Skip to main content
The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime Podcast

By Talysa Iannello

Two moms, running complete shit shows, talking about everyone’s favorite subject - true crime!!
Listen on SpotifySend voice message
Available on
Apple Podcasts Logo
Spotify Logo
Report content on Spotify
Currently playing episode

23. Black Widow Tillie Klimek & Gary Hilton

The Shit Show: A Half Assed True Crime PodcastAug 28, 2020

00:00
01:30:23
23. Black Widow Tillie Klimek & Gary Hilton

23. Black Widow Tillie Klimek & Gary Hilton

This week, Sarah covers the lady who hated Joe's, Tillie Klemek. Talysa tells us abou the National Forest Serial Killer, Gary Hilton. He sucks.

Make sure you check our merch store out!
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG

Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Aug 28, 202001:30:23
Quicky 13. The Murder of Robert Kidney

Quicky 13. The Murder of Robert Kidney

In this weeks Quicky, Sarah tells us about the Old Timey murder of Robert Kidney

Make sure you check our merch store out!
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG
Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Aug 26, 202025:30
Quicky 12. The Craigslist Killer

Quicky 12. The Craigslist Killer

In this weeks Quicky, Talysa covers Philip Haynes Markoff, The Craigslist Killer.
***NOW THROUGH AUGUST 24TH, GET 15% OFF OUR MERCH***
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG
Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Aug 21, 202021:22
22. The Unsolved Murder of Garrett Phillips and Serial Killer Pamela Worms

22. The Unsolved Murder of Garrett Phillips and Serial Killer Pamela Worms

In this weeks episode, Talysa covers the heart breaking murder of Garrett Phillips and the story of how the police department had tunnel vision. Everyone go watch "Who Killed Garrett Phillips" on HBO. Then Sarah covers the Old Timey serial killer Pamela Worms. I bet the people of Wales won't claim her.

The potsdam police Dept is still in control of any investigations so any tips can go to them at Phone: 315-265-2121

New York State Crime Stoppers | 24/7 Hotline: (866) 313-TIPS (8477)

***NOW THROUGH AUGUST 24TH, GET 15% OFF OUR MERCH***
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG
Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Aug 19, 202001:41:23
Quicky 11. The Mysterious Death of SGT. Patrick Rust

Quicky 11. The Mysterious Death of SGT. Patrick Rust

In this weeks Quicky, Sarah tells us about a soldier who died in Upstate NY and no one knows what happened. •If you or anyone you may know has information on the disappearance and death of Sgt. Patrick Rust please contact the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office at 315-786-2676 or email at mailto:detectives@co.jefferson.ny.us
There is a facebook page set up called SGT Patrick Rust’s mysterious death

***NOW THROUGH AUGUST 24TH, GET 15% OFF OUR MERCH***
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG

Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp

Aug 14, 202027:06
21. Murders in Rome NY and John Jamelske

21. Murders in Rome NY and John Jamelske

This week Sarah covers the murders of Anne Boncella and her daughter, Crystal Nadeau and the murder of Patricia Woodruff. Talysa tells us about John Jamelske and his gross awful dungeon. That guy is so fucked.
***NOW THROUGH AUGUST 24TH, GET 15% OFF OUR MERCH***
50% OF ALL PROFITS THROUGH THE END OF SEPTEMBER 2020 WILL GO TO END THE BACKLOG

Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Aug 12, 202001:15:15
Quicky 10. The Oneida Community...Cult

Quicky 10. The Oneida Community...Cult

Aug 07, 202037:35
20. The Disappearance of Suzanne Lyall and the Murder of Cipriano Garcia

20. The Disappearance of Suzanne Lyall and the Murder of Cipriano Garcia

Talysa covers the unsolved disappearance of a college student in Albany NY. Sarah tells us about some shady shit going on in Indiana, proving no matter how much crime tv you watch, murder is still hard to cover up.
If you have any information on Suzannes disappearance please contact:

New York State Police - 519-783-3211


SUNY Albany Police Department - 518-442-3131

To stay anonymous - www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/suzanne-g.-lyall





Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp

Check our merch store out!: teespring.com/stores/the-shit-show-tcp


Aug 05, 202001:21:27
Quicky 9. The Mysterious Case of Lurancy Vennum

Quicky 9. The Mysterious Case of Lurancy Vennum

In this weeks Quicky, Sarah tells us about Lurancy Vennum. What caused her behavior?

Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Check our merch store out!: teespring.com/stores/the-shit-show-tcp
Jul 31, 202031:42
19. The Death of Molly Young and The Fall River Cult Murders

19. The Death of Molly Young and The Fall River Cult Murders

This week Sarah tells us about the death of Molly Young and how screwed up that case was. Talysa covers the Fall River Cult Murders, which was horrifying.
If you have ANY information in the case of Molly Young please contact the Illinois State Police at 618-542-1180
If you or someone you love s struggling with depression or suicidal thoughts PLEASE reach out!
The National Suicide Hotline is: 1-800-273-8255

Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Check our merch store out!: teespring.com/stores/the-shit-show-tcp
Jul 29, 202001:26:44
Quicky 8. Lizzie Halliday

Quicky 8. Lizzie Halliday

In this weeks quicky, Talysa covers the story about an Irish woman named Lizzie Halliday.
Find us everywhere through our Linktree: linktr.ee/shitshowtcp
Check our merch store out!: teespring.com/stores/the-shit-show-tcp
Jul 24, 202023:52
18. The Lady of the Dunes and Patricia Columbo

18. The Lady of the Dunes and Patricia Columbo

Jul 22, 202058:01
Quicky 7. The Murder of Jill-Lyn Euto

Quicky 7. The Murder of Jill-Lyn Euto

Jul 17, 202018:56
Welcome to The Shit Show - Trailer

Welcome to The Shit Show - Trailer

Jul 16, 202000:44
17. The Bennington Triangle and Ashley Reeves

17. The Bennington Triangle and Ashley Reeves

Jul 15, 202001:17:15
Quicky 6. The Disappearance of Ayla Reynolds

Quicky 6. The Disappearance of Ayla Reynolds

In this weeks quicky, Talysa lets us know about the disappearance of a 20 month old girl named Ayla in Waterville, Maine.
Waterville, ME crime tips form: www.waterville-me.gov/police/crime-tips/
Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit: (207) 624-7143
Crime Stoppers USA:

www.crimestoppersusa.org/
1-800-222-TIPS


Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Jul 10, 202025:01
16. Paula Sims and Pamela Smart

16. Paula Sims and Pamela Smart

Sarah talks about Paula Sims, and Talysa tells the story of Pamela Smart and the murder of her husband, Gregg Smart. 

Postpartum Support International: Available 24 hours a day

Find us everywhere:

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jul 08, 202001:33:38
Quicky 5. The Tragic Murders of Mike Morrison and Debbie Means

Quicky 5. The Tragic Murders of Mike Morrison and Debbie Means

In this weeks quicky, Sarah tells us about the murders of Mike Morrison and Debbie Means. 


Find us everywhere:

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jul 03, 202022:32
15. The Genessee River Killer and The Sausage Vat Murder

15. The Genessee River Killer and The Sausage Vat Murder

Episode 15! Talysa goes deep into the Genesee River Killer, Arthur Shawcross. Sarah talks about The Sausage Vat Murder, which is yucky. 

Trigger warning for child death, rape, cannibalism and everything gross, just a heads up. 

Find us everywhere:

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jul 01, 202001:35:43
Quicky 4. The Great Molasses Flood

Quicky 4. The Great Molasses Flood

We're switching up our Quicky Episodes! This week, Talysa talks about the Great Molasses Flood of Boston in 1919!

Find us everywhere: 

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/  

 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu 

 Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21   

 Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast   

 Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!    

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jun 26, 202019:58
14. Two Murders in Massachusetts and The Murder of Pravin Varughese

14. Two Murders in Massachusetts and The Murder of Pravin Varughese

Talysa talks about the Massachusetts abductions and murders of  Holly Piirainen and Molly Bish, and how they could be connected. Sarah talks about the senseless murder of Pravin Varughese, from Southern Illinois. 

Massachusetts State Police Tip Line at (508) 453-7575

Justiceforpravin.org

Find us everywhere: Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/  

 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu   

 Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21   

 Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast   

 Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!   

 Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jun 24, 202001:32:13
13. The Disappearance of Megan Paige Nichols And Terry Rasmussen

13. The Disappearance of Megan Paige Nichols And Terry Rasmussen

Sarah discusses the disappearance of a 15 year old girl from Illinois and Talysa covers Terry Rasmussen and the Bear Brook Barrel victims.
Find us everywhere: Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Jun 18, 202001:47:20
Quicky Episode 3!

Quicky Episode 3!

Weird Laws and historical facts! Talysa covers New Hampshire and Sarah is, once again, all over the place.
Find us everywhere: Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Jun 12, 202023:35
12. Lewis Lent and The Murder of Adrianne Reynolds

12. Lewis Lent and The Murder of Adrianne Reynolds

Talysa talks about the murder of James Bernardo and Sarah Woods at the hands of Lewis Lent, who should get the crotch lice. Sarah Tells about a teenage love triangle that ends in murder, and a Snapped episode.
Find us everywhere: Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us everywhere you listen to podcasts!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Jun 10, 202001:22:43
Quicky Episode 2: Weird laws from everywhere that Sarah has lived and Massachusetts

Quicky Episode 2: Weird laws from everywhere that Sarah has lived and Massachusetts

Weird laws, historical facts and town names!

Join us for an exclusive discussion with host @JoshMankiewicz about podcast Motive for Murder with Goodpods - the new podcast social network.   Search for Motive for Murder and submit your questions on the discussions tab before noon PDT June 10.    Get the link and add it to your calendar here:  https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_gKgBRZfyQ0-FSdJKckTD2w

Twitter: @goodpods

Insta:  @Goodpods

Find us everywhere: Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/   

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu   

Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21   

Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast 

 Find us on Spotify too!  

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

Jun 05, 202020:56
11. ADK Killer Robert Garrow and The Slaying of the Dardeen Family

11. ADK Killer Robert Garrow and The Slaying of the Dardeen Family

Talysa tells us about the Adirondack (spree? serial?) killer, Robert Garrow. Then Sarah lets us know about a terrible family slaying. *TRIGGER WARNING FOR CHILD DEATH*

  • Official George Floyd Memorial Fund: https://www.gofundme.com/f/georgefloyd
  •  Find us everywhere: Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/ 
  •  Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu 
  •  Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21  
  • Anchor: https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast  Find us on Spotify too! 
  • Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Jun 04, 202001:21:15
Quicky Episode 1: Shitty Weird Laws!

Quicky Episode 1: Shitty Weird Laws!

Shitty, weird laws from Maine and Illinois
Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us on Spotify too!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
May 28, 202012:17
10. The Grand River Hotel and Stacey Castor

10. The Grand River Hotel and Stacey Castor

Sarah goes old timey with the Grand River Hotel and Talysa talks about a black widow.
Find us everywhere: Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us on Spotify too!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
May 27, 202001:11:46
9. The Tragic Death of Anthony Tucker and the Crazy Story of Belle Gunness

9. The Tragic Death of Anthony Tucker and the Crazy Story of Belle Gunness

Talysa talks about the tragic death of Anthony Tucker, at the hands of his mother's boyfriend, Todd Curry. Sarah goes old timey and tells us about Belle Gunness!

National Domestic Abuse Hotline - 800-799-7233

Or you can chat with an advocate on the site TheHotline.Org - there’s a chat now button

National helpline for substance abuse and mental health support- 800-662-HELP


Find us everywhere: Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us on Spotify too!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
May 20, 202001:17:35
8. The Death of Mary Yoder and The New Bedford Highway Killer

8. The Death of Mary Yoder and The New Bedford Highway Killer

Sarah tells us about Mary Yoder and Talysa talks about the New Bedford Highway Killer AND The Main South Woodsman killings.
Near Death Dolls: anchor.fm/paige-law/episodes/Near-Death-Dolls-Trailer-eb90fr
Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/
Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu
Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21
Anchor: anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast
Find us on Spotify too!
Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
May 14, 202001:22:59
7. A Couple of the Worst Humans.

7. A Couple of the Worst Humans.

Talysa tells us about Kristen Gilbert the asshole nurse. Sarah talks about 16 year old, Christopher Churchill, who brutally murdered his brother, his fiancee and her children. Just literally a couple of the worst humans. 

Link to the Facebook page Sarah mentions: https://www.facebook.com/groups/728736263857150

Find us everywhere:

Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: https://twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

https://anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com

May 06, 202001:20:42
6. Doing Terrible Things For Money

6. Doing Terrible Things For Money

Episode 6! Sarah tells us about Dr. John Dale Cavaness and Talysa tells us about the Tri Willow Murders in Lee NY. Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 30, 202001:18:16
5. Boon Island cannibals and River Pirates

5. Boon Island cannibals and River Pirates

Talysa tells us about some guys who wreck their ship and turn to cannibalism and then Sarah tells us about some river pirates and serial killers. Shout out to So You Want Me To Believe Podcast! Find them at: linktr.ee/sywmtbpod

Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 24, 202001:19:27
4. That Asshole, Whitey Bulger.

4. That Asshole, Whitey Bulger.

In part two of our old timey gangster stories, Talysa talks about Whitey Bulger. And we also briefly talk about Tiger King.

Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 16, 202001:20:24
3. Gangster Shit

3. Gangster Shit

In part one of our old timey gang coverage, Sarah tells us about the Shelton Brothers Gang from Peoria IL.

Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 16, 202056:15
2. Witchy Women

2. Witchy Women

Join us for episode 2! We're chatting about some witchy legends...

Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 08, 202049:46
1. Florida Mans

1. Florida Mans

Our first episode!! Join us for some Florida Man headlines! If the audio is a little shitty, please forgive us, we're recording remotely due to COVID 19!

Find us everywhere:
Facebook: m.facebook.com/TheShitShowtcp/

Instagram: www.instagram.com/p/B_W_C1opsae/?igshid=2cl7vkuzo5bu

Twitter: twitter.com/theshitshowtcp/status/1253658085916389380?s=21

anchor.fm/shitshowtruecrimepodcast

Send an email: shitshowtcp@gmail.com
Apr 03, 202039:47