. Intro Audio: Emmie Reese Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com Instagram & Facebook: 4mpodcast Be sure to rate us, like, and share with your friends. --- This episode is sponsored by · Anchor: The easiest way to make a podcast. https://anchor.fm/app --- Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/4mpodcast/message
Feb 06, 202201:33:38
Glows In the Dark: Radium Girls & Arlis Perry

Glows In the Dark: Radium Girls & Arlis Perry

Season 2, Episode 2, of 2022!  Whoooo!!!  Today's episode we discuss the story of the women who became known as the "Radium Girls" and we cover the SOLVED mystery of the murder of Stanford University student Arlis Perry.  Both are tragic stories, but have semi-happy endings.  


Intro Audio: Emmie Reese

Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey

Instagram & Facebook: 4mpodcast

Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com

Jan 23, 202201:05:44
Glows In the Dark: Radium Girls & Arlis Perry

Glows In the Dark: Radium Girls & Arlis Perry

Season 2, Episode 2, of 2022! Whoooo!!! Today's episode we discuss the story of the women who became known as the "Radium Girls" and we cover the SOLVED mystery of the murder of Stanford University student Arlis Perry. Both are tragic stories, but have semi-happy endings. Intro Audio: Emmie Reese Logo Design: Autumn Rumsey Instagram & Facebook: 4mpodcast Email: mysterymompodcast@gmail.com --- This episode is sponsored by · Anchor: The easiest way to make a podcast. https://anchor.fm/app --- Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/4mpodcast/message
Jan 23, 202201:06:33
Gigas-ity Gigas-ity (IYKYK) Season 2

Gigas-ity Gigas-ity (IYKYK) Season 2

Welcome to our first episode of 2022 and Season 2!  Thank you for helping us get this far!  In today's episode we cover The Codex Gigas AKA the Devils Bible and the case of the Route 29 Stalker.  

Jan 11, 202201:10:52
Gigas-ity Gigas-ity (IYKYK) Season 2

Gigas-ity Gigas-ity (IYKYK) Season 2

Welcome to our first episode of 2022 and Season 2! Thank you for helping us get this far! In today's episode we cover The Codex Gigas AKA the Devils Bible and the case of the Route 29 Stalker.

---

This episode is sponsored by
· Anchor: The easiest way to make a podcast. anchor.fm/app

---

Send in a voice message: anchor.fm/4mpodcast/message
Jan 11, 202201:11:41